Skip navigation

Basra clashes test al-Maliki’s government

Opinion: Securing the port city is critical for the health of all of Iraq

Mahdi Army fighters take positions in Basra, Iraq, Friday, March 28, 2008. Shiite militants clashed with government forces for a fourth day in Iraq's oil-rich south and sporadic fighting broke out in Baghdad, despite a weekend curfew in the capital.
Nabil Al-jurani / AP
  Most Popular
Most viewed

Lt. Col. Rick Francona
Military analyst

The clashes in the southern Iraqi oil and port city of Basra pose the first real test of the viability of Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki’s government.  The situation in Basra has spiraled out of control in the past few months following the withdrawal of British troops and the turnover of the city to Iraqi security forces.  The local Iraqi security forces, overwhelmingly Shiite, have proven incapable of controlling the competition among rival Shiite groups for control of the lucrative oil and port industries.

Security in Basra is a critical issue for the new country and its struggling economy because almost 80 percent of Iraqi’s oil fields are located in the Basra area and exported via the port. The port on Iraq’s miniscule coastline is the country’s major import facility and serves as an economic lifeline. Faced with the abysmal security situation, al-Maliki ordered the Iraqi army last week into the city to quell the violence.

This deployment presents a unique challenge for the army and for the al-Maliki government.  Since both organizations are predominantly Shiite, there has always been a question as to how the government would handle these types of Shiite issues. There is a perception among Sunnis and Kurds that al-Maliki has turned a blind eye to past Shiite indiscretions, particularly those of radical Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr and his jaysh al-mahdi (Mahdi Army) militia. The fact that al-Sadr’s militia is still the primary force in Sadr City and wields great influence in the Shiite southern part of the country is a testament to the failure of the al-Maliki government to control the Shiite cleric.

Order to intervene set up a power struggle
Al-Maliki’s order for the army to intervene in Basra has set up a power struggle between the government and al-Sadr. Which one emerges as the victor has huge ramifications for the future of the ethnically and religiously diverse country. Al-Sadr envisions himself as the future leader of Iraq and does not want to suffer a political defeat at the hands of al-Maliki’s government.

He has mobilized his followers in Sadr City, the Shiite stronghold in Baghdad, calling for “civil strikes” against the government.  Whether by design or not, these “civil strikes” have manifested themselves as daily rocket and mortar attacks on the Green Zone, the center of the Iraqi government, the American Embassy and U.S. military headquarters.  If these attacks are not sanctioned by al-Sadr, one could draw the conclusion that he is losing control of his subordinates.

The confrontation in Basra is being watched all over the country, particularly in the Sunni Arab areas.  The Sunnis, keenly aware of the Shiite dominance over the government and security forces, are looking to see if al-Maliki is willing to fight his Shiite brethren, and what effect that inter-Shiite struggle will have on the army and police.

It is absolutely essential that the government prevail in this fight, not just because of the importance of Basra, but because of the symbolism of a Shiite-led Iraqi government willing to take on rogue Shiite elements. Al-Maliki realizes the stakes and that is why he has gone to Basra to personally oversee the military operation. 

If the al-Maliki government cannot  or will not  act decisively against fellow Shiite in Basra, it will by difficult for them to solve the al-Qaida problem in Mosul or the ethnic diversity, Kurd-Turkmen-Arab, issue in Kirkuk. This may be al-Maliki’s defining moment.

© 2013 msnbc.com Reprints

Sponsored links

Resource guide