Image: Charles Rangel
Alex Brandon  /  AP
Rep. Charles Rangel, D-N.Y., gives a thumbs up as he leaves his office to go vote on Thursday in Washington, D.C.
updated 7/31/2010 2:28:22 AM ET 2010-07-31T06:28:22

President Barack Obama on Friday called ethics charges against Democratic Rep. Charlie Rangel "very troubling" and said he hopes the longtime lawmaker can end his career with dignity. Several House Democrats went further, flat-out urging the New York congressman to resign.

"He's somebody who's at the end of his career," Obama said in an interview that aired Friday on "CBS Evening News with Katie Couric." "I'm sure that what he wants is to be able to end his career with dignity. And my hope is that it happens."

Obama, speaking on the issue for the first time, praised the 20-term Rangel for serving his constituents well but called the more than one-dozen tax and disclosure charges against him "very troubling."

It was hardly an endorsement for the veteran lawmaker, but fell well short of the calls for resignation Rangel received on the eve of the House's August recess. As House Democrats headed home, they wrestled with how to handle the matter in their districts ahead of the midterm elections.

Republicans, meanwhile, raced ahead with plans to make Rangel the face of corrupt Washington under the rule of Democrats who had vowed to clean up Congress.

'Some sloppiness'
For his part, Rangel, who denies the charges, met with perhaps his staunchest supporters, members of the New York state delegation, in the stately Capitol parlor named for the Ways and Means Committee that he headed until March.

"He indicated there was some sloppiness" in his official papers, Rep. Edolphus Towns, D-N.Y., told reporters, "but, you know, there's no criminality here."

Rangel's defense against 13 charges of misusing his office and tax and disclosure issues includes pointing fingers at peers, The Washington Post reported Saturday. He argues that others have taken the same course of action without fear of punishment in asking corporate donors to give to academic centers bearing their names.

His legal team, in their 32-page rebuttal, said Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., helped raise money for a center named for him at the University of Louisville. They also cited similarities with the recently deceased Sen. Robert C. Byrd, D-W.Va. and with former Republican senators Trent Lott of Mississippi. and Jesse Helms of North Carolina.

"These activities have never been regarded as creating an improper benefit to a Member," the lawyers said in their 32-page rebuttal.

McConnell spokesman Donald Stewart told the Post Friday that "Mr. Rangel's efforts to draw comparisons are absurd and without any similarity whatsoever."

  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California

House rules and credibility were the reasons cited by more than a half dozen House Democrats known to have called for Rangel's resignation by late afternoon Friday.

A House panel on Thursday made public for the first time the charges against Rangel, 80, as it opened the trial phase of the ethics proceedings against him. If Rangel and the ethics committee do not settle the case, it goes to a public trial this fall, at the height of an election season in which every member of the House, 36 in the Senate and the Democratic majorities of both chambers are on the line.

Resignation calls
Either conditionally or outright, Democrats calling for Rangel's resignation included Rep. Walter Minnick of Idaho, Betty Sutton of Ohio, John Yarmuth of Kentucky, Zack Space of Ohio, Ann Kirkpatrick of Arizona and Mary Jo Kilroy of Ohio.

"Too many politicians, both Democrats and Republicans, have fallen victim to the idea that they are 'different' than regular folks and nothing could be further from the truth," Kirkpatrick said in a statement.

"It is our job as members of Congress to hold each other accountable to a higher standard regardless of party," she added. "If the serious charges against (Rangel) are accurate, he needs to resign."

Rangel has said the indictment released Thursday contains factual errors.

"We've heard Charlie in the Ways and Means Committee, and he's addressed these charges. He never denied they happened. He always has an explanation. You can excuse one or two, but not 13," Yarmuth told the Louisville Courier-Journal in an interview published Friday. "I don't see how he can stay if they're true. I believe they are."

Back home in Rangel's Harlem district, he remains popular with many voters and could well win reelection if his political career survives the ethics probe, though one woman said Friday she had mixed feelings after reading news accounts of the allegations against him.

"I don't think he is 100 percent honest, but he's no worse than other politicians," said Charynda Morez, a college student who was buying groceries at a deli.

She said that she didn't know how he should be punished, but that Rangel should resign anyway. Rangel has four apartments "when there are people who don't have a home," she said, citing allegations that Rangel lived in four combined rent-stabilized apartments instead of one, in violation of New York City law.

'Dirty laundry'
But outside the apartment building in question, food vendor Curtis Parker defended Rangel and said the 40-year House veteran was being targeted despite all the good he's done for the community.

"They're just airing his dirty laundry," he said, adding that the charges fall far short of what would normally deserve "jail time."

Democratic leaders are urging their members to cast the election as one about a choice between their party, which under President Barack Obama has overhauled health care and Wall Street, and a GOP-tea party combination that wants to roll back Democratic accomplishments.

House Republicans relished using Rangel to change the subject — especially if he does not reach a settlement with the ethics committee. A public trial equates to a free media presentation of the misdeeds of one of the most senior Democrats in the House.

The House Republicans' campaign arm released a list of Democrats who have not returned campaign contributions they received from Rangel during their careers and said those lawmakers would face questions about the matter from constituents during the August break.

"It's very difficult for Democrats to make the case that this is a 'choice' election when the national headlines are focused around an ethics scandal that has clearly impacted the party in power," said Ken Spain, spokesman for the National Republican Campaign Committee.

Rangel retained many supporters Friday. The New York delegation and the Congressional Black Caucus, which was co-founded by Rangel, urged their colleagues not to rush to judgment. House leaders eager to avoid alienating black voters remained mum on what Rangel should do.

Some Democrats privately said they took a small measure of comfort in one revelation. Rep. Gene Green, the Texas Democrat who led the four-member bipartisan panel of investigators, told reporters that his committee recommended a relatively mild punishment for Rangel — reprimand, a statement of wrongdoing voted by the whole House that carries no other penalty.

But statements continued to trickle out that left no doubt that at some point, Democrats would have to look out for No. 1 - themselves.

"If at the trial's conclusion Mr. Rangel is found guilty by his peers, then he should incur the full punishment allowed by the House, including removal from office," said Rep. Bobby Bright, D-Ala. 

Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Rangel faces 13 ethics charges

  1. Closed captioning of: Rangel faces 13 ethics charges

    >>> breaking news to pass along in the rangel ethics investigation. want to go back to luke russert with the details.

    >> i'm holding a statement of alleged violation which is essentially the statement put out by the investigative subcommittee which says what mr. rangel is being charged with. there are 13 charges and counts in this. but mr. rangel soliciting donations for his school at the city college of new york , they have found that violated the house gift ban so they believe him to be guilty of that. in terms of filing disclosure reforms about his personal incomes , they found that he violated the ethics and government act by not disclosing financial reforms from 1998 through 2008 . they feel he's guilty there. he had rent controlled apartments in what are legharlem, he use d one as his personal office. they found his violated the government service act. and in regards to not paying federal income tax on his personal villa in the dominican republic , they found that he violated ethics rules on that. the respondent's pattern of indifferent or disregard for the laws, rules and regulations of the united states and the house representatives are a ? serious violation. the investigate tiff committee found that the actions did not fit into clause one of the code of conduct . so essentially what you have here is a two-year investigation, the culmination of it in my hands, his colleagues on the investigative subcommittee believe him to be guilty on these things that he allegedly was guilty of for so long. the soliciting donations for the city college of new york , on house stationary, they found that to be unjust. they believe that him not paying taxes on his villa in the dominican republic is unjust. having fourth rent controlled apartments in new york city , that's unjust. so they are putting it out here right now that his colleagues in the investigative subcommittee part believe himming to gift. if that does go to trial, this is essentially the prosecution's case. his colleagues believe him to be guilty of what are some serious violations.

Interactive: Rangel under scrutiny


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments