Image: Timothy Geithner
Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner responds to lawmakers during a House Financial Services Committee hearing on mortgage finance reform, on Capitol Hill, March 1, 2011.
updated 7/5/2011 12:13:27 PM ET 2011-07-05T16:13:27

If Timothy Geithner steps down as Treasury secretary, it would spotlight an increasingly apparent liability for the Obama administration as it searches for a way out of the economic crisis — the weakness of its bench on economic and financial services policy, where a number of crucial vacancies loom at a fragile time for the financial system.

While the administration's economic attention has been consumed by the struggle to strike a budget-cutting deal that would lift the debt limit before the economy is further rattled by the threat of a default, critics have been complaining that there is little attention or manpower devoted to other pressing issues. Having to take time and energy away from limited resources to focus on replacing a Treasury secretary would only add to those problems, analysts said Friday.

“It makes matters worse,” said William Longbrake, an executive in residence at the University of Maryland and the former vice chairman of Washington Mutual. “What about the rest of the economics team? There doesn’t seem to be a whole lot there to actually help the president formulate good sound economic policies as well as good sound political strategy. Everywhere I look, the people who have been guiding the president’s economic policy are all either departed or shortly will depart.”

    1. What We Learned: It's All Over Now Full story
    2. Inslee Wins WA GOV Race
    3. House Dems Barber, Bera Gain After More Canvassing
    4. Previewing the Sunday Shows
    5. Insiders: Look to Florida for Strongest 2016 GOP Candidate

It is well known that Austan Goolsbee, the chairman of the President’s Council of Economic Advisers, is on his way out; Jared Bernstein, Vice President Joe Biden’s top economic adviser, has already left; and Jeffrey Goldstein, the Treasury’s undersecretary for domestic finance, also has announced his exit.

But what has gotten far less attention is that the administration has put little emphasis on new solutions to the painful housing correction, and has almost no permanent financial regulators in charge of implementing all the reforms Congress passed last year that were intended to protect taxpayers from another financial catastrophe like the one that cost so many people their jobs, homes, and retirement savings.

Video: Chuck’s First Read (on this page)

Michael Barr, the former Treasury assistant secretary for financial institutions, was looked to as a surrogate leader on financial reform and was known as an outspoken advocate for foreclosure mitigation even before he joined the administration. His position has not been replaced since he left last year, and no one in the administration is seen as taking up the same mantle.

    1. Another 150 Hillary Clinton Emails Had Classified Info, State Dept. Says Full story
    2. Obama Renamed Mount McKinley. Ohio Isn’t Happy.
    3. The Anti-Establishment Candidate Challenging Donald Trump
    4. How Donald Trump Uses Instagram to Troll Jeb Bush
    5. Women Leaders Around the World

There is also the shortage of two governors on the Federal Reserve Board and the lack of permanent heads in place at the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Federal Housing Finance Agency, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and Federal Housing Administration. Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Vice Chairman Marty Gruenberg has been named to succeed Sheila Bair as FDIC chief, but his Senate confirmation process has not begun.

In the meantime, the administration is only able to focus fully on one issue at a time, and it is taking its toll on other financial policy matters.

“Everything is falling way behind schedule and I don’t see them picking it up; people are leaving rather than coming,” said Dean Baker, a co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. “It’s a really big problem in the sense that nothing is getting done. The issues don’t go away. It just means that they fester or others take the lead ... For example, you have the mortgage suits, where I guess the state attorneys general are taking the lead; I’m not sure what role the administration has played.”

But Bernstein, Biden’s former adviser, said he thought it was typical for a Treasury secretary’s tenure to be about one term and that the vacancies in the administration should not be considered a major obstacle to implementing financial reform. Delays on financial reform usually occur in Congress, he said, and would be unaffected by the number of people on the president’s economic team.

Finding a candidate willing to go through the often bruising confirmation process is a bigger challenge, Bernstein said.

    1. Massachusetts Democratic Rep. Barney Frank to Retire Full story
    2. After Ignoring Iowa, Romney Ramps Up in the Hawkeye State
    3. Atlanta Woman Alleges 13-Year Affair With Cain
    4. QUICK TAKE: Filibuster Likely Over Payroll-Tax Cut
    5. Obama Threatens Veto of Defense Authorization Bill

“They’d have to have thick skin to get through the confirmation hearing,” he said. “Ideally, someone who has market credibility that isn’t necessarily a person of the markets, because you need a Treasury secretary who — I think Geithner has this quality — you need a Treasury secretary who appreciates the connection between Wall Street and Main Street. The Treasury secretary can’t be there just to advocate for banks and financial markets, they have to make sure the economy is reaching all corners.”

Indeed, the confirmation process for filling any of these vacancies could be messy.

Typically, higher-profile appointments such as Cabinet officials are met with more bipartisanship and a sense of urgency, but even Geithner had to overcome some questions about his failure to pay taxes during his confirmation hearings. Any red flag like that now so close to the next election might not be so easily overcome.

On other appointments, Republicans have already said they would oppose anyone to run the CFPB, and it remains in doubt whether any appointment can be filled there if Republicans make good on threats that they will continue to hold the Senate in session during recesses.

The GOP has succeeded in blocking Joe Smith, a North Carolina state bank commissioner, to lead the FHFA. It has also forced the administration to drop the nomination of Peter Diamond, a Nobel Prize-winning economist, to serve on the Fed.

    1. In First Foreign Policy Test of 2016, Rand Paul Rises Full story
    2. Rand Paul: 'Best Chance' to Stop Syria Measure Is In House
    3. Obama Bets the House on Syria—and Is Losing
    4. Who Really Wants McConnell to Win His Primary? Democrats
    5. Graphic: Countdown To Conflict

“It would be amazing that you are at the one-year anniversary of Dodd-Frank and, if the headlines about Geithner are true, the last man standing from the financial crisis is Ben Bernanke,” said Ed Mills, a financial policy analyst with FBR Capital Markets, referring to the Federal Reserve Board chairman, who is a holdover from the Bush administration. “I don’t think anyone would have every imagined that at a point in our history ... that you would have so few permanent people in place.”

Mills noted that filling vacancies is challenging because of the partisanship in Congress.

“The White House is in a little bit of a bind in terms of getting top-tier people willing to go through the confirmation process ... It’s a fine line that the administration is going to have to walk to find a Treasury secretary that the street is comfortable with but does not have the tarnish from the financial crisis,” he said.

But William Black, an outspoken critic of the government’s handling of the financial crisis and an associate economics and law professor at the University of Missouri, Kansas City, argued that with the economy in such a weak state, there is little incentive for Geithner to stick around to bear the blame for it. He added that Obama can get by like he has been doing by appointing an acting leader.

“The economy is obviously in very poor shape, the recovery is obviously weak, the budgetary deals that they are talking about are insane ... That means Geithner is going to be a liability on the job side,” said Black. “The president can use an acting leader and he can always bring former Fed Chairman Paul Volcker in. And then say we are adopting with my new guy, or new gal, this new initiative, and we are going to spend a lot of time on job training and infrastructure, which is what he always says,” he said sarcastically.

The article, "After Geithner, a Weak Econ Bench," first appeared in the National Journal.

Copyright 2012 by National Journal Group Inc.

Video: Chuck’s First Read

  1. Closed captioning of: Chuck’s First Read

    >> let's get right to my first -- democrats are floating a july 22nd deal leaving time for lawmakers to pass a bill and have that three-day period for everybody to look at it before the august 2nd recess. but responding to the president's fiery rhetoric from wednesday, republicans spent the day yesterday firing back.

    >> it frankly wrangles many of us to have the president engage in blame shifting when he himself is unwilling to take responsibility for his duties.

    >> con descending speech yesterday that told congress ignored the fact that he was elected as president to lead.

    >> maybe he would take a valium and come down and talk to us, it might be helpful.

    >> the president toned down his rhetoric last night at the fundraiser in philadelphia while doing a little previewing of his re-election message. take a listen.

    >> while i'm working there will be candidates doing what they do, they are going to attack. the american people are a lot less interested in us attacking each other. they are more interested in us attacking the country's problem. they want us to exchange ideas about the future. that's the contest i'm looking forward to because it's the contest that america needs and we will win.

    >> one thing to keep an eye on, since we're been covering barack obama as a presidential candidate starting in the summer of 2007 . every single summer has been a bad summer for him politically. summer of '07, summer of '08, summer '09 health care town hall , summer of '10 the oil spill. one other thing, he traveled overseas. this time he's not doing that. this time they are trying to make their summer not a political problem, trying to go on offense, that was the point of the wednesday press conference, trying to get some of this debate back on their terms because as a lot of democrats have argued, all of these debates, from the stimulus at the start of the presidency to health care , to the midterms, all of it has been done with the republicans framing the debate. they are trying to do that. we will see if this summer pays off for the president. heading into the holiday weekend, mitt romney down played the fundraisering in a stop in allentown, pennsylvania.

    >> doesn't have a primary opponent. he's going to raise a billion dollars? we're not going to raise anywhere near that kind of money.

    >> mitt romney 's campaign said his total would be less than what he raised in the first major quarter of 2007 . tim pawlenty expected to bring in less than 5 million. jon huntsman raised a little over 2 million throwing his own money at 4 million. ron paul told supporters he's raised over $4 million. the number though everybody is watching what will the michele bachmann number be? she can transfer money from the house campaign. was she able to get in the internet and direct mail money in in time? will the number be forth of 5 million? will it be north of 10? that would be somewhat of a surprise. meanwhile, a siren for the supporters of rick perry , he's scouting out a vendor pot at the straw poll . it's our understanding perry won't get into the race until after he has the national day of prayer on august 6th . the straw poll is basically a week later. he wouldn't get in before then bupt the straw poll could be a way to see if that's the launching point and he gets in sometime in late august in time for those three debates that mitt romney and company are competing in in september. meanwhile, though there are no firm numbers yet, we're expecting a big quarter from team obama . fundraisers are predict they will bring in more than the record breaking that george bush raked in in 2003 . the campaign tweeted add midnight, we're closing the books on the first chapter of the campaign with 493,697 donors. what does that mean? if he averages $200 a donor, he's going to be at awfully close to $100 million. obama did average $200 a donor the first two quarters as a candidate. campaign keeps pushing back on that. but do the math. in our look at all things independent. in battle ground states and emerging battleground states , the independent share of the voters equal to the two major parties or ahead, all courtesy of a book called how barack obama won, some guy here may have co-authored. in iowa and texas, 21%. in montana, 35%. 45% in new hampshire. bottom line is this, we know elections are won in the middle. wept strong for obama in '08. but the big question is there such a vacuum in the middle that somebody tries to fill it from the outside? we're going to talk about that later today . as bloomberg was first to reported, tim geithner has signaled to the white house that he is considering thinking about leaving the administration after the president reaches an agreement with congress to raise the national debt limit. in an appearance yesterday with former president bill clinton at the clinton global initiative event, he played down the reporting saying he'll remain in his position for the foreseeable future. we're told it's accurate geithner is thinking about it. we're also told not to read as much into as others are. it's about living in d.c., close to the president and his political team and enjoyed the town more than he expected. would end up being a big surprise if geithner did leave. think about it, confirming a new treasury secretary would be painful and difficult. it would serve to relitigate the economic policy at a time that the republican presidential campaign is getting started. and it also could serve as a signal, we're told a lot of cabinet secretaries were given a window to leave, none of them are expected to leave now until november of 2012 . at this point geithner doing this would be a real bombshell to the west wing .


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments