Richard Scruggs, Paul Leonard
Nicole LaCour Young / AP
Attorney Richard 'Dickie' Scruggs, left, and his client Paul Leonard joke with reporters outside the federal courthouse in Gulfport, Miss., Monday. Leonard is suing Nationwide insurance company over damages from Hurricane Katrina in the first such case to reach trial.
updated 7/10/2006 7:57:10 PM ET 2006-07-10T23:57:10

A federal judge Monday began hearing a groundbreaking trial that could signal whether thousands of people whose homes were destroyed by Hurricane Katrina can receive payouts for losses their insurance companies claim were caused by flooding.

Attorneys for Paul and Julie Leonard claim the couple was misled by their insurance agent and then denied much of their claim for their Pascagoula home without a full review of the facts.

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. argues that while wind damage is covered by its homeowners’ policies, damage from flooding is excluded, including Katrina’s wind-driven storm surge.

The trial, being heard without a jury by U.S. District Judge L. T. Senter Jr., is the first among hundreds of lawsuits that have been filed by Gulf Coast homeowners challenging insurance companies over the wind-verses-water issue. Plaintiffs’ attorneys hope a ruling in the homeowners’ favor would pressure insurance companies to pay out hundreds of millions of dollars in settlements for homeowners whose claims have been rejected.

Paul Leonard asked a Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. agent in 1999 if he should get flood coverage. “You don’t need that,” the agent replied, according to one of the Leonards’ lawyers.

The agent did not want to write a flood policy “because he didn’t make much money off of it,” attorney Zach Scruggs said in opening statements.

Scruggs and his father, Richard “Dickie” Scruggs, represent about 3,000 policyholders on Mississippi’s Gulf Coast. Their law firm also has filed suits against other insurers, including Allstate Insurance Co., Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., State Farm Insurance Cos. and United Services Automobile Association.

Zach Scruggs said Nationwide paid $1,600 to the Leonards for $130,000 worth of damage to their home, several hundred yards from the Mississippi Sound near the eastern end of the state’s shoreline. He said that was $500 less than the premiums the family paid to Nationwide that year.

“Nationwide actually made money off the Leonards as a result of Hurricane Katrina,” he said.

Dan Attridge, an attorney for the Columbus, Ohio-based company, said evidence would show the company “has fully complied with its obligations.” He said the agent never told Leonard that flood damage was covered by his policy or that he did not need flood insurance.

Leonard, the first witness, said that before Katrina, he had “always considered flood as coming from a river. Storm surge doesn’t happen unless there’s a hurricane.”

Under questioning by the insurance company’s attorney, Leonard said he did not need separate flood coverage because his agent “explained I had hurricane coverage.”

Asked if the agent had explained why he did not need flood insurance, Leonard responded: “No, sir. I always had a hurricane policy. Why would I need flood on top of hurricane (coverage)?”

The first floor of the Leonard home received five feet of water during the hurricane, forcing the family to live on the second floor during repairs. Leonard said he has spent $30,000 of his own money on repairs, clothing and other needs since Katina.

Zach Scruggs said weather data shows Katrina’s 140 mph wind hit the Mississippi coast three hours before any storm surge flooding. He said Nationwide’s experts ignored that evidence and wrongly blamed water for the vast majority of the damage to the Leonards’ house.

Attridge said Nationwide has paid out $230 million for 21,000 claims in Mississippi since Katrina and an additional $220 million for its handling of 1,800 flood insurance claims under the National Flood Insurance Program.

Richard Scruggs said it was too early to discuss the case’s effect on other claims.

“A journey of a thousand miles begins with one step, and this is the first step,” he said. “It’s one case. If you win it, it’s a huge win. If you lose it, you spin it the best way you can.”

Nationwide spokesman Joe Case said the company looks “at each claim on a case-by-case basis.”

© 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Insurance struggle goes to court


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

Data: Latest rates in the US

Home equity rates View rates in your area
Home equity type Today +/- Chart
$30K HELOC FICO 3.79%
$30K home equity loan FICO 4.99%
$75K home equity loan FICO 4.69%
Credit card rates View more rates
Card type Today +/- Last Week
Low Interest Cards 13.83%
Cash Back Cards 17.80%
Rewards Cards 17.18%