Image: JoNel Aleccia
By JoNel Aleccia Health writer
updated 8/19/2011 9:44:16 AM ET 2011-08-19T13:44:16

A Wisconsin firm shuttered after massive recalls of alcohol wipes blamed for illnesses and deaths is suing a vendor who canceled orders and refused payment after reports of bacterial contamination became public.

The Triad Group of Hartland, Wis., claims that a St. Louis firm breached its contract when officials from Vi-Jon Inc. canceled nearly $500,000 in orders for Germ-X, the company's popular line of antibacterial wipes and other products. In addition, Vi-Jon refused to pay Triad nearly $145,000 for products already delivered, according to a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Wisconsin.

  1. Special report: Tracking tainted wipes
    1. Michael Stravato
      Investigation finds lax oversight, rampant problems with contaminated wipes series reveals federal Food and Drug Administration officials knew about problems at Wisconsin plant for years before taking action to halt production, distribution.

    2. Smith & Nephew sues beleaguered wipe-maker
    3. Tainted wipes destroyed as firm moves forward
    4. Tainted wipe maker gets FDA nod toward reopening
    5. 11 deaths tied to alcohol prep wipes

Vi-Jon canceled its orders on Feb. 22, more than a month after Triad and its sister company, H&P Industries Inc., recalled millions of alcohol pads because of possible contamination with a rare bacterium, Bacillus cereus.

The cancellation came a week after first reported that a Houston couple had sued Triad , alleging that a contaminated alcohol pad supplied to a hospital the firm led to their son's death from a meningitis caused by Bacillus cereus.

But Triad's lawsuit alleges that Vi-Jon's particular products weren't affected and that company officials were acting "based only on speculation of contamination."

"There is no evidence of any such contamination affecting any such Germ-X products," the lawsuit contends.

Vi-Jon officials are seeking dismissal of the suit, claiming that the recalled products were similar enough to Germ-X to cause worry after a massive public recall and that the company had a right to halt its orders.

"It was required in order to protect Vi-Jon's product and reputation," the firm's response said.

Vi-Jon has contracted with the Triad Group for years, sending supplies to Wisconsin firm to be processed into Germ-X products. Before the cancellation, Vi-Jon had forecast an order of 12,000 cases of products per month for 2011, the suit said.

The latest skirmish comes weeks after Triad officials posted a $4 million penal bond, part of the first of several requirements mandated by a consent decree implemented after federal officials shut down the company in mid-June, according to a U.S. justice department spokesman.

More than $6 million in Triad products were seized by federal marshals and the firm was slapped with a permanent injunction prohibited from manufacturing or distributing medical products until it submits a reconditioning plan approved by federal regulators.

At least nine lawsuits have been filed in multiple states by people who claim that contaminated wipes and other Triad products led to life-threatening illnesses. Two lawsuits, including the Houston complaint, say the products caused death.

A lawyer for Vi-Jon said the company doesn't comment on pending lawsuits; officials from Triad did not immediately respond to requests for comment from News of the lawsuit was first reported by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel newspaper.

© 2013 Reprints


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments