updated 8/31/2010 1:23:13 PM ET 2010-08-31T17:23:13

Astronauts, submariners and over-wintering Antarctic researchers have all been looked to for comparisons of the psychological plight of the 33 trapped miners in Copiapó, Chile. But a better analogy might be soldiers on extended combat duty.

  1. Don't miss these Health stories
    1. Splash News
      More women opting for preventive mastectomy - but should they be?

      Rates of women who are opting for preventive mastectomies, such as Angeline Jolie, have increased by an estimated 50 percent in recent years, experts say. But many doctors are puzzled because the operation doesn't carry a 100 percent guarantee, it's major surgery -- and women have other options, from a once-a-day pill to careful monitoring.

    2. Larry Page's damaged vocal cords: Treatment comes with trade-offs
    3. Report questioning salt guidelines riles heart experts
    4. CDC: 2012 was deadliest year for West Nile in US
    5. What stresses moms most? Themselves, survey says

"(Astronauts, sailors and polar researchers) go into it voluntarily," said psychologist and isolation researcher Lawrence Palinkas of the University of Southern California. "They know their isolation will come to an end. These miners are not sure about that."

Even experiments in which people try to simulate the long, dangerous, profoundly isolating trip to Mars fail to reproduce the harshest aspects of reality, Palinkas said.

"The drawback is that these people know it's an experiment," Palinkas told Discovery News. "They can say 'I'm done now, so I want to go up.'"

"When you boil it down to the psychological level, there is physical misery, separation (from families), uncertainty and ambiguity about the future," explained U.S. Army Col. Tom Kolditz of Westpoint. These pretty much sum up the experiences of soldiers on extended combat missions, he said.

The good news, Kolditz said, is that there has been loads of research on soldiers in these situations, so there is plenty of precedents to look to and strategies available to help the miners.

Emergent leadership key to survival
Among the first things to happen in such dire predicaments among soldiers, said Kolditz, has already happened in the mine: The miners appointed leaders among themselves.

"It's called 'emergent leadership,'" said Kolditz, who has studied this phenomenon in detail. "In dangerous contexts an individual's rank or official standing has less to do with leadership than competence does."

All other normal, everyday leadership attributes — affability, popularity and such — go out the window. The most competent people lead.

    1. Tech: Measuring Nuclear Disasters
    2. Food Packaging Harbors Harmful Chemicals
    3. Disaster Relief: Contrasting Haiti and Japan
    4. Petroleum Common in Some 'Green' Products
    5. Moms' Junk Food Habits May Alter Kids' Brains

The next big psychological challenge for the miners, just like soldiers, is their families.

"A big part of their stress is about their families," said Kolditz. The miners are all poor, and the company that owns the mine is teetering on the brink of bankruptcy. So the miners are worried about the safety and well-being of their loved ones, and are powerless to help.

The loss of the daily rhythms is another major hurdle, says Palinkas. Cycles of light and dark stimulate hormones that regulate the human body. That can lead to insufficient sleep, increased fatigue, short-term memory loss, irritability and depression. These, in turn, can magnify even the smallest irritations, he said.

"Snoring you could pretty much stand in normal situations," said Palinkas. But, he says, it could lead to major conflicts in prolonged isolation.

Distrust could develop
An additional pattern that could develop among the miners is distrust. It could be aimed either within their group or towards the people trying to rescue them, Palinkas said.

"Any attempt to be not entirely forthcoming (by rescuers) could be seen as a lack of trust," said Palinkas. That, oddly, could unify the miners against the people running things, in this case their rescuers.

"You see that a lot in polar expeditions and a lot of missions in space," said Palinkas. Too little information (from their distant superiors) or too much work causes discontent and distrust.

Among the simple things that can help the miners battle all the effects of isolation is a predictable schedule, said Kolditz.

  1. Most popular

For example, during the Vietnam War, soldiers in extended field operations for 50 to 80 days were required to shave and reapply their face paint every day. It's was a small thing, but a constant in an otherwise unpredictable situation.

There is also evidence from people who have worked in bunkers for long periods that circadian rhythms can be managed with good schedules, Kolditz said.

Miners' chances are good
Overall, Kolditz is particularly optimistic about the miners' psychological prospects. The fact that the men supported each other when they broke down emotionally during recent videos is a very good sign, he said.

"What you are seeing is that they have really pulled together as a group," said Kolditz.

It's even likely, he said, that for some of the miners this whole disaster will be a life-changing experience that will lead to positive changes in their lives. Once again, the lives of soldiers have borne this out.

© 2012 Discovery Channel

Video: Camera sent down mine reveals life of trapped miners

  1. Transcript of: Camera sent down mine reveals life of trapped miners

    BRIAN WILLIAMS, anchor (New Orleans): Back now from the Ninth Ward in New Orleans . And far from here in Chile , we're getting a fascinating look at what life is like for those 33 miners trapped way underground, living together in a small space while waiting to be rescued, a risky process that could take months. Crews above ground sent a tiny camera down through the bore hole and, as our own Tom Costello reports, the miners sent it back with images of what life is like for them down there.

    TOM COSTELLO reporting: Chanting and singing deep inside the hot, humid mine, the 33 trapped miners appear shirtless, unshaven, dirty and 20 pounds lighter after three weeks underground.

    Unidentified Man #1:

    COSTELLO: 'Hello to my family, my daughter,' this miner says.

    Unidentified Man #2:

    COSTELLO: Another says, 'Even though the conditions aren't good, we're OK because we know that we're going to get out of here .' We now know the area the miners are living in is much larger than just a 30x20-foot refuge chamber. The men can move through open sections of the mine that are big enough to hold several trucks, though ventilation is not always good. Some areas of the mine have been set aside for exercise, a clinic, and because sanitation is critical, a remote section is set aside as the latrine. A table set aside to play cards and dominoes. Above ground, rescuers send down clean water, food and oxygen, while family members hold vigil.

    Unidentified Boy: I love my dad.

    COSTELLO: Telemundo 's Angie Sandoval is there.

    ANGIE SANDOVAL reporting: They're very happy, but also concerned because some of the men appear very thin.

    Ms. ELIZABETH SEGOVIA (Trapped Miner's Sister): If God gave us the patience and the strength when we didn't know if they were alive, now there's even more reason to be strong.

    COSTELLO: The men are still joking at times about how badly each of them smells. And they've established rules and schedules, knowing full well their physical and mental health will be put to the test over the coming months. Tom Costello, NBC News, Washington.

Gallery: Miner profiles, first moments of freedom

Read about each of the 33 miners as they are rescued.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments