Image: Sharpie plant
Bill Waugh  /  AP
Because of high resin costs, Rubbermaid is going to simply quit making some of it's products — excluding the Sharpie pen.
updated 9/4/2008 2:49:16 PM ET 2008-09-04T18:49:16

Conventional wisdom had long held that some industries would collapse if oil topped $100 a barrel. As oil neared $150, sending costs higher for everything from jet fuel to plastic jars, the question was how many companies would succumb.

The surprising answer: Not many. Some have even thrived.

Companies have culled unprofitable products, cut production costs and passed along price increases. Airlines have laid off thousands of employees, dropped routes, sold planes and raised fares 20 percent in the last year — the fastest rate of increase in 15 years. Consumer product makers have shrunk everything from tubs of Smart Balance Buttery Spread to jugs of laundry detergent. Retailers from The Yankee Candle Co. Inc. to Target Corp. have passed on higher prices to consumers.

"We are squeezing every dollar out of our working capital," said James Craigie, chairman and chief executive of Church & Dwight Co., on the company's second-quarter earnings call in August. Sales have increased 50 percent over the last four years at the company, which makes detergent, toothpaste and Arm & Hammer baking soda, but the number of employees has stayed flat, at 3,700, Craigie said.

With oil prices roughly twice what they were in January 2007, many companies have simply adjusted. Now that oil's daily price swings are moving down as well as up, that preparation has put them in a strong position — leaner than they've been in years, with customers paying higher prices.

Of course, the adjustment hasn't been smooth.

Consumer inflation is the highest in 17 years, up 5.6 percent this year and unemployment is at a four-year high. Workers are doing more, without earning more: Productivity, the output for every hour of work, jumped 4.3 percent at an annual rate in the April-June quarter, while labor costs fell.

The auto industry has been hammered as gasoline prices climbed roughly $1.30 a gallon since the beginning of 2007. Higher prices for gas and food crimped consumer spending and slammed department stores and restaurants. Every penny increase for a gallon of gas equals more than $1 billion in consumer spending over a year, according to Citigroup Inc. Business bankruptcies are higher than they were a year ago, soaring in industries like trucking, which have excess capacity and are unable to pass on higher costs.

But many businesses have proved resilient. A surge in exports thanks to the weak dollar helped, but so have price increases and cost-cutting.

Underwear company Maidenform Brands Inc. said on its second-quarter earnings call in August that it had been able to offset all the fuel surcharges it received in 2008.

"In 2009, we're going to have to work harder," said Chris Vieth, the company's chief operating officer and chief financial officer.

To that end, Vieth said the company had a team looking for new factories to work with in Vietnam and Thailand. It's also finding lower cost materials.

Craigie at Church & Dwight reminded investors on the company's quarterly earnings call in early August that management had made a promise, when oil was less than $100 a barrel, to add 1 percent to gross margins.

"We will still deliver on our objective despite higher oil prices," he said.

The company has raised prices on 30 percent of its products. At the same time, it kept a lid on costs. Condensing laundry detergent and shipping it in smaller packages saved so much money, the change more than offset rising commodity costs.

As a result, Church & Dwight added 1.1 percent to its second-quarter gross margin, while net income increased 13 percent, from $40.5 million for the year ago quarter to $45.8 million.

At Newell Rubbermaid Inc., where resin prices are one-tenth the cost of goods, oil's runup could have been disastrous.

"When I found myself looking at the price of oil several times a day, it was too much," CEO Mark Ketchum said. "That's not the way a CEO or any member of management is going to build shareholder value."

Rubbermaid had already restructured, winnowing 40 percent of its product line between 2003 and 2004. As oil rose, management scrutinized the 12 percent of "commodity-like" products it had kept.

The products, including plastic shelving and its cheapest storage containers, had one thing in common: Resin was somewhere between one-third to one-half the cost of sales.

"We couldn't sell it for what it cost to make it," said spokesman David Doolittle.

Its cheapest clear plastic storage bins, which hold Christmas tree ornaments or sweaters and are pulled out of a closet twice a year, no longer made economic sense, Ketchum said.

"Resin is never going to be a cheap alternative; those may go back to cardboard boxes," he said.

In contrast, the company kept its Roughneck containers, meant for hard use, like recycling bins.

"The consumer is willing to pay a price because they know they're going to beat the heck out of them," he said.

Rubbermaid hasn't released a list of products it will drop, but it has said it will keep making Sharpie pens, Rubbermaid food storage products and Graco car seats, where resin is only 2 to 15 percent of total costs. Higher resin costs would increase those prices slightly, between 1 and 5 percent a year. In contrast, the company raised prices for some of its products as much as 22 percent this year.

Once Rubbermaid has whittled its product line, $500 million of the company's $6.5 billion sales will be gone, but Ketchum expects margins to rise.

In the process, the company will trim the 700 million pounds of resin it buys each year by 280 million pounds. It will also change how its CEO spends his days.

On Rubbermaid's earnings call, Ketchum said, "I expect to spend one-tenth as much time talking about resin next year, even if it continues to rise."

Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Discussion comments


Data: Latest rates in the US

Home equity rates View rates in your area
Home equity type Today +/- Chart
$30K HELOC FICO 3.79%
$30K home equity loan FICO 4.99%
$75K home equity loan FICO 4.69%
Credit card rates View more rates
Card type Today +/- Last Week
Low Interest Cards 13.83%
Cash Back Cards 17.80%
Rewards Cards 17.18%