Image:
Pablo Martinez Monsivais  /  AP
Republicans wave copies of their health care bill in objection to President Barack Obama’s proposals Wednesday during a joint session of Congress. At one point, a Republican lawmaker shouted, ‘You lie!’ at Obama.
By M. Alex Johnson Reporter
msnbc.com
updated 9/9/2009 11:04:03 PM ET 2009-09-10T03:04:03

Declaring that he is determined to be the last president confronted with reshaping health care in America, President Barack Obama proposed a 10-year, $900 billion plan Wednesday night to overhaul a system that he said had left the country at “a breaking point.”

In a prime-time address to a joint session of Congress, Obama laid out the specifics of his proposal to change the way Americans’ medical care is paid for, responding to critics who have complained that he has not set forth precisely what he thinks the new program should be.

Obama outlined what he called the favored proposals of extremes on both sides of the health care debate: a single-payer system like Canada’s, in which the government provides coverage for everyone, and a dismantling of the employer-based system, leaving individuals to buy insurance on their own.

The president rejected both options, saying they would represent “a radical shift that would disrupt the health care most people currently have” — something that he said could not be allowed to happen. Instead, he charted a middle course on the most contentious issue of the entire debate — whether the government should directly pay for some Americans’ health insurance beyond the current Medicare and Medicaid programs.

  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California

While Obama strongly endorsed what has come to be known as the “public option,” he offered it as only a small component of a larger “insurance exchange” in which individual Americans and small businesses could pool their negotiating power to wrest better coverage and lower rates from private insurance companies.

“It would only be an option for those who don’t have insurance,” Obama said. “No one would be forced to choose it, and it would not impact those of you who already have insurance.”

And even then, he said that he would be open to alternatives as long as they accomplished the “ultimate goal” — ensuring coverage for uninsured Americans and promising “security and stability” for those who already have coverage.

That was not sufficient for Rep. Charles Boustany, R-La., who delivered the official Republican response .

“The president had a chance tonight to take government-run health care off the table. Unfortunately, he didn’t do it,” said Boustany, a cardiothoracic surgeon.

Obama: ‘Time for games has passed’
Obama’s address came against the background of harsh back and forth between proponents of competing health care proposals.

The president went out of his way to denounce the “scare tactics” of his opponents, which have included false claims that the government would convene panels to decide whether ill, elderly Americans should be forced to die.

In blunt language rarely heard from a president from the halls of Congress, Obama used words like “bogus,” “demagoguery” and “distortion.” He dismissed the death-panels claim as “a lie, plain and simple.”

And even as he declared that “the time for bickering is over” and that “the time for games has passed,” Obama took a strong swipe at his predecessor, President George W. Bush, in arguing that his proposal — whose price tag he himself put at $900 billion — would actually save money.

That bill would still be “less than we have spent on the Iraq and Afghanistan wars and less than the tax cuts for the wealthiest few Americans that Congress passed at the beginning of the previous administration,” he said.

Without naming Bush, Obama blamed his administration for bequeathing him “a trillion-dollar deficit when I walked in the door of the White House ... because too many initiatives over the last decade were not paid for — from the Iraq war to tax breaks for the wealthy.”

“I will not make that same mistake with health care,” he said.

The remarks contributed to a palpable sense of tension in the room. When Obama promised that his plan would not cover illegal immigrants, Rep. Joe Wilson, R-S.C., shouted, “You lie!” — an outburst for which he quickly issued an apology.

“While I disagree with the president’s statement, my comments were inappropriate and regrettable,” Wilson said in a statement. “I extend sincere apologies to the president for this lack of civility.”

Wilson also called the White House and apologized to Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel after fellow Republicans criticized the episode.

“I think we ought to treat the president with respect,” said Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky. “Anything other than that is not appropriate.”

Sen. Bob Corker, R-Tenn., likewise said Wilson’s eruption was “not the kind of thing that to me is appropriate in that kind of setting.”

“My sense was that most people there didn’t think it was a good idea that it occurred, and I happen to be one of those.”

Individuals would join for group rates
Obama took pains to spell out that he was rejecting “a government takeover of the entire health care system.” Instead, he laid out a proposal to create a “marketplace” where individual Americans and small businesses could shop among a variety of private plans.

The idea is to clump individual Americans not already covered by their employers into one big group with “greater leverage to bargain with the insurance companies.” The exchange would take effect within four years, he said, “which will give us time to do it right.”

The collective bargaining of group rates “is how large companies and government employees get affordable insurance,” he said. “It’s how everyone in this Congress gets affordable insurance. And it’s time to give every American the same opportunity that we’ve given ourselves.”

While the insurance exchange is the centerpiece of Obama’s plan, the White House told Democrats that the details would also include at least some ideas from Republicans because “he believes reform should be bipartisan.” But it said Obama was firm that it was now or never.

“The Republicans will have to decide whether they are genuine in their wish to work in a bipartisan manner, or whether they will continue to vote against proposals they have said are key to reform,” the White House message said.

If they choose the latter, it said, opponents “will need to either propose their own plan or explain why they think it is best to do nothing.”

In an interview with Joe Scarborough and Mika Brzezinski of MSNBC TV, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs said Wednesday that Obama still hoped Republicans would sign on to his efforts but that it might not be possible.

Referring to three Republican senators crucial to the debate, Gibbs said: “We’ve worked with Olympia Snowe, with Mike Enzi, with Chuck Grassley. What we’re trying to do is bring Republicans together. ... But some people don’t want to come together.”

From the beginning of his administration, Obama has labored to craft a bipartisan solution, but the White House message and the tone of Obama’s speech Wednesday appeared to be a prelude to an agreement to go ahead without Republican support.

Obama’s proposal tracks closely with legislation offered by Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., who as chairman of the Finance Committee has been one of the main negotiators among the differing factions on Capitol Hill.

Baucus signaled Wednesday that he, too, had finally abandoned seeking a bipartisan agreement. He said his committee would take up action on health care legislation he has put forth within two weeks whether or not Republicans agreed.

“I very much hope and do expect Republicans will be on board,” Baucus told reporters. But he acknowledged that “I moved forward anyway,” saying, “The time has come for action, and we will act.”

“We’re going to get this bill done by the end of the year,” said Baucus, one of the centrist lawmakers known as “the Gang of Six” who are considered the dealmakers and dealbreakers on health care.

Baucus: No chance for public option
That legislation is sure to disappoint proponents of a public option, which Baucus said did not have enough support in the Senate.

Liberal health care activists and lawmakers — including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. — have insisted that some form of government-run insurance system is necessary, both to provide coverage for Americans with no other option and to drive down costs by creating a large competitor to private insurance companies.

But opponents mounted a fast-moving, blunt-force campaign to kill the idea during the summer congressional recess, leading to vivid scenes of raucous objection at lawmakers’ meetings with constituents throughout August.

“I think, with increasing conviction, the public option cannot pass the Senate,” Baucus said.

Snowe, of Maine, another of the Gang of Six, agreed that Obama should give up on the idea of a government-run system.

“I hope that this public option will be taken off the table,” Snowe said in interview Wednesday with MSNBC TV. “Hopefully, he will indicate that he will consider alternatives to the public option so we can move the debate forward.”

White House on board with Baucus plan
The White House message to Democrats said Baucus’ plan, which does not include a public option, was “in line with the principles the president has laid out.” It would require Americans to have health insurance, either through their employers or individually through the insurance exchange, while prohibiting insurance companies from refusing to cover anyone with a pre-existing condition.

To make that happen, the plan would make all families with incomes below a certain point eligible for Medicaid, while tax credits would be offered to help everyone else buy private insurance. In Baucus’ plan, that level would be 133 percent of the federal poverty level, or about $29,300 for a family of four.

Obama welcomed the general principles of that proposal at the close of his address.

“There is agreement in this chamber on about 80 percent of what needs to be done, putting us closer to the goal of reform than we have ever been,” he said. While he will remain open to new proposals, “know this,” he said:

“I will not waste time with those who have made the calculation that it’s better politics to kill this plan than improve it. I will not stand by while the special interests use the same old tactics to keep things exactly the way they are.

“If you misrepresent what’s in the plan, we will call you out. And I will not accept the status quo as a solution. Not this time. Not now.”

Kenneth Strickland of NBC News and David Shuster of MSNBC TV contributed to this report from Washington.

Kenneth Strickland of NBC News and David Shuster of MSNBC TV contributed to this report from Washington.

Video: Obama: ‘Provide you with a choice’

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments