Image: Students in a classroom in Arnsberg, Germany
Julian Stratenschulte  /  EPA
The PISA exam is one of a handful of tests that compare educational levels across nations, and is considered to be the most comprehensive.
updated 12/7/2010 7:17:03 PM ET 2010-12-08T00:17:03

United States students are continuing to trail behind their peers in a pack of higher performing nations, according to results from a key international assessment.

Scores from the 2009 Programme for International Student Assessment released Tuesday show 15-year-old students in the U.S. performing about average in reading and science, and below average in math. Out of 34 countries, the U.S. ranked 14th in reading, 17th in science and 25th in math.

Those scores are all higher than those from 2003 and 2006, but far behind the highest scoring countries, including South Korea, Finland and Singapore, Hong Kong and Shanghai in China and Canada.

'Brutal truth'
"This is an absolute wake-up call for America," U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan said in an interview with The Associated Press. "The results are extraordinarily challenging to us and we have to deal with the brutal truth. We have to get much more serious about investing in education."

    1. Hoffman withdrew $1,200 hours before death: sources

      Philip Seymour Hoffman withdrew a total of $1,200 from an ATM at a supermarket near his New York City apartment the night before he was found lifeless in his bathroom with a syringe still in his left arm, sources told NBC News.

    2. NYC mayor will skip St. Pat's parade over gay ban
    3. Indiana man back home 18 years after abduction
    4. 32 states in the path of another wild storm
    5. Judge vows quick ruling on Va. marriage ban

The PISA exam is one of a handful of tests that compare educational levels across nations, and is considered to be the most comprehensive. The test focuses on how well students are able to apply their knowledge in math, reading and science to real-life situations. Some 470,000 students took the test in 2009 in 65 countries and educational systems, from poor, underdeveloped nations to the most wealthy.

Student performance on international assessments is considered especially relevant as today's high school graduates enter a global job market, where highly skilled workers are in increasing demand.

The United States' mediocre scores on the PISA exam have repeatedly been highlighted by the Obama administration and others pushing for education reform. A number of countries have made significant improvements in recent years, while the U.S. has made only incremental advancements.

Grim figures
Between 1995 and 2008, for example, the United States slipped from ranking second in college graduation rates to 13th, according to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, the Paris-based organization that develops and administers the PISA exam. Of 34 OECD countries, only 8 have a lower high school graduation rate.

Responding to the grim figures, President Barack Obama has set a goal for the U.S. to have the highest proportion of students graduating from college in 2020.

"We live in a globally competitive knowledge based economy, and our children today are at a competitive disadvantage with children from other countries," Duncan said. "That is absolutely unfair to our children and that puts our country's long term economic prosperity absolutely at risk."

The impact of improving math, reading and science scores could be radical: A recent OECD study with Stanford University projected that if the U.S. boosted its average PISA scores by 25 points over the next 20 years, there would be a gain of $41 trillion in the U.S. economy over the lifetime of the generation born in 2010.

  1. Most popular

The 2009 exam had an extra focus on reading, and looked at how factors such as family background, equity of resources, and governance influence educational outcomes.

The top performers in reading were South Korea, Finland, Hong Kong and Shanghai in China, Singapore, Canada, New Zealand, Japan and Australia.

The gap between the highest performing countries and the United States is stark — students in Shanghai, for example, had an average score of 556 points in reading, 56 points higher than the 500-point average reached by United States students. Shanghai students also posted the highest score in math, with an average of 600 points, 113 points higher than the 487 point U.S. average.

Video: Duncan: ‘Long way to go’ on education reform (on this page)

OECD Secretary-General Angel Gurria cited ongoing evaluations, an emphasis on the importance of education, and a curriculum that is relevant to everyday life as reasons for the Chinese success.

"They don't only produce children who know the matters by heart," Gurria said. "They're educated to understand and face the challenges of real life."

He noted that the Chinese scores were strong in all three subject areas.

"That speaks about who is going to be leading tomorrow," Gurria said.

The Shanghai and Hong Kong results are certainly unrepresentative of China as a whole — additional results from other regions will be released next year, but Andreas Schleicher, head of the Indicators and Analysis Division at the OECD said he didn't expect much variation.

The report also notes that the GDP per capita in Shanghai is well below the OECD average — highlighting another finding of the study: Low national income does not necessarily signify poor educational performance. South Korea, another top performer, also has a GDP below the OECD average.

Newsweek: Why Michelle Rhee isn't done with school reform

"While national income and educational achievement are still related, PISA shows that two countries with similar levels of prosperity can produce very different results," Gurria said. "This shows that an image of a world divided neatly into rich and well-educated countries and poor and badly education countries is now out of date."

  1. Only on
    1. OWN via Getty Images
      From belief to betrayal: How America fell for Armstrong
    2. pool via Reuters file
      US to Syria neighbors: Be ready to act on WMDs
    3. China: One-child policy is here to stay
    4. NRA: Practice Range
      New 'Practice Range' shooter game says it’s from NRA
    5. 'Gifted' priest indicted in crystal meth case
    6. AFP - Getty Images
      China's state media admits to air pollution crisis
    7. AFP - Getty Images
      French to send 1,000 more troops to Mali

The United States spends more per student, on average, than other countries. In the 2009 PISA study, only Luxembourg spent more per student. The report notes that countries like Estonia and Poland perform at about the same level as the United States, while spending less than half the amount per student.

"I think we have to invest in reform, not in the status quo," Duncan said.

The PISA study does not look to draw cause-and-effect relationships, but does highlight some findings about what the top performing countries tend to have in common.

Schleicher noted that some of the top systems are centralized, while others are very decentralized. There was also much variation in class sizes, with some of the best performers finding success in putting quality teachers in larger classes. But in each case, teachers are subject to evaluations and have a high standing in society. Also, schools have a degree of autonomy in determining their curriculum — but are also held accountable.

"In other words, autonomy without accountability would be a very bad outcome," he said.

Common academic standards
He said many of the things the United States is doing, such as developing common academic standards and smarter assessment systems, are important, positive changes.

"What we have seen from other countries doing similar things is those initiatives do pay off in the longer term," Schleicher said.

The study found that the best school systems were also the most equitable, meaning students from disadvantaged backgrounds were just as likely to do well academically. In the U.S., 17 percent of the variation in student performance was found to be related to a pupil's background — compared to 9 percent, for example, in Canada.

The report notes that Canadian 15-year-olds, on average, perform more than one school year ahead in math than 15-year-olds in the United States, and more than a half year ahead in reading and science. Canada, like the U.S., has a decentralized education system.

"Canada's experiences raise questions about why the United States has so far not equaled the performance of it northern neighbor," the report states.

Newsweek: Why education reform could happen

Mexico had the lowest reading score among OECD member countries, with an average of 425 points — the equivalent of more than two school years behind the highest member score. Among all 2009 participants, there was a gap of 242 points between the highest and lowest reading scores — equal to more than six years of schooling.

Mexico was commended for reducing the number of low performers in reading, and for improving math scores.

Gurria said the report's overall message is that, "Even in this crisis and even with the expenditure cuts, keep on supporting the education but also look at what successful systems have in common. They all can be very different but they have in common a number of features that can really make for better systems."

Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: China schools U.S. in standardized test

  1. Closed captioning of: China schools U.S. in standardized test

    >>> now to the news today on our schools. part of our continuing coverage of "education nation." every three years, 15 year olds all over the planet take a standardized test that has become a respected benchmark measure of student achievement . well, students in shanghai in china took the test for the first time and the results they got are raising new questions about the schools in this country. our report tonight from our education correspondent rahema ellis.

    >> we'll start now with --

    >> reporter: for american studentses the writing is on the wall and it's not good. the latest results from pisa, the international test of 15 year olds in 65 countries, shows among the 34 top- developed nations american kids are average. the u.s. scored 14th in reading, 17th in science and 25th in math. slightly higher than the last time the test were given. but the really stunning news comes from china, and the province of shanghai, where students scored better than anyone else in the world after taking the test for the first time. overall, of the top six performers, asia dominates.

    >> two generations ago you knew if a nation was rich it was well educated but today that doesn't work.

    >> reporter: how is asia getting better results? longer school days , better educated teachers and a culture that values education . the obama administration has put billions of dollars to ward education reform but these test results, officials say, are yet another wake-up call.

    >> other countries are investing more. they are investing smarter and putting more resources behind the children in the community that need the most help and they are outeducating us today. that's the brutal truth.

    >> reporter: education analysts stress the scores are not just a measure of learning by roet. instead, the pisa tests imagination, creativity and thinking outside the box and experts say it could take less than a decade for shanghai's success to be replicated across china.

    >> the rest of the world had better be aware that china in the future is not just going to be producing cheap plastic toys . they are going to be outcompeting us in everything that requires brain power .

    >> and one analyst says china's results on these tests could be likened to the russians launching sputnik in 1957 . that was a wake-up call to the united states and a call to action .

    >> i'm tempted to ask how many wake-up calls we need but we'll leave that for your next visit. scary story but a good story tonight, thank you.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments