By
updated 11/11/2010 4:54:34 PM ET 2010-11-11T21:54:34

When the Obama administration launched its flagship foreclosure prevention program in early 2009, it pledged to spend up to $50 billion helping struggling homeowners. But the government has so far only spent a tiny fraction of that.

A recent Treasury Department report summarizing TARP spending put the total at $600 million through October.

Although the Treasury Department posts the maximum amount that could go to each mortgage servicer on its website, it doesn’t report the details of the spending. So we filed a Freedom of Information request for the data, and can now show for the first time exactly how much money has gone to each servicer. (A Treasury Department spokeswoman said they’re considering regularly releasing the information going forward.)

The program, which uses TARP money, tries to prevent foreclosures by paying mortgages servicers incentives to make loan modifications. The largest payout, $79 million, has gone to JPMorgan Chase. Next on the list is Bank of America with $45.1 million. That’s a drop in the bucket for BofA, which reported net servicing income of $780 million in the third quarter. (You can use our bailout tracker to see how much money has gone to each mortgage servicer. The figures, which come from our FOIA request, only go through August.)

With the government’s program showing signs of slowing down, the small payout so far shows that Treasury won’t come close to using the full $50 billion, said Guy Cecala, publisher of Inside Mortgage Finance. “It’s a joke, because everyone’s asking ‘is [the program] really worth the $50 billion we’ve committed?’” he said. “We’ll never spend anywhere near that.”

There are two main reasons why so little money has been paid out. First, there have been few modifications done through the program. The government only pays incentives for finalized modifications, not trials. For instance, even though $8.3 billion has been set aside for Bank of America, it won’t get that money unless it provides modifications.

Second, incentives are paid out over time. For instance, homeowners in the program receive a $1,000 reduction to their mortgage each year for five years if they stay current on the modified loan. The program is less than two years old, and few modifications were given during the first year.

Related: Foreclosure mess will take years to clean up

Incentives are paid to three different groups: homeowners, investors, and banks and other companies who service the loans (The four biggest servicers of mortgages are also the U.S.’s largest banks: Bank of America, Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Chase and Citigroup.) So far, the servicers have kept most of the money paid out: $231.5 million all told. Investors (lenders and mortgage-backed securities investors) and homeowners have received $129.2 million and $34.7 million, respectively. Our database breaks those amounts down for each servicer.

It’s hard to estimate just how much Treasury will ultimately use of the $50 billion. One reason is that a portion of the modifications will default, so all the incentives for each modification will not be paid out. Of modifications completed a year ago, about 21 percent have already defaulted, according to Treasury data.

If a homeowner keeps up payments on a modified mortgage for the full five years, it could cost the government in the range of $20,000 over five years, according to a ballpark estimate provided by the Treasury spokeswoman. But many homeowners in the program are expected to default on their mortgages well before that.

The government has set aside billions of dollars from the TARP for other, related programs – but it also remains to be seen how much of that money will be spent. The government pays incentives for other ways of avoiding foreclosure, like short sales, but those programs started relatively recently. It’s also allocated $7.6 billion to 18 different states (plus Washington, D.C.)  for local plans to avert foreclosure. Another $8.1 billion has been reserved for a plan to refinance homeowners in underwater mortgages into Federal Housing Agency loans.

Separate from the TARP, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, both under government control, also participate in the loan modification program. Administration officials have said Fannie and Freddie could pay up to $25 billion in incentives to their servicers and homeowners, but it’s also doubtful that whole amount will be spent. As the TARP inspector general recently noted, they’ve only paid out $451 million through September.

© Copyright 2012 ProPublica Inc. All rights reserved.

Video: Moving from pity to empathy in mortgage mess

  1. Transcript of: Moving from pity to empathy in mortgage mess

    LESTER HOLT, anchor: The home mortgage crisis in this country has triggered a wave of foreclosures, shattering the dreams of countless families. But it has changed the lives in other ways, as well. Take the story of one real estate professional in Oklahoma , whose business is booming even as she sees the crisis hitting home . We get the story from NBC 's Ron Mott .

    RON MOTT reporting: Becky Watkins has her hands full. She works for her local sheriff's office near Tulsa as an appraiser of foreclosed properties. Today she's working her way through yet another stack of homes to value destined for the auction block. She jots down notes, takes a look around, snaps a photo or two, then off to the next one. Sometimes it all gets to her.

    Ms. BECKY WATKINS: I get very emotional sometimes. It's hurtful to see children's toys, clothes, shoes, bicycles. Sometimes they leave in the middle of the night .

    MOTT: She says the foreclosures she sees touch families at every income level. It makes her long for the not-so-distant good old days when home sales were booming, home prices rising.

    Ms. WATKINS: It was happy times for everybody. And maybe too happy, but still it was happy times .

    MOTT: But these days...

    DARRELL: But it's a no cost to you so...

    MOTT: ...she and husband Darrell , full-time firefighter, part-time home builder say it's much harder to find happy times . Darrell 's construction business took a big hit when the economy soured two years ago. The bills piled up, they fell behind. And now Becky is facing a fate she never imagined possible. The bank is foreclosing on her and her husband, and soon someone else could be coming to their doorsteps to do the exact same job she does, someone from her own office. It may be someone you know?

    Ms. WATKINS: It will be somebody I know.

    MOTT: Like many families, Becky says then tried to get their lender to modify their loan for months, almost two years now. Instead, in mid-August, the bank gave them a foreclosure notice.

    DARRELL: Coming in the house and seeing her working on the phone, you know, it's hard.

    MOTT: For Becky it's a startling turnabout.

    Ms. WATKINS: The time we started this house, never, never thought that it would get this bad.

    MOTT: Yet she refuses to give up, still investing in home repairs ...

    Ms. WATKINS: Many things unfinished.

    MOTT: ...hoping the worst won't happen. This is not a scene you want...

    Ms. WATKINS: No.

    MOTT: ...repeated at your place?

    Ms. WATKINS: No, absolutely not. Never want -- never want to feel like I'm in this final position, no, where you have nowhere to go except to leave.

    MOTT: From sympathy to empathy on the front lines of foreclosures. Ron Mott, NBC News, Wagoner, Oklahoma.

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

Data: Latest rates in the US

Home equity rates View rates in your area
Home equity type Today +/- Chart
$30K HELOC FICO 4.32%
$30K home equity loan FICO 5.05%
$75K home equity loan FICO 4.50%
Credit card rates View more rates
Card type Today +/- Last Week
Low Interest Cards 10.98%
10.96%
Cash Back Cards 16.43%
16.45%
Rewards Cards 16.00%
15.99%
Source: Bankrate.com