Image: Elizabeth Smart and father
Matt Cilley  /  AP
Ed Smart, walking with his daughter Elizabeth Smart at the White House in 2003, said Friday he's horrified by the parallels between the case of Jaycee Lee Dugard and his daughter's nine-month captivity with an alleged kidnapper in 2003.
updated 8/29/2009 10:23:46 PM ET 2009-08-30T02:23:46

The Utah father of Elizabeth Smart said he's horrified by the parallels between the latest abduction story to grip the nation and his own daughter's long journey with an alleged kidnapper.

Snatched at knifepoint from her bedroom in Salt Lake City, then 14-year-old Elizabeth Smart was kept by a street preacher for nine months in 2002 and 2003 as he drifted around, wintering at a homeless camp near San Diego, Calif., prosecutors say.

She was spotted walking along a busy street in a Salt Lake City suburb in March 2003 with her alleged captors, all dressed in robes. Her father reunited with her at a police station. At home, she had to adjust to her lost family.

"I remember the day Elizabeth was found, how wonderful that was. There are a lot of concerns about how we would move forward, and she's done just amazingly well," Ed Smart told AP Radio on Friday.

Like Jaycee Lee Dugard, found this week after an abduction that lasted nearly two decades, the suspect's wife was apparently complicit in the alleged crime.

In both cases, the accused abductor seems to have been motivated by religious extremism, Ed Smart said.

"It makes you angry that anyone would use God as an excuse to rationalize their predatory behavior," he said.

His reaction: 'Another miracle'
He said he had one reaction after hearing of Dugard's reunion with her family after being found in California this week.

"Another miracle. She survived 18 years and is now out of the hands of this monster. It's wonderful to hear of another rescue, another survival," he said.

Elizabeth Smart, 21, is studying for a music degree at Brigham Young University.

"A psychologist once said to me, 'It's really almost like being born again. You have to re-establish a bond with Elizabeth,'" her father said Friday. "Finding those things she loves and enjoys helps her move forward — finding things that will become her passion and allow her to put the past behind her."

The Smart case has taken a meandering, six-year journey in state courts with no resolution.

Brian David Mitchell and his wife, Wanda Barzee, have been deemed incompetent to stand trial. Both are being held indefinitely on multiple state charges, including kidnapping and sexual assault.

Mitchell was indicted by a federal grand jury in March 2008 on charges of kidnapping and unlawful transportation of a minor. Federal prosecutors hope to get a competency hearing sometime this fall.

Once told a judge to ‘repent’
Doctors have said Barzee, 63, claims to receive messages from God through her television and is delusional.

Mitchell, 55, has been diagnosed with another delusional disorder and has frequently disrupted court proceedings by singing hymns. He once yelled to a judge to "repent."

Dugard's alleged captors, 58-year-old Phillip Garrido and 54-year-old Nancy Garrido, pleaded not guilty Friday to a total of 29 counts, including forcible abduction, rape and false imprisonment. They allegedly kidnapped her from a street in South Lake Tahoe, Calif.

Police expanded the boundaries of the Dugard kidnapping crime scene to include the house next to Dugard's alleged abductors. Police on Saturday wrapped yellow crime scene tape around the home and property next to Garrido's Antioch home.

Police from three agencies have been searching the Garridos' property since they were arrested Wednesday.

Neighbors identified Damon Robinson as a resident of the house next to the Garridos. Robinson has said he lived there for more than three years and it was his then-girlfriend in 2006 who called police after she saw tents and children in the backyard.

'Horrible atrocity'
Ed Smart said he was baffled by reports that Phillip Garrido has a long rap sheet, including a conviction for kidnapping a 25-year-old woman in 1976.

"How many times is a person allowed to do such horrible atrocity and get away with it? I mean, it's just amazing," he said. "There isn't a way in the world that he should be let out again."

Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments