RR Auction
The papers of R. Finley Hunt, a dentist with a passion for flight, describe scenarios where flying machines bombed Federal troops across Civil War battlefields.
updated 9/12/2011 7:26:57 PM ET 2011-09-12T23:26:57

While Rebel and Union soldiers still fought it out with bayonets and cannons, a Confederate designer had the foresight to imagine flying machines attacking Northern armies. He couldn't implement his vision during the war, and the plans disappeared into history, until resurfacing at a rare book dealer's shop 150 years later.

Now those rediscovered designs have found their way to the auction block, providing a glimpse at how Victorian-era technology could have beaten the Wright Brothers to the punch.

The papers of R. Finley Hunt, a dentist with a passion for flight, describe scenarios where flying machines bombed Federal troops across Civil War battlefields. Hunt's papers are set to go up for sale at the Space and Aviation Artifacts auction during the week of Sept. 15-22, giving one lucky collector a chance to own a piece of an alternate technological history that never came to pass.

  1. Science news from NBCNews.com
    1. NOAA
      Cosmic rays may spark Earth's lightning

      All lightning on Earth may have its roots in space, new research suggests.

    2. How our brains can track a 100 mph pitch
    3. Moth found to have ultrasonic hearing
    4. Quantum network could secure Internet

"It's incredible for someone who loves early aviation, because it poses the great question of 'What if?'" said Bobby Livingston, vice president of sales and marketing with RR Auction. "What if planes had appeared above the wilderness when (Union Gen. Ulysses S.) Grant began his campaign in the Shenandoah Valley?"

The hardback collection includes pencil drawings of wings, propellers and a multicylinder steam engine. Hunt's designs drew inspiration from his love of studying any and all flying methods found in nature, despite his own lack of professional expertise.

But Hunt found it difficult to find an engineer willing to build the device, despite getting the help of Confederate President Jefferson Davis to have the proposal considered. Letters between Hunt and a Confederate review board show that other engineers had strong doubts about the "steam flying machine."

First, the engineers said Hunt had dramatically overestimated the engine's power and ability to keep the machine flying. They also described another error in Hunt's reasoning as being "so obvious on reflection that no discussion is required."

"When they turned him down, it was over the science of it," Livingston told InnovationNewsDaily. "But they considered it, and considered it a lot."

Hunt refused to take no for an answer. The papers include another letter to Davis, wherein Hunt tries to defend his flying theories and asks for assistance from a machinist. In the end, the Confederates decided against spending money to fund the project.

Still, the Confederates did deploy several other innovative war machines. Their ironclad steamship, the CSS Virginia, fought against the USS Monitor in the world's first duel between ironclads. A Confederate submarine called the H.L. Hunley also made its mark in history as the first submarine to successfully sink an enemy ship.

Both the Union and Confederate sides also flew manned balloons to scout different battlefields.

As for Hunt, he went to Washington, D.C., and got a U.S. patent on his device after the Civil War ended in 1865. He also built several working models and was still attempting to get financing in 1872. Yet he never saw his vision take flight.

"It looks to me like he's 40 years before the Wright brothers with a rotary engine driving propellers, but I don't know how close he was," Livingston said. "He never got the money to do it."

You can follow InnovationNewsDaily senior writer Jeremy Hsu on Twitter @ScienceHsu. Follow InnovationNewsDaily on Twitter @News_Innovation, or on Facebook.

© 2012 InnovationNewsDaily.com. All rights reserved. More from InnovationNewsDaily.com.

Explainer: Eight great American discoveries in science

  • Bicentennial Fireworks Over Statue Of Liberty
    Hulton Archive  /  Getty Images

    When the colonies declared independence from Great Britain in 1776, scientists in the Americas, with a few notable exceptions, were largely dependent on Europeans — shipping botanical specimens, for example, across the Atlantic for study and classification, according to Marc Rothenberg, the agency historian with the National Science Foundation. But in the 19th century, the infrastructure was put in place for homegrown American science and engineering.

    "In the 20th century we really become an international leader," Rothenberg said. Follow along as msnbc.com takes a look back at some of the achievements and discoveries that gave the U.S. a leadership role in the sciences.

  • Benjamin Franklin experiments with electricity

    Image: Benjamin Franklin in painting
    Henry S. Sadd via LOC

    Benjamin Franklin, one of the Founding Fathers, was a man of many trades — author, printer, statesman and scientist, among others — but he’s best-known today for two images: His mug on the $100 bill, and textbook depictions of him holding a kite in a lightning storm.

    Some accounts claim that Franklin actually went out with a kite and a key in the early 1750s to verify that lighting was electrical in nature. Others say that part of the story is apocryphal. In any case, Franklin’s research led to the invention of the lightning rod, helped pave the way to batteries — and, according to Rothenberg, represented the beginning of U.S. science.

  • Joseph Henry keeps electric buzz alive

    Image: Joseph Henry

    Joseph Henry was a 19th-century scientist whose life parallels that of the English physicist Michael Faraday, who is often credited for discoveries that Henry made too. For example, in 1831, Henry discovered the principle of electromagnetic induction, which underlies the operation of generators and electric motors, but he didn't publish his results. Faraday made the same discovery at the same time, published, and generally gets the credit for the feat.

    Rothenberg noted that Henry also invented the first electric motor and became the first secretary of the Smithsonian Institution in 1846, a role in which he fostered the communication of science to the public.

  • Othniel Charles Marsh digs a course for U.S. paleontology

    Image: Othniel Charles Marsh
    Manuscripts & Archives, Yale University

    The U.S. took a leading role in the world of paleontology in the late 19th century with the many fossil discoveries credited to Othniel Charles Marsh, who spent most of his career at Yale University. He published widely on everything from fossil horses and toothed birds to a gaggle of dinosaurs. These discoveries, along with those of Marsh's longtime rival Edward Drinker Cope, helped put U.S. paleontologists on the map, according to Rothenberg.

    "From about the 1870s on it is the U.S. who is just completely leading the way in terms of paleontology with great dinosaur bones being discovered all over the place," he said.

  • Thomas Morgan Hunt puts genetics on the map

    Image: Flies
    University of Exeter

    The draft sequences of the human genome, published in 2001 by the publicly funded Human Genome Project and Craig Venter's privately funded Celera Genomics, are often hailed as one of the greatest scientific achievements of the 21st century. Perhaps so, but the field of genetics was pioneered in the early 20th century at Columbia University in Thomas Hunt Morgan's lab.

    He and his students, working on fruit flies in what was known as the "Fly Room," mapped the first genes and linked heredity with chromosomes. "Morgan and his people at Columbia are really the people who say 'Hey, there's a physical thing here that we can link to heredity,'" Rothenberg said. Hunt received the Nobel Prize for his work in 1933.

  • Edwin Hubble observes that the universe is expanding

    Image: Hubble Space Telescope

    Starting in the 1870s, some of the largest telescopes in the world were constructed in the U.S., which made the country the place for observational astronomy, according to Rothenberg. Some of the greatest discoveries belong to Edwin Hubble, who spent his time observing the stars at the Mount Wilson Observatory in California.

    In the 1920s, for example, Hubble discovered that the Milky Way is just one of many, many galaxies, an observation that forever changed how astronomers view our place in the universe. Then, in 1929, Hubble announced that the universe is expanding, based on observations of starlight from distant galaxies. The finding formed the basis of inflationary big-bang theory.

    The Hubble Space Telescope, shown here, backed up Hubble’s findings and continues the tradition of groundbreaking discoveries in observational astronomy

  • U.S. collaboration leads to the Internet

    Image: Internet access at library
    Tim Boyle  /  Getty Images file

    Former Vice President Al Gore came in for a lot of ridicule while running for president in 1999 after making a comment that was interpreted as a claim that he personally invented the Internet. He didn't. Rothenberg said the reality is that “we invented the Internet” — with “we” meaning American engineers and scientists.

    "The Internet is a partnership of the federal government and the private sector coming together," he said. Key players beginning in the 1960s include the U.S. Department of Defense and the National Science Foundation's efforts to set up computer communication networks.

    The Internet is "transformative in a way that nothing else, perhaps, has ever been," Rothenberg noted. Today, anyone can walk into a library like the one shown here and access the global network.

  • Moon landing, where science and technology meet


    On July 20, 1969, the U.S. celebrated one of its greatest technological feats by landing astronauts on the moon. As Neil Armstrong famously said while planting the first human foot on another world, "That's one small step for man; one giant leap for mankind." Rothenberg said the accomplishment represents an integration of technology with scientific discovery. "The technology leads to the discovery,” he said. “We've learned so much."

  • Ardi joins Lucy in the annals of American science

    Image: Ardi drawing
    J.H. Matternes

    American paleoanthropologist Donald Johanson's 1974 discovery of Lucy, a 3.2 million-year-old hominid named Australopithecus afarensis that walked upright, is often considered one of the greatest scientific discoveries in the field of human origins. The discovery of a 4.4 million-year-old hominid known as Ardi, short for Ardipithecus ramidus and described in a series of paper in 2009, may be an even bigger scientific breakthrough, according to Rothenberg.

    Ardi lived in woodlands and climbed on all fours in the trees, but was also capable walking on two feet — suggesting that this hallmark of human evolution occurred in the forest, not grasslands as previously believed. The discovery team, headed by Tim White of the University of California of Berkeley, said Ardi may be ancestral to Lucy. Such findings have brought scientists closer to identifying the common ancestors of chimpanzees and humans.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments