Image: Pat Toomey
Matt Rourke  /  AP
Democratic Rep. Joe Sestak has trailed Republican Pat Toomey, above, for months, and a GOP victory always has seemed likely. Yet recent polls suggest Sestak has closed the gap, and Republican leaders are imploring supporters not to panic even as they ask themselves: What's going on?
updated 10/24/2010 3:47:00 PM ET 2010-10-24T19:47:00

To understand Republicans' nagging fear that the Nov. 2 elections might not be quite the massive triumph that many have predicted, check out Pennsylvania's perplexing Senate race.

Democratic Rep. Joe Sestak has trailed Republican Pat Toomey for months, and a GOP victory always has seemed likely, given that it's a Republican-trending year in this perpetually contested state. Yet recent polls suggest Sestak has closed the gap, and Republican leaders are imploring supporters not to panic even as they ask themselves: What's going on?

The Sestak-Toomey race mirrors other Senate contests that are making this one of the most intriguing and unpredictable midterm elections in years.

Just as in Nevada, Colorado, Kentucky, and perhaps Alaska and Connecticut, each candidate is an accomplished but imperfect politician, and the tea party movement is playing a big but uncertain role.

  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California

In most of those states, plus Washington and California, Senate races are tightening to nail-biting margins. That means Republicans might pick up a few seats or as many as 10, which would give them the majority. Democrats privately concede they may be unable to keep their House majority, but losing the Senate would be devastating.

President Barack Obama's travels now focus largely on trying to save Democratic senators in Washington, California, Nevada and Wisconsin, a clear sign that his party is still playing defense.

Story: GOP storm bears down on Wis., may pass by Minn.

While California and Washington see Senate GOP challengers creeping up on Democratic incumbents, it's embattled Democrats who seem to be rising elsewhere. They have seized on a common claim: A dangerous fringe movement, the tea party, has taken over the Republican Party.

    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California
    6. Christie acknowledges federal subpoena
    7. Obama says Fox News's O'Reilly 'absolutely' unfair in extended interview
    8. Christie security officer hit with shoplifting charges
  1. More politics
    1. Obama's 2nd year
    2. Political Cartoons

Unlike the Republican nominees in Colorado and Nevada, Pennsylvania's Toomey fits more comfortably in the GOP's business-friendly, low-tax tradition than in the hot-blooded, anti-establishment tea party model. Still, he has accepted tea party champion Sarah Palin's endorsement.

Story: Big guns push midterm campaigns into high gear

Sestak is using that fact — plus, curiously, the notoriety of tea partier Christine O'Donnell, the GOP Senate nominee in neighboring Delaware — to paint Toomey as a pilot of a new and scary Republican Party veering dangerously to the fringe.

'Those extreme candidates'
In speeches and ads, Sestak ties Toomey to O'Donnell, the headline-grabbing upstart who trails by double digits in Delaware polls. In a debate Wednesday, Sestak said he worries about "those extreme candidates" who take advantage of "the extreme fringe of the tea party. There are those that are running with Congressman Toomey. Miss O'Donnell next door, for example."

Story: Candidates of all stripes seek to label opponents 'extreme'

While many analysts have predicted a tightening of Senate races, the strategy might be working. If that perception spreads, it will embolden Democrats making similar claims against tea party Republicans in Nevada, Colorado and elsewhere.

It might even give hope to Democratic Senate nominee Jack Conway in Kentucky, where Republican Rand Paul has not quite sealed a victory.

In Alaska's complex race, Sen. Lisa Murkowski is slapping the too-extreme label on Joe Miller, the tea party favorite who denied her the Republican nomination. Murkowski is trying a write-in campaign, while the Democratic nominee, Scott McAdams, seems to be running third.

Some analysts see two other factors helping Sestak, and perhaps Democrats elsewhere:

  • Democrats are thought to have a superior get-out-the-vote operation here and in other states, and the latest polls might be reflecting the heavy contact of voters by phone and door-knocking.
  • Obama and others have said Democratic voters will "wake up" when they realize what's at stake, and some analysts think that's happening now.

Tide of voter anger
Many Republicans scoff at these claims, saying a powerful tide of voter anger still runs heavily in their favor.

  1. Most popular

To be sure, Sestak has his own problems, just as Sen. Harry Reid has poor approval ratings in Nevada, and Sen. Michael Bennet struggles to defend his support of Obama in Colorado.

Pennsylvania Republicans say the intense former Navy admiral is too liberal for this centrist state. They note that Sestak, a two-term House member, wanted a public insurance option in the new health care law, a larger stimulus package than the $814 billion plan Congress approved, and a tougher cap-and-trade energy bill than the House passed.

A TV ad by the National Republican Senatorial Committee rattles off those points with machine-gun speed, part of a torrent of campaign attacks by both parties that assault Pennsylvania viewers daily. Plenty of anti-Toomey ads air, too. Some voters say they now tune out the entire avalanche of commercials for and against House, Senate and gubernatorial candidates.

In a televised debate in Pittsburgh on Friday, Sestak defended Obama's stimulus spending. He said mainstream economists believe 8 million more jobs would have disappeared without the blend of middle-class tax cuts and help for cash-strapped state governments and the unemployed.

Toomey said three years of halving payroll taxes would have been more effective, by making it less costly for businesses to hire new workers.

As elsewhere, the Pennsylvania political debates and TV ads specialize in guilt-by-association.

One 30-second anti-Sestak ad ties him to Obama, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Reid on the issues of stimulus spending, bank bailouts and energy.

Sestak sandwiched his opponent between the most famous tea party figures, alluding to "Palin, Toomey, O'Donnell" as if they were a law firm.

Toomey was in the House from 1999 to 2005, but Sestak invariably calls him "congressman" in this anti-insider year.

Toomey is trying to blunt the attacks by saying Sestak is the extremist in the race. His allies run TV ads attacking Sestak for saying suspected terrorists should be tried in federal courts, not military tribunals.

'Voters decide'
The GOP nominee is trying to keep some distance from tea party activists while embracing more traditional Republicans. He welcomed former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani at a small rally Friday in a fire station in Blue Bell, northwest of Philadelphia. But speaking later with reporters, Toomey was expressionless when asked if Palin is qualified to be president, a question he sidestepped in Wednesday's debate.

  1. Only on
    1. OWN via Getty Images
      From belief to betrayal: How America fell for Armstrong
    2. pool via Reuters file
      US to Syria neighbors: Be ready to act on WMDs
    3. China: One-child policy is here to stay
    4. NRA: Practice Range
      New 'Practice Range' shooter game says it’s from NRA
    5. 'Gifted' priest indicted in crystal meth case
    6. AFP - Getty Images
      China's state media admits to air pollution crisis
    7. AFP - Getty Images
      French to send 1,000 more troops to Mali

"Politicians don't decide who's qualified for office," he said. "Voters decide."

Ed Rendell, a former Democratic Party national chairman who is retiring after two terms as Pennsylvania governor, said in an interview that he thinks the specter of an ascendant tea party is lighting a fire under Democratic voters.

"Democrats are getting scared by all the craziness out there," he said moments after campaigning for Sestak at Temple University. He cited Republicans who want to subpoena scores of Obama administration officials and who would outlaw abortion for rape victims. That message, plus the party's get-out-the-vote push, might help candidates such as Sestak pull off upsets on Nov. 2, Rendell said. Or maybe not.

"It's all coming together," Rendell said. "Now will it come together fast enough to make a difference? I can't predict that."

Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Dems hope turnout can slow GOP wave

  1. Transcript of: Dems hope turnout can slow GOP wave

    LESTER HOLT, anchor: Nine days to go until Election Day . And the vote counting has started, at least in the minds of Republican and Democratic leaders, who were out today doing the math and predicting what the next Congress will look like. The name of the game is controlling the agenda on Capitol Hill , and on this next-to-last weekend before the vote, the strategies of how they both hope to get there were on full display. NBC 's Mike Viqueira reports.

    MIKE VIQUEIRA reporting: Today on " Meet the Press " the GOP chairman predicts a sweeping victory for his party.

    Mr. MICHAEL STEELE (Republican National Committee Chairman): Oh, I absolutely believe in the House the balance of power will shift, as I like to say, with 38 seats. And we need to get to 39 to get control. But I think we're more than there.

    VIQUEIRA: And while conceding that his party faces big losses, the Democratic leader is holding out hope that all is not lost .

    Mr. TIM KAINE (Democratic National Committee Chairman): The more people turn out, the better we do. And we're seeing strong trends at the presidential rallies and early voting.

    President BARACK OBAMA: Hello, Huskies!

    VIQUEIRA: Fresh off a five-state campaign swing, President Obama has worked to fire up core Democrats as Election Day draws near.

    Pres. OBAMA: And so in 2008 you said yes, we can. In 2010 , you've got to say yes, we can.

    VIQUEIRA: The president has staged big rallies on college campuses...

    Pres. OBAMA: We still have a significant gender gap when it comes to wages.

    VIQUEIRA: ...and drawn a renewed focus on issues affecting women.

    Mr. PETER HART (Democratic Pollster): Democrats need to get out the core vote; that is the minorities, it's the women and it's the young people. That's where the president's going, and he's doing the job that needs to be done for Democrats .

    VIQUEIRA: Mr. Obama plans more campaign travel between now and Election Day , trying to shore up Senate Democrats at risk with stops in Pennsylvania , Connecticut , Illinois and Ohio , along with a trip to raise campaign cash tomorrow in Rhode Island .

    Unidentified Man: Thank you! Thank you!

    VIQUEIRA: And while Republican gains are expected in the Senate , they are not likely to take majority control. But with only the most optimistic Democrats believing that the House can be saved, experts say a new face, Republican John Boehner , is likely to be seen in the speaker's office next year.

    Mr. STUART ROTHENBERG (Political Analyst): Chances are good that all the gains the Democrats made in the House in the last two elections, 50 seats plus, are going to be erased in this one election.

    VIQUEIRA: And, Lester , to give you some idea the length to which Mr. Obama is going to reach younger voters this Wednesday appears for the first time as president on " The Daily Show ." That's a comedy program that makes fun of the news, pundits and politicians. Lester :

    HOLT: Mike Viqueira , thanks.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments