Image: Rick Perry, Mitt Romney
Phelan M. Ebenhack  /  AP
Republican presidential candidate former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, right, listens as Texas Gov. Rick Perry makes a statement during a debate Thursday, Sept. 22, 2011.
updated 9/23/2011 4:34:10 PM ET 2011-09-23T20:34:10

To hear Democrats tell it, Gov. Rick Perry's economic record in Texas is nothing more than a mirage and his views on Social Security make him "America's Most Dangerous Cowboy." In Massachusetts, President Barack Obama's allies say job creation lagged under Mitt Romney, whose policies would undermine the middle class.

Republicans won't pick a candidate to challenge Obama for months but Democrats already are working to poke holes in the two who, according to polls, are mostly likely to win the GOP nomination.

No matter who Republicans pick, the 2012 general election is all but certain to be negative given Obama's weakened standing and the sagging economy. Sharp contrasts between Obama and his GOP challenger are likely. And Obama's advisers stress that next year's election will be a "choice, not a referendum" on the president — a clear indication that the incumbent Democrat will draw bright lines between himself and the Republicans.

Video: GOP candidates clash at Florida Debate (on this page)
  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California

So Democrats are working to lay the groundwork for that choice now by highlighting the contrasts between Obama and the leading Republicans.

For now at least, the race to negatively define Perry and Romney in voters' minds is being driven by the Democratic National Committee and outside groups like Priorities USA and American Bridge, which formed following a 2010 Supreme Court ruling lifting the ban on corporate donations to political campaigns. The outfits are taking cues from Romney and Perry's tangling over Social Security, health care and the economy, while working to cast the candidates as purveyors of tax policies that led to the economic downturn.

Story: Perry, Romney struggle to define each other at GOP debate

Most of the dirty work is being left to such groups, which helps insulate Obama and his campaign from criticism of waging a negative campaign more than a year before the election. Still, they aren't entirely innocent; the White House has poked Romney on the health care measure he signed into law in Massachusetts that was the basis for the federal program conservatives loathe.

Perry: Vision tops debate skills

"This used to be a Republican idea, by the way, this whole notion of the individual mandate, and suddenly some — it's like they got amnesia," Obama said during an August visit to Cannon Falls, Minn., referring to a "governor who is running for president right now."

In an interview earlier this month with NBC News, Obama declined to critique Perry. "Well, he's been the governor of a big state, and there's no doubt he's a credible candidate, as is Mr. Romney and a whole bunch of other folks," Obama said.

Democrats are challenging Perry's argument that his economic record in Texas would serve as a template to put the nation back to work while trying to portray him as out-of-step with most Americans.

Video: Romney challenges Perry on immigration (on this page)

Perry has highlighted his efforts to cut taxes in Texas and noted that since the middle of 2009, his state accounted for more than 40 percent of the nation's job growth. But Democrats counter that many of the new jobs in Texas are low-paying and the state benefited from high oil prices and more than $17 billion that Texas government agencies and businesses received from Obama's recovery act.

Beyond the economy, Democrats want to portray Perry as beholden to special interests and a cowboy who would make former President George W. Bush seem like a moderate. A web video by American Bridge calls him "America's Most Dangerous Cowboy" and shows a montage of clips in which the Texas governor refers to Social Security as a "Ponzi scheme" and a "monstrous lie on this generation." Democrats say the position could move seniors in their direction.

Story: Romney, Perry go after each other in debate

Romney, the former Massachusetts governor who founded a venture capital firm, is routinely painted as beholden to business interests who will change his position to suit his purposes.

Democrats hope to discredit Romney's work as a business executive by pointing to the Massachusetts economy during his tenure as governor and portray him as an out-of-touch corporate titan. Massachusetts ranked 47th in the nation in job creation from 2003 to 2007 under Romney's watch, beating only Rust Belt states like Ohio and Michigan, which lost thousands of manufacturing jobs during that time, and Louisiana, which suffered in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.

Video: Chuck's first read: (on this page)

The DNC relished Romney's exchange with liberal activists at the Iowa State Fair last summer, when he declared that "corporations are people." And when Romney quipped in Tampa that he was "also unemployed," Democrats seized on it as being insensitive. In recent weeks, they have circulated reports that Romney was expanding his La Jolla, Calif., beachside home and promoted a video of Romney touring an Arizona Ford dealership, in which he told a dealer he has "a couple of Cadillacs at two different houses ... and I've got my Mustang."

Following Thursday's debate in Florida, Democrats pounced on another line from Romney — "There are a lot of reasons not to elect me. There are a lot of reasons not to elect other people on the stage" — to raise questions about Republicans' commitment to education, the environment and health care.

"The Republican candidates have repackaged the same economic policies that don't benefit the middle class and have been tried and failed," said Obama campaign spokesman Ben LaBolt.

Republicans call the strategy of sullying their top candidates an act of desperation, a sure sign that Obama will be hard-pressed to defend his record

"Because they have an unpopular candidate, the DNC and Obama campaign are trying to define the GOP candidates by going negative," said Republican National Committee spokeswoman Kirsten Kukowski. Instead of highlighting Obama's record, his campaign will try to tear down the Republican candidates' records "and attempt to ruin their personal credibility," Kukowski said.

Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Romney challenges Perry on immigration

  1. Transcript of: Romney challenges Perry on immigration

    WILLIAMS: Good evening.

    BRIAN WILLIAMS, anchor: At some point the process will result in a Republican nominee to challenge President Barack Obama . But from now until then, especially at this point in the process, it's all about those GOP debates. The candidates running behind are all aiming at the front-runner. Those toward the top are trying to stay there; and, along the way, they're hoping for that memorable moment, the quote that lives on, the devastating quip that changes the direction of the race. But also along the way, voters are watching and listening. Their every word gets studied, torn apart, debated, until at the end of the process, there's one candidate standing. We watched it all again during last night's debate. The discussion spilled over again into today. It's where we begin tonight with NBC 's Chuck Todd in Washington .

    CHUCK TODD reporting: Front-runner, Rick Perry , found himself on the defensive for his support of allowing children of undocumented Texas immigrants to get in- state college tuition.

    Governor RICK PERRY: If you say that we should not educate children who have come into our state for no other reason than they've been brought there by no fault of their own, I don't think you have a heart.

    TODD: A defense that didn't sit well with opponents last night, and also today at a conservative gathering in Florida .

    Mr. MITT ROMNEY (Republican Presidential Candidate): I think if you're opposed to illegal immigration it doesn't mean that you don't have a heart, it means that you have a heart and a brain.

    TODD: Last night's debate also gave opponents and fact checkers plenty of fodder. Michele Bachmann at first suggested the government shouldn't collect taxes.

    Representative MICHELE BACHMANN: I think you earned every dollar, you should get to keep every dollar that you earn. That's your money. That's not the government 's money.

    TODD: But then left herself an out.

    Rep. BACHMANN: Obviously, we have to give money back to the government so that we can run the government , but we have to have a completely different mindset.

    TODD: Mitt Romney denied he supported Education Secretary Arne Duncan 's Race to the Top program.

    Mr. ROMNEY: I'm not sure exactly what he's saying. I don't support any particular program that he's describing.

    TODD: But just the day before at a Miami town hall, Romney did praise the program.

    Mr. ROMNEY: Secretary Duncan has done some good things. He's the current secretary of Education. I hope that's not heresy in the room, but he, for instance, has a program called Race to the Top which encourages schools to have more choice, more testing of kids.

    TODD: The lingering moment of the night belonged to Perry during his attempt to hit Romney as a flip-flopper.

    Gov. PERRY: I think Americans just don't know sometimes which Mitt Romney they're dealing with. Is it the Mitt Romney that was on the side of -- against the Second Amendment before he was for the Second Amendment ? Was it -- was before he was before the social programs from the standpoint of he was for standing up Roe vs. Wade , before he was against Roe vs. Wade ?

    TODD: These three September debates have also exposed just how stark some of the cultural divides are between left and right. From the cheering of Perry 's death penalty record, to the shouts from the audience about whether emergency rooms should treat the uninsured?

    Unidentified Man #1: Are you saying the society should just let him die?

    Unidentified Man #2: No, what...

    TODD: To last night's jeers of a question about gays in the military .

    Mr. STEPHEN HILL (Serving In Iraq): Do you intend to circumvent the progress that's been made for gay and lesbian soldiers in the military?

    TODD: Some Republicans are concerned these audience moments might send the wrong message to swing voters.

    Unidentified Man #3: : Well, are booing a United States Marine ...

    TODD: Yeah.

    Man #3: officer. It really bothers a lot of people out there, particularly those voters that are right there in the middle.

    TODD: Back to Perry , today he tried to clean up that awkward debate moment he had with Mitt Romney saying, you know what, he's not going to be the best debater, but that isn't what this election's about. But, Brian , I can tell you this, a lot of Republicans and the so-called establishment still making phone calls to New Jersey Governor Chris Christie to see if he's interested. He publicly always says no, but he still picks up the phone and listens.

    WILLIAMS: Way early yet still in the process. Chuck Todd starting us off from our DC newsroom tonight. Chuck , thanks.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments