Image: Humam Khalil Abu-Mulal al-Balawi
NBC News
Humam Khalil Abu-Mulal al-Balawi had been invited into a U.S. base in Afghanistan.
NBC News and news services
updated 1/6/2010 10:00:15 PM ET 2010-01-07T03:00:15

Al-Qaida claimed responsibility Wednesday night for the suicide blast in Afghanistan that killed seven CIA officers and contractors, saying in a communique that the attack was in retribution for recent drone attacks on terrorist leaders in Pakistan.

The CIA-controlled Predator drone aircraft have had great success in killing high-ranking al-Qaida and Taliban leaders, using Hellfire missiles.

The communique said the CIA blast was revenge for three leaders: Abu Saleh al Somali, al-Qaida's director of international operations, killed Dec. 8; Beitullah Mehsud, leader of the Pakistani Taliban, killed Aug. 23; and Abdullah Saaed al-Libi, the former military commander of al Qaeda, killed Feb. 10. The communique was signed by Al-Qaida's No. 3, Shaykh Mustafa Abu al-Yazid.

But the United States isn't pulling back on its covert operations to hunt terrorists in Afghanistan and in Pakistan.

In fact, the U.S. struck back at militant targets in Pakistan on Wednesday with explosives apparently launched from a drone — the fifth such attack since the suicide bombing at a secretive eastern Afghan base that reportedly was a key outpost in the effort to identify and target terrorist leaders.

The latest attack was a lethal message that the Obama administration views its airstrikes as too effective to abandon, even though they are unpopular with civilians and the U.S.-backed governments in both Afghanistan and Pakistan. The apparent strike killed 13 people in an area of Pakistan's volatile northwest teeming with militants suspected of directing the suicide attack last week across the border in Afghanistan.

The U.S. deaths were a reminder that while the use of drones may lessen the risk to American pilots, the CIA-run operation has its own human Achilles' heel: the intelligence agents who practice old-fashioned spycraft to pinpoint the targets.

Blow to talent pool
The attack came as a severe blow to the expertise and talent pool of the CIA in a little-understood country where its spies are now most at risk.

Charles Faddis, a former agency case officer, said it was a major strike to agency operations in Pakistan and Afghanistan.

"CIA is a small outfit," said Faddis, who recently published "Beyond Repair," a scathing assessment of the agency. "You don't lose this many people in one strike and not feel it acutely."

The bomber, a Jordanian doctor identified as Humam Khalil Abu-Mulal al-Balawi, was apparently a double agent — perhaps even a triple-agent — who had been considered a key asset. Al-Balawi was invited inside the outpost facility bearing a promise of information about al-Qaida's second in command, presumed to be hiding in Pakistan.

A federal law enforcement official said Wednesday that the bomber entered the base by car and detonated a powerful explosive just outside the base's gym, where CIA operatives and others had gathered. It was unclear whether the explosives were hidden in a suicide vest or belt.

The CIA base chief for Khost province was among those killed, and the Kabul deputy station chief was wounded.

The al-Qaida communique also identified al-Balawi as the bomber and said he had participated in jihadi Web forums. Evan Kohlmann, a counterterrorism analyst for NBC News, said a video on al-Bilawi was likely to follow.

"This is only the beginning," Kohlmann said. "I think we will see a major video production."

FBI probes blast site
A small team of FBI agents, including bomb and evidence technicians, flew to the remote Afghan base soon after the blast, an official said. The team, which is working closely with the CIA, has since returned and is still trying to identify the components of the explosives and whether they included shrapnel.

Several current and former intelligence and defense officials said the deaths of the CIA agents and the others were a foreseeable cost of doing business with unsavory people in dangerous places.

Video: Source: Tape exists of CIA bomb attack "The attacks confirm what has been the CIA's view all along: that undertaking intelligence operations requires taking risks, and while those risks can be diminished by excellent tradecraft, hard work, and smart people, they can never be eliminated," said former CIA officer Steven Cash.

The CIA is taking heat from some of its own former employees, however, for apparently taking unnecessary risks in this case by failing to search the bomber before he penetrated the base's security perimeter. They also raised questions about why more than a dozen U.S. personnel were close by when al-Balawai detonated explosives strapped to his body.

Two CIA operatives might have been plenty, former CIA officials said. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss what they called tradecraft, or agency procedures.

Bruce Riedel, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution Saban Center and a former CIA officer, said the agency would now likely be scrubbing its other sources in the region to ensure they are legitimate.

"If the other side was running this one person against us, how confident are we of everyone else?" Riedel asked. "You have to take a period to assess where you are."

However, Riedel said the CIA is aware, especially after the Dec. 25 attempted bombing of an airliner in Detroit, that it doesn't have the luxury of time.

Riedel said the bait that al-Balawi was offering — the location of al-Qaida No. 2 Ayman al-Zawahri, was too tempting to resist.

"We haven't had real location on either him or bin Laden in years," he said.

Bad as the suicide attack was, several current and former intelligence officials said the CIA has a deep bench of operatives with experience in Afghanistan, after eight years of active warfare and the Cold War decades in which Afghanistan was considered strategic.

There are no immediate plans to close the once-secret military base, and the CIA is expected to quickly rebuild its operations there.

Scope of operations increase
A U.S. intelligence official said the agency has increased the size and scope of its operations in Afghanistan and is continuing its counterterrorism mission as before.

Military officials said there may be additional security precautions for people entering the kind of forward operating base that houses the CIA operation. But the CIA controls many of the decisions about whom to meet and where, and how thoroughly to search a presumed informant.

Informants are sometimes invited to secure bases because of the security risk involved in sending undercover employees or other operatives outside the base, current and former intelligence and military officials said.

NATO's top intelligence officer has ordered significant changes in the way information is collected and shared in Afghanistan, saying that without reform the U.S. intelligence community will continue to be only "marginally relevant" to the counterinsurgency mission.

In a stinging assessment of the U.S. intelligence effort after eight years of war, U.S. Maj. Gen. Michael Flynn directed intelligence workers to focus less on the enemy and more on civilian life.

'Starved for information'
Field agents are not providing the kind of intelligence that analysts need to respond to inquiries from President Barack Obama and the top commander in Afghanistan, Gen. Stanley McChrystal.

"These analysts are starved for information from the field — so starved, in fact, that many say their jobs feel more like fortune telling than serious detective work," said the report released this week.

The report was compiled before the suicide attack at Forward Operating Base Chapman in eastern Afghanistan. The CIA is not mentioned in Flynn's report, which focuses more on the thousands of uniformed and civilian intelligence personnel serving with the Defense Department and joint interagency operations in the country.

Intelligence officials said al-Balawi had provided a stream of useful information in what may have been an artful ruse to build trust with his Jordanian and U.S. contacts.

NBC News' Evan Kohlmann and Robert Windrem and The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Video: Slain CIA officer honored

  1. Closed captioning of: Slain CIA officer honored

    >> nushgs sanaa.

    >>> it was a week ago today in afghanistan, the cia suffered one of its worst losses in more than 26 years. seven americans were killed at a then-secret cia base by a jordanian double-agent suicide bomber who was supposedly helping provide intelligence about al qaeda . nbc news has learned the bomber detonated his explosive vest not while already on the base, but after security officers noticed his hand in his pocket and demanded he show his hands. tonight our own peter alexander has the personal story of one of the cia operatives who lost his life.

    >> reporter: a public farewell in atlanta this afternoon for cia security officer scott roberson who died along six others serving their country on a secret mission on terror's front lines.

    >> they are the best of the best and my brother deserved to be among them.

    >> reporter: years before helping to serve covert operations, roberson patrolled atlanta 's toughest streets.

    >> he just made the job easier because he was so easy to be around.

    >> reporter: south side scotty, as his camarades called him is one of the founders of the police department emerald society with the motto, "cops taking care of cops." at today's service, they made sure roberson 's family is taken care of, too.

    >> he died doing what he felt he needed to do. he left us too soon.

    >> reporter: his security work took him from kosovo then to iraq before he joined the cia last summer and headed to afghanistan.

    >> he said, you know, remember, mom, no regrets. i'm doing something really great for my country.

    >> reporter: because their work is highly classified a cia officer's identity is typically kept secret after their death. roberson 's family received permission to discuss his life publically.

    >> by releasing these names, the cia is reminding the american people , even though they fight this war in the shadows, there is a high cost to it. in some instances people are tragically losing their lives.

    >> reporter: an ohio native, roberson was scheduled to return home next month for the birth of his first child, a girl he and his wife molly planned to name piper. his last trip back, the baby shower over thanksgiving.

    >> it's the first time i've seen him so content. his life was just where he wanted it to be. he had a job he was proud of. he had a wife he adored, a baby he was looking forward to.

    >> reporter: no longer anonymous, a hero to his family, his co-workers and his country, peter alexander , nbc news, atlanta .


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments