John Edwards
Gerry Broome  /  AP
Former presidential candidate John Edwards is seen with his daughter Cate following a court appearance in Winston-Salem, N.C. on June 3.
updated 6/5/2011 3:15:39 PM ET 2011-06-05T19:15:39

The legal case against two-time presidential candidate John Edwards focuses on where to draw the line between the public and private in a politician's life, a divide he riskily straddled throughout his entire career and family life.

Edwards isn't alone. The private activities and concerns of public officials increasingly seem to be pulled or pushed into the public arena. Is that Rep. Anthony Weiner modeling his underwear? Donald Trump and Sarah Palin use a knife and fork to eat pizza! Which school did President Barack Obama pick to go all the way in college hoops?

These things don't reveal much about their qualifications to lead, yet they fascinate Americans.

Edwards, a millworker's son, was a master at honing an image of his private life for public consumption.

  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California
Story: A disgraced but determined Edwards readies for new trial

There was much to draw the public to Edwards and his family that seemed so full of youthful vibrancy. He had a whip-smart wife who was at least his equal in political talent and a daughter getting her Ivy League education. The tow-headed youngest daughter and son coaxed smiles out of voters and even from the journalists invited to board the family's campaign bus, eat their snacks and join their sing-alongs. The way that the Edwardses dealt with their son Wade's death in an auto accident won sympathy.

But from the start, there were ruses. Edwards' chief criminal accuser, former aide Andrew Young, writes in his book how Edwards would drive a beat-up Buick Park Avenue while on campaign business, stashing his BMW and Lexus to keep up the "everyman" image.

Now the central dispute over his indictment on felony charges is whether money that two of his supporters spent to keep his mistress in hiding were campaign contributions that should have been reported publicly, as prosecutors say, or private gifts from friends, as Edwards' lawyers claim.

Edwards' team says the payments were to keep the affair a secret from hurting his cancer-stricken wife. The government alleges they were a scheme to keep the child conceived by Edwards and Rielle Hunter a secret from the public to protect his White House ambitions.

'Family man' image centerpiece of presidential run
"A centerpiece of Edwards' candidacy was his public image as a devoted family man," the indictment of Edwards says. "The communication strategy developed by Edwards' campaign stressed the importance of publicizing, among other things, 'that (Edwards') family comes first.'"

Story: Edwards pleads not guilty to felony charges in NC

That is a reference to the communications plan Edwards' advisers wrote in advance of the 2008 nominating race, when the former North Carolina senator was coming off a losing race as vice presidential nominee to Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., on the 2004 ticket.

The undated document, turned over to prosecutors and provided to The Associated Press by a person involved in the investigation, stressed that "JRE" — the initials Edwards' staffers often used to refer to him — had a unique chance to show Americans how he "shares their everyday values."

"JRE is a household name, and we have a remarkable opportunity to give voters a richer understanding of just who John Edwards is — the man, not the politician," the plan said. President George W. Bush "of course, has done a tremendous job in this regard — in 2000, among many other things, people knew he liked to clear brush, that he loved baseball, that he loved his wife, and that he had overcome personal adversity. "

It recommended that Edwards use every chance to attend activities with his family, such as going to a theme park, rodeo or high school football games. "These do not need to be advertised to the press," it said. "Word will get out on its own. And hearing about things like this from your friend or neighbor is much more powerful than a staged photo-op on the 6 p.m. news. We should do this AS OFTEN as possible."

It also suggested that a book by his wife, Elizabeth, would help the effort. She ended up writing "Saving Graces," published in September 2006. That book and a second published after her husband's campaign was over and his philandering exposed endeared her to many as a woman of strength who gracefully dealt with hardships, even the cancer that would kill her. Meanwhile, campaign operatives whispered behind the scenes that Elizabeth could often be cruel and demanding.

While the campaign communications plan stressed Edwards' devotion to family and Elizabeth, he was secretly spending time in the lead-up to the campaign with his videographer.

"In the same way that so many know that JRE is the son of a mill worker and the first person in his family to go to college (which we cannot repeat enough), we need people to know:

"— that his family comes first,

"— that he and Elizabeth have overcome tremendous challenges and adversity,

"— that faith has been an important part of his life,

"— what his friends think about him, and

"— what he likes to do for fun."

Even disregarding the National Enquirer reports during the campaign about Edwards' affair, which he denied, there were other signs the public image of his private life was not as it seemed.

While Edwards' campaigned on a fight against poverty and the "Two Americas" of the haves and have-nots, it was disclosed that he was getting $400 haircuts, building a 28,000-square foot home and consulting work for a hedge fund that catered to the wealthy.

Edwards' lies eventually alienated most of his one-time supporters and advisers and demolished his political career. Now he really does have more time for family, and even now it is still part of his public image.

As he left federal court Friday in a crush of media photographers, his daughter Cate was by his side.

Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Timeline: John Edwards

Video: Edwards case boils down to: 'Was it criminal?'

  1. Closed captioning of: Edwards case boils down to: 'Was it criminal?'

    >>> the government overreached in its indictment former presidential candidate john edwards . edwards is accused of using campaign funds to hide an extramarital affair . tonight even those with no love for john edwards are scratching their heads. more about this. lisa.

    >> reporter: good evening, lester. this indictment put an exclamation point on john edwards stunning political fall. today there was unusual criticism, not of him but of the justice department . in the state which launched john edwards once promising political career, banner headlines today and condemnation.

    >> in public opinion, he's lost. and i think rightfully so, because what he did was wrong.

    >> he doesn't seem to comprehend right from wrong.

    >> edwards spent the day out of sight with his children at the family estate. a friend of his wife elizabeth , who died six months ago of breast cancer , told nbc that despite john's betrayal, nobody wanted him to face criminal charges . she said elizabeth 's friends worry about the impact on the children. emma claire and jack and hope the case never comes to trial. the charges center on almost a million dollars secretly provided by two wealthy donors and used to keep edwards mistress, rielle hunter and their child hidden away in lavish homes and on private jets while he ran for president. the government argues even though the payments did not go to his campaign, they amounted to unlawful campaign contributions meant to keep his candidacy viable. edwards lawyer say the money was a gift from friends to help hide the affair from elizabeth . the indictment has triggered unusual criticism of the justice department , even among those usually pleased to see a politician prosecuted.

    >> i think that john edwards is a lousy human being but i think this is a really lousy and flimsy criminal case .

    >> reporter: a " washington post " editorial said it is troubling that the justice department would choose to devote its scares resources to pursuing this questionable case.

    >> i did not break the law. and i never, ever thought i was breaking the law .

    >> reporter: for this to be a criminal violation, prosecutors also must show edwards knew he was breaking the law .

    >> i think this is going to be a tough case for the government to prove. i by no means think it's a slam-dunk.

    >> reporter: still some experts argue this case is critical to cracking down on campaign abuses.

    >> what the government says is there has to be a line. john edwards crossed that line. we believe it's criminal behavior , and that's why we saw an indictment.

    >> reporter: this case was thoroughly reviewed by the justice department and prosecutors insist they have a strong case and can prove that edwards knowingly broke the law. lester.

    >> lisa meyers in raleigh for us tonight. thank you.

    >>> a developing story tonight the


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments