Video: How Shanghai schools stunned the world

  1. Transcript of: How Shanghai schools stunned the world

    BRIAN WILLIAMS, anchor: We are back now and we have tonight's Education Nation report. Last night on the broadcast we told you about a new report card that showed America 's students continue to struggle in terms of both math and reading. Well, tonight we go to the other side of the world , Shanghai , a city that stunned the world when students there took international exams for the first time ever and outscored every other school system on the planet. Question is, how did that happen? And what can American schools learn from what Shanghai is doing? Our chief education correspondent, Rehema Ellis , went to Shanghai to find out. She's here with us in our New York studios tonight. Rehema :

    REHEMA ELLIS reporting: Brian , they're working very hard in the schools in Shanghai . And the one thing that struck me during my visit to China is that kids there love learning, and in many ways their success in school is a direct consequence of a whole culture that really values education .

    Unidentified Woman:

    ELLIS: From the moment the teacher enters the classroom...


    ELLIS: ... Shanghai students, rooted in tradition, are ready to learn. The 900 kids at Shanghai Yucai High School have nine hour school days with just a few breaks for workouts and timeouts for eye massages to relieve stress. Kids study on weekends and during summer and winter breaks. Why do you want to study so much?

    Unidentified Student #1: Because I want to have a better future and do some contribution to our society.

    ELLIS: Everything is geared toward the all important college entrance exams .

    Mr. JIANG XUEJIN (Peking University High School): It's a test oriented education system , which means that students are taught from a very early age how to beat tests.

    ELLIS: On international exams, Shanghai scored number one across the board. American students ranked 14th in reading, 17th in science and 25th in math.

    Unidentified Teacher: What of you would like to be a business person one day, right?

    ELLIS: Teachers in Shanghai are among the highest paid educators nationwide. Shanghai is a booming city of 23 million people, but some downplay the academic success here, saying it doesn't represent education in China as a whole. This is what learning is like in most of the nation . Resources are scarce. The result, just 24 percent of rural kids go to college vs. 80 percent in Shanghai and 64 percent in the United States . Ironically, as the world studies Shanghai 's success, China is now focusing on its academic weaknesses.

    Mr. JIANG: In terms of management, artistic, creative talent, China 's tremendously lacking. And that's going to hamper China 's ability -- the economy to grow and to compete globally, especially with the United States .

    Unidentified Student #2: Maybe I'm going to be a musician or some kind of -- this is my dream.

    ELLIS: Shanghai students, the world's best test takers, are now starting to dream of being so much more. For all the hours Chinese students spend in school, that nation has yet to produce a Steve Jobs , a Mark Zuckerberg or Bill Gates . But now China is trying to open the door to that kind of academic creativity, which America has been known for. And experts say it's only a matter of time , Brian , until China gets there.

    WILLIAMS: Those high school students speaking to you in perfect English may be all we need to know.

    ELLIS: Perfect English. Absolutely.

    WILLIAMS: Rehema Ellis , thank you. Great

updated 11/2/2011 7:06:32 PM ET 2011-11-02T23:06:32

Students in this booming Chinese city shocked the world last year when they beat every other country on international exams, but Chinese educators say their success is no fluke.

“If you are a hard-working, diligent student you will succeed," said Qiu Ying Li, who has been teaching English for 20 years. "This is the secret for all Chinese students.”

At Shanghai’s Yucai High School, students put in 12-hour days – nine hours before dinner plus three after they eat. Homework is assigned every evening, even for weekends, as an essential part of students’ learning activities. And kids study during summer and winter breaks to get ready for high-stakes college entrance tests.

With all of this hard work comes stress. To help students cope, time is set aside for workouts and even eye massages.

“It’s a test-oriented education system, which means students are taught from a very early age how to beat tests,” said Jiang Xueqin, deputy principal of Peking University High School.

Students are even tested in English, which they start learning at six years old. The approach seems to be paying off.

In the last worldwide evaluation of students’ performance, administered by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), Shanghai pupils’ scores topped the charts across the board in math, science and reading. Shanghai was the only site in China where the tests were administered.

In the same test, American students ranked 25th in math, 17th in science and 14th in reading.

China has a long tradition of valuing education, seen as the major path to climb the country’s social ladder. But just a couple of decades ago, Shanghai schools were struggling, so officials launched a reform effort hinged on making the curriculum much more rigorous, and they invested heavily to do so.

“Culture may well be an asset,” Andreas Schleicher, OECD education expert, said, “but you also need to enable your asset.”

Today, this international business hub of 23 million people pours vast resources into its schools, and its teachers are among the highest paid in the nation.

When asked if student discipline is ever an issue, Luo Jian Jun, an English teacher, shot back a confused look.

“You just give your lesson and students just listen to you, maybe write down, sometimes they ask questions. No discipline problem,” Luo said.

In English class, a young man nicknamed Bill said his life revolves around school. “It’s all about studying,” he said, laughing. “I got to make money, I got to make a living.”

Another student said he pushes himself to work hard in school so he can achieve his goal of working in an organization that protects ocean creatures.

Read NBC's Rehema Ellis personal account of her visit to a Shanghai school

Schleicher, of the OECD, believes the most impressive result of Shanghai’s performance is not just its high average score, but the low variability of test scores between schools, even those in poorer districts.

A determined effort to convert weaker schools into stronger schools produced these results, as high-performing teachers and school managers were transferred to low-performing schools, either temporarily or permanently, Schleicher said.  School officials also share lesson plans, curricula, teaching methods and effective practices.

Schleicher said U.S. schools could benefit by making high-performing teachers more mobile, so disadvantaged schools could also benefit from their expertise.

Shanghai is proud of how it performed on the international tests, but experts say there is a downside to the emphasis on test taking.

Jiang believes test taking is damaging to students’ creativity, critical thinking skills and, in general, China’s ability to compete in the world.

“It can make students very narrow minded,” he said, adding that, in the 21st century, China needs the creative types its education system isn’t producing.

Jiang also points out that Shanghai, the country’s wealthiest city is the exception in China. Only 24 percent of rural Chinese kids go to college versus 80 percent in Shanghai and 64 percent in the United States. Many children walk miles every day to rundown schools – if they’re among the lucky ones who have access to a school.

“Shanghai is definitely an outlier in China,” he said.

But one quality that all Chinese students share, Jiang said, is their love of learning – a positive attitude he thinks American students should emulate.

“Chinese students love learning. They go to class and they have a real attitude that ‘education can change my life.’”

NBC News' Rehema Ellis and's Becky Bratu contributed to this report.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments