Stephanie Pappas
One of 27 mice with two fathers created in the lab by MD Anderson geneticist Richard Behringer.
updated 12/30/2010 10:58:49 AM ET 2010-12-30T15:58:49

The problem with the mice with two fathers is that they're distractingly adorable. Sure, they're a mean feat of genetic engineering and a possible first step on the long road toward gay couples creating biological children. But with their tiny bewhiskered faces and itty-bitty paws, it's hard to ignore: This is scientific progress at its cutest.

I came to this conclusion while holding one of the mice in a basement lab here at MD Anderson Cancer Center. The mice are a reproductive first: Instead of having chromosomes from both a mother and a father, these critters get all of their DNA from two dads. Researchers led by MD Anderson geneticist Richard Behringer announced the existence of the mice Dec. 8 in the journal Biology of Reproduction. When I found out the babies were still alive and thriving, I knew I had to meet them.

Babies from two daddies
Behringer, a soft-spoken man who seems to choose every word with care, was kind enough to let me do just that. We met in Behringer's eighth-floor office, which contains, among other things, a butterfly net and a copy of Dan Brown's "The Da Vinci Code." When I mentioned the latter, which was wedged between "Manipulating the Mouse Embryo: A Laboratory Manual" and Lewis Thomas' "The Lives of a Cell: Notes of a Biology Watcher," Behringer rolled his eyes.

  1. Science news from
    1. NOAA
      Cosmic rays may spark Earth's lightning

      All lightning on Earth may have its roots in space, new research suggests.

    2. How our brains can track a 100 mph pitch
    3. Moth found to have ultrasonic hearing
    4. Quantum network could secure Internet

"I couldn't put that stupid book down," he said.

It took Behringer and his team two years to see the mouse project through to completion. To coax viable baby mice from the genes of two males, the researchers engineered cells taken from male mice so they became stem cells that could then become any tissue. Those cells are called induced pluripotent stem cells, or iPS cells. Because of natural genetic accidents, some of these male iPS cells lose their Y chromosome, becoming XO cells with a single sex chromosome instead of the typical XY genotype.

The researchers then injected the stem cells into a regular mouse embryo, creating a sort of genetic hybrid, or chimera. The cells from the blastocysts would be normal, two-chromosomed XX cells. But the cells from the iPS injection would be single-chromosomed XO cells.

When the chimera mated with a regular male, some of their babies contained only genes from the regular male and the male iPS cells. [Graphic: How Mr. and Mr. Mouse Had a Baby ]

Image: Reporting holding mouse
LiveScience reporter Stephanie Pappas meets one of the mice with two dads.

"It's a little twisty, because it is a female giving birth, and it is her eggs," Behringer said. "But genetically, it's his genome."

Brown and black mice
With the backstory explained, we headed downstairs to meet the mice. After a ride in a rodent-scented elevator (imagine the smell of a vet's office), it was off to the locker rooms, where one of Behringer's graduate students helped me suit up for my visit. No one goes into the live animal area without shoe-covering booties, a long yellow smock, gloves, a surgical cap and a face mask. The precautions aren't to protect humans, the grad student explained; they're to keep the mice safe from any bugs we might carry.

The mice reside in a room full of long metal shelves, all stacked with amber-colored cages. Behringer selected two cages, which we took to a spare room next door for a closer look.

Even for a novice, it was easy to tell which mice had two fathers and which came from a more traditional parentage. That's because Behringer and his team used brown mice to create the male stem cells that contribute to the two-fathers' genome. The normal embryo they injected those stem cells into came from a black mouse. So the babies genetically related to the embryo are black, while those genetically related to the stem cells are brown.

The daddy-only mice are completely normal, Behringer said. They certainly act no different from their black counterparts, sniffing around their cages and pulling themselves up the sides like they're doing chin-ups. I held one in my hand, and it sniffed my glove thoroughly before peering down at its cage mates with black, bulgy eyes. [Photo: Mouse with two daddies ]

The research team produced 27 of the double-daddy mice, and Behringer said he'll likely mate some of them to demonstrate that they're fertile (there's no reason they shouldn't be, he said). He's now working to see if he can take stem cells that have lost their second sex chromosome (the X-only iPS cells used back in the beginning of the mouse experiment) and put a replacement chromosome back in. In mice, offspring with just one X chromosome — an XO genotype, in other words — do just fine. In humans, most embryos with only one sex chromosome die. Those that do survive with an XO genotype have Turner syndrome. Women with Turner syndrome are infertile and may have other health problems.

If the transfer techniques work, scientists could start with male cells, turn them into XO stem cells, and then add in new X chromosomes, effectively turning a male body cell into a female stem cell.

Hurdles for humans
Solving the Turner syndrome problem would get the procedure past one barrier for use in humans, but there are two other major hurdles, Behringer said, "and they're big ones."

  1. Most popular

First, the induced stem cells used have to be medically safe, a standard not yet passed in humans. (Induced pluripotent stem cells have a tendency to become cancerous, even in mice.) The second problem is turning a stem cell into an egg or a sperm. (In the case of two men reproducing, you'd want an egg.)

The chimera mice Behringer and his team created are essentially a living, breathing way to turn stem cells into eggs, but with the legal and ethical issues surrounding human chimeras, the idea is a "non-starter," Behringer said. "You won't make a human chimera."

That means it's back to the lab to figure out how to make a switch from stem cell to sex cell in the laboratory. Researchers have made progress, getting stem cells to a precursor "primordial germ cell" stage, but they haven't figured out how to keep the cells alive and growing.

"That's why it's really important to do basic research on germ cell development at all these different stages to understand what are the molecules that regulate this process," Behringer said. "If you knew that, you could start mimicking it."

Even if scientists can overcome all of the technical barriers, it won't be so easy to remove women from the reproductive equation. After all, even the mice with two fathers aren't precisely motherless.

"You need a uterus," Behringer said, adding dryly, "People always forget this."

You can follow LiveScience Senior Writer Stephanie Pappas on Twitter @sipappas

© 2012 All rights reserved.

Explainer: The 2010 Weird Science Awards

  • Atala et al., PNAS / WFUBMC
    A researcher injects cells from a rabbit's penile erectile tissue into a scaffold (top photo), a procedure which results in a functional rabbit penis (bottom photo).

    That's one small step for rabbit penises, and potentially one giant hop for restorative surgery. An experiment that gave rabbits lab-grown penises capable of fathering offspring won the most votes in's 2010 Weird Science Awards contest. Cells of penile tissue were grown on scaffolds of cartilage. When the creations took on the right shape, they were grafted onto rabbits that had their penises removed. After the transplants, the rabbits were able to breed ... like rabbits. The procedure could someday be used to heal humans as well. The photos at right show an experimenter working on the penile tissue, and an X-ray image of the restored penis.

    Click "Next" to see the nine other Weird award-winners for 2009-2010, and click on the highlighted links to learn more.

  • Fruit bats get kinky

    Image: Fruit bat sex
    Tan et al. / PLoS ONE

    Researchers report that female Chinese fruit bats use oral sex to prolong the pleasure for their partners. The study suggests that there may be an evolutionary advantage to at least some types of kinky sex in the animal world. But can you imagine being the researcher with the job of watching bat porn?

  • Is the future trying to avert our doom?

    Image: LHC
    Martial Trezzini  /  AP

    Why did it take so long to get the world's most powerful particle-smasher up and running? Two scientists suggested it might be because the Large Hadron Collider was about to create phenomena so catastrophic that the future sent a cosmos-altering signal back in time to disrupt its operation. The research wasn't taken all that seriously when it came out, and since then the LHC was restarted without incident.

  • Octopus builds mobile home

    Image: Octopus
    R. Steene

    It sounds like a spin-off from "The Little Mermaid" or "Spongebob Squarepants": An octopus builds a mobile home under the sea by stacking up coconut shells. It moves in ... and then it carries the whole heap across the seafloor. "It was an extremely comical sight," said marine biologist Julian Finn, who spotted the behavior off the Indonesian coast. "I never laughed so hard underwater." Let's just hope those clever cephalopods don't develop opposable thumbs. That won't be such a laughing matter.

  • Researchers clone dogs that glow

    Image: Dog
    Seoul National University  /  AP

    Awww, how cute! South Korean scientists cloned a litter of genetically engineered dogs that glow red under ultraviolet light. Like an earlier experiment involving glowing cats, this isn't aimed at creating glow-in-the-dark pets. Rather, it's a proof of concept for procedures that could help develop treatments for genetic diseases in humans. If you can add the coding to make fluorescent protein, maybe you can add the coding to fix a genetic flaw.

  • Gay penguins make good dads

    Image: Penguins
    Focke Strangmann  /  AP

    German zookeepers in Bremerhaven had a problem on their hands when penguin parents rejected one of their eggs. To solve it, they placed the egg in a nest shared by two male penguins. The pair is one of three same-sex couples that have tried to mate at the zoo. The males incubated the egg for 30 days and continued to care for the chick after it hatched. Homosexual behavior has been documented in many animal species. "Sex and coupling in our world don't always have something to do with reproduction," the zoo said.

    Video:'s Dara Brown reports on the gay penguin parents.

  • Huge blob lies deep beneath Nevada

    Image: Crossing the Great Basin
    J.D. West / Silverheels Photography

    You wouldn't know it by driving through the Great Basin in Nevada, but researchers have detected a huge blob of highly compressed rock that is dripping like honey, extending from a depth of about 47 miles to at least 310 miles beneath the surface. The blob is 30 to 60 miles across, scientists say. But don't worry, Nevadans: This blob isn't expected to cause earthquakes - or rise up and destroy Las Vegas.

  • Nude 'Mona Lisa' surfaces

    Image: Mona Lisa
    Museo Ideale Leonardo Da Vinci

    Art historians have long suspected Leonardo da Vinci painted more than one version of his famous "Mona Lisa," and now a painting with much more Mona has surfaced. The painting, which portrays its subject nude from the waist up, had been hidden for almost a century within the wooden walls of a French cardinal's library. Experts are looking into whether this particular work, now on display in the Tuscan town of Vinci, was actually painted by the master.

  • Galileo's fingers and tooth found

    Image: Galileo's finger

    Was that any way to treat a genius? Back in 1737, Galileo Galilei's admirers removed three fingers, a vertebra and a tooth from the astronomer's body when his corpse was being moved to a new tomb. The vertebra and one of the fingers were recovered soon afterward, but the whereabouts of the tooth and the other two fingers were a mystery. Recently, however, the relics turned up in a container that was auctioned off to a private collector. Now the Galilean body parts, including the finger shown at right, will be put on display at the Museum of the History of Science in Florence.

  • Fragrances pay tribute to dead celebs' DNA

    Spotlight On Marilyn
    Hulton Archive  /  Getty Images file

    Let's get one thing straight: MyDNAFragrance's "Antiquity" line of perfumery will not make you smell like Marilyn Monroe did when she was alive, and certainly not like her mortal remains. Rather, the "Marilyn" fragrance is mixed up from ingredients that are coded to capture the "essence" of the movie star's mitochondrial DNA. Other scents pay tribute to Albert Einstein, Joan Crawford, Katharine Hepburn, Michael Jackson and Elvis Presley. The company behind the scents says the process is "very scientific," but others might well conclude that the whole exercise smells like a gimmick.

    Click here for the 2009 Weird Science Awards


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments