updated 9/24/2011 9:58:49 AM ET 2011-09-24T13:58:49

Texas Gov. Rick Perry is struggling to defend his front-runner position in the race for the Republican presidential nomination.

  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California

Republicans in early voting states, once excited about the Texas governor's presidential bid, are openly questioning the strength of his candidacy. High expectations have been met by the sudden national scrutiny that comes with the front-runner bull's-eye.

Perry is leading national polls, but he is also facing intensifying criticism from the right and left. Some Republicans in Iowa and New Hampshire are expressing doubts, especially after debates in which rivals raised questions about his record on immigration, public health and Social Security retirement benefits.

One national immigration group says Perry is finished, and conservatives are slamming his support of education benefits for illegal immigrants.

The campaign dismisses the criticism. After all, supporters say, he entered the presidential race just six weeks ago.

Video: Perry and Romney trade jabs at debate (on this page)

Things looked rosier then. Perry arrived to great fanfare and seemed poised to steal significant support from his top rival, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney. Many influential Republican activists saw Perry, with his executive experience and good jobs record, as an attractive alternative to Romney, who has struggled to win over conservatives who make up a sizeable portion of the party base.

Since then, the Texan has campaigned repeatedly in New Hampshire and Iowa, states that host the nation's first presidential voting contests in roughly four months.

And unaligned Republicans in those states — including some who backed Romney four years ago and are looking for an alternative — have watched Perry closely this month to see if the early buzz would become lasting campaign strength. But his debate performances, including bobbled attempts Thursday night in Florida at painting Romney as a flip-flopper, did not impress some influential activists.

Story: Perry, Romney struggle to define each other at GOP debate

"Perry has been doing damage to himself over the last couple weeks," said Jamie Burnett, a New Hampshire-based Republican who led Romney's political operation here four years ago but is unaligned this year. "Perry's on shaky ground, but I'm not willing to say there's no path to victory. But he's definitely not in the place he was during the first two weeks of his campaign."

Besides accusing Romney of being a flip-flopper, Perry suggested that those who oppose Texas' immigration law are heartless and he gave a wobbly response to a question on Pakistan, making him seem unprepared.

"The guy just isn't ready for prime time. It's not the issues themselves. It's how he handles them," said Doug Gross, a Des Moines lawyer who was Romney's Iowa co-chairman in 2008 but isn't backing any one candidate yet this year. "He doesn't look like a president."

Debating only one part of campaigning
Veteran Republican strategist Mary Matalin, who is not affiliated with any of the 2012 campaigns and is neutral, said that while debating is not Perry's strong suit, it's only one aspect of the early campaign.

"His support in the states that are the foundation of his strategy is not slipping," Matalin said. "Romney has been consistently really good, is solidifying his establishment support, but is far from closing the deal with conservatives."

Activists have discovered policy differences as they get to know Perry better.

He has drawn sharp criticism for requiring 6th-grade girls in Texas to be vaccinated against a sexually transmitted virus that can cause cancer, a position that frustrates libertarians and social conservatives alike. And on immigration, Perry's opposition to a border fence and support for education benefits for illegal immigrants who came to the country as children have been unpleasantly eye-opening to some in Iowa.

Video: Is Perry getting stronger? Or is he getting weaker? (on this page)

"Immigration and the vaccines are just tough sells," said former state Republican chairman Richard Schwarm, a Romney supporter in 2008 who has not yet committed to a candidate. "There are a lot of things people like about him, but those issues cause people a lot of problems."

Some national groups have been less diplomatic.

"Rick Perry is finished," said Americans for Legal Immigration's campaign arm in a statement Friday.

Perry also raised eyebrows for coming in a surprising fourth in a New Hampshire poll this week, getting just 8 percent and ranking well behind Romney while also trailing Texas Rep. Ron Paul and former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman.

Story: Democrats working to undercut Perry, Romney

Rivals are looking to take advantage of Perry's woes in Iowa.

Romney is expected to step up his campaign presence in the state after visiting only twice this year. And Minnesota Rep. Michele Bachmann is focusing on Iowa to reclaim the attention she stirred in the state before Perry entered the race.

Top Perry strategist Dave Carney said the notion the governor is floundering is "more wishful thinking from other camps."

The campaign hopes for a boost at the end of the month when it releases its quarterly fundraising totals, Perry's first such report. He is known as a prolific fundraiser and has devoted considerable energy to filling his campaign coffers. A strong showing could help quiet questions.

Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Perry’s immigration problem

  1. Closed captioning of: Perry’s immigration problem

    >>> in politico briefing, does rick perry have an immigration problem ? perry was hammered on the issue last night as other candidates ganged up on him allowing undocumented workers' children to get in-state tuition.

    >> to go to university of texas if you're an illegal alien , you get a discount. four years of college you get $100,000 discount if you're an illegal alien .

    >> if you say we should not educate children who have come into our state for no other reason than they've been brought there by no fault of their own, i don't think you have a heart.

    >> david is a national political reporter for politico. this issue has bubbled up. a texas governor running for president and we've seen with george w. bush that texas has a particular attitude because it's right on their doorstep and they seem to be much more welcoming to people from mexico coming over. this really has shown mitt romney moving farther and farther to the right.

    >> right. rick perry is not backing away from this comment. he's doubling down on it. mitt romney is trying to make this rick perry 's romney care moment. an issue that perry is at odds with his own base but perry moving forward with it. his rivals attacking him on it even today down there at the conservative political action convention continuing to hammer perry on this issue. they see it as an issue that could divide the base for him.

    >> this is what romney had to say today. he doubled down on it.

    >> my friend governor perry said if you don't agree with his position on giving in-state tuition to illegals, that you don't have a heart. if you're opposed to illegal immigration , it doesn't mean that you don't have a heart. it means you have a heart and brain.

    >> they went after him for arguing that it doesn't make sense that you can build a fence for 3,000 miles. they argued against that. that's going to be another big issue when we talk about border control .

    >> michele bachmann went at the heart of that in her cpac speech this morning. perry within the last hour took the stage down in cpac and acknowledged he didn't have a good debate. we shouldn't nominate the best debator. we need the person with the best vision. that's his counterpoint right now.

    >> michele bachmann who barely was speaking last night during the debate talking about not having a debate, she wasn't even in the middle of the action. thank you very much, david. these debates get more and more interesting.

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments