Image: Pope Benedict XVI
Andrew Medichini  /  AP
Pope Benedict XVI said that the important thing was that the intent was to take responsibility and take into consideration the life of the other.
msnbc.com news services
updated 11/23/2010 8:47:25 AM ET 2010-11-23T13:47:25

Pope Benedict XVI's comments about condom use being a lesser evil than transmitting HIV also apply to women, the Vatican said Tuesday, a significant shift for a pope who just last year said condoms only worsen the AIDS problem.

Benedict said in a book released Tuesday that condom use by people such as male prostitutes was a lesser evil since it indicated they were taking a step toward a more moral and responsible sexuality by aiming to protect their partner from a deadly infection.

His comments implied that he was referring primarily to homosexual sex, when condoms aren't being used as a form of contraception, which the Vatican opposes.

Questions arose immediately, however, about the pope's intent because the Italian translation of the book used the feminine for prostitute, whereas the original German used the masculine.

The Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, told reporters Tuesday that he asked the pope whether he intended his comments to only apply to male prostitutes.

Video: Pope takes new position on condoms (on this page)

Taking responsibility
Benedict replied that it really didn't matter, that the important thing was the person in question took into consideration the life of the other, Lombardi said.

"I personally asked the pope if there was a serious, important problem in the choice of the masculine over the feminine," Lombardi said.

"He told me no. The problem is this ... It's the first step of taking responsibility, of taking into consideration the risk of the life of another with whom you have a relationship," he added.

    1. Castaway's parents thought they would never see him again

      The father of Pacific castaway Jose Salvador Alvarenga said he was told his long-lost son vanished on a fishing trip but he didn’t have the heart to break the news to his ailing wife.

    2. Scotland legalizes same-sex marriage
    3. Weapons deal strengthened Assad: US intel chief
    4. Outcry over the fate of Sochi's stray dogs
    5. Olympic construction leaves Sochi residents in the cold

"This is if you're a woman, a man, or a transsexual. We're at the same point, which is the first step in responsibly avoiding passing on a grave risk to the other," Lombardi said.

The pope is not justifying or condoning gay sex or heterosexual sex outside of a marriage.

Elsewhere in the book he reaffirms the Vatican opposition to homosexual acts and artificial contraception and reaffirms the inviolability of marriage between man and woman.

But by broadening the condom comments to also apply to women, the pope is saying that condom use in heterosexual relations is the lesser evil than passing HIV onto a partner.

While that concept has long been a tenet of moral theology, the pope's book "Light of the World" — a series of interviews with a German journalist — was the first time a pope had ever publicly applied the theory to the scenario of condom use as a way to fight HIV transmission.

The pope's comments have generated heated debate, mostly positive in places like Africa which has been devastated by AIDS and where the church has been criticized for its opposition to condom use.

'The Big Lie'
The late cardinal John O'Connor of New York famously branded the use of condoms to stop the spread of AIDS as "The Big Lie."

In the book, the pope says the use of condoms could be seen as "a first step toward moralization," even though condoms are "not really the way to deal with the evil of HIV infection."

After the pope first mentions that the use of condoms could be justified in certain limited cases, the author, Seewald asks: "Are you saying, then, that the Catholic Church is actually not opposed in principle to the use of condoms?"

The pope answers: "It of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution, but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality."

  1. Only on NBCNews.com
    1. OWN via Getty Images
      From belief to betrayal: How America fell for Armstrong
    2. pool via Reuters file
      US to Syria neighbors: Be ready to act on WMDs
    3. China: One-child policy is here to stay
    4. NRA: Practice Range
      New 'Practice Range' shooter game says it’s from NRA
    5. 'Gifted' priest indicted in crystal meth case
    6. AFP - Getty Images
      China's state media admits to air pollution crisis
    7. AFP - Getty Images
      French to send 1,000 more troops to Mali

The pope's words and Lombardi's explanation — while not changing the Catholic ban on contraception — were nonetheless greeted as a breakthrough by liberal Catholics, AIDS activists and health officials.

"For the first time the use of condoms in special circumstances was endorsed by the Vatican and this is good news and good beginning for us," said Margaret Chan, director-general of the World Health Organization.

"It is a marvelous victory for common sense and reason, a major step forward toward recognizing that condom use can play a vital role in reducing the future impact of the HIV pandemic," said Jon O'Brien, head of the U.S. group Catholics for Choice.

"This is a significant and positive step forward taken by the Vatican," said UNAIDS Executive Director Michel Sidibe. "This move recognizes that responsible sexual behavior and the use of condoms have important roles in HIV prevention."

The Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report.

Video: Pope takes new position on condoms

  1. Transcript of: Pope takes new position on condoms

    NATALIE MORALES, anchor: The pope is addressing difficult issues facing the Catholic Church , including condom use in a book that comes out tomorrow. NBC 's Kerry Sanders already has a copy and he joins us now from Miami . Kerry , good morning.

    KERRY SANDERS reporting: Well, good morning, Natalie . Here is the book, " Light of the World ," by the Pope Benedict XVI , and it's about 200 pages long, but it's near the end where he talks about condom use that will draw the most attention among America 's 68 million Catholics . The book is simply questions and answers, Pope Benedict XVI sat with journalist Peter Seewald in what the Vatican says was an open forum to ask any questions, and it's there on page 118, a question about AIDS in Africa , should condoms be used to prevent the spread of that disease? In one of the longest answers in the book, the pope says in part, "There may be a basis in the case of some individuals, as perhaps when a male prostitute uses a condom. The church of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution, but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality." Was that the pope endorsing the use of condoms?

    Father JOSEPH FESSIO: No, it's not. But it sounds dangerously close, doesn't it?

    SANDERS: Father Joseph Fessio is the publisher of the pope's new book. He's also a longtime friend. When you hear that already the word is out that the pope is endorsing the use of condoms in limited situations.

    Father FESSIO: Right. He's saying it's immoral, but he's saying someone could do it in a particular case having an intention of causing less harm, and that could be a first little step towards a more moral life. But that does not say, 'OK, go ahead use condoms, it's all right.'

    SANDERS: In the book, the pope answers every question he was asked, including some very direct difficult questions about the sex abuse scandal in the

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments