updated 7/22/2015 9:20:27 AM ET 2015-07-22T13:20:27

Date: July 21, 2015
Guest: Kenneth Blackwell, Lizz Winstead, April Ryan, Carol Lee

CHRIS MATTHEWS, HOST: I`ll fight any man in the house for a dollar.
So who`s going to take on Donald Trump?

Let`s play HARDBALL.

Good evening. I`m Chris Matthews in Washington.

Well, it`s clown car Tuesday, with the king of the clown car now
leading the parade. Donald Trump is now soaring in the Republican polls,
well above Jeb Bush and all the others.

The only question -- who`s going to take him on? Which Republican`s
going to risk a face-off with the guy and challenge with it the old rule of
never get into a peeing match with a skunk, or in this case, with Donald

Today, Trump tramped into South Carolina and pulled his old number of
picking a fight, this time with the local man, Lindsey Graham, who showed
just what happens when you take a jab at the P.T. Barnum of 21st century
American politics.

Steve Schmidt was the senior adviser to John McCain`s 2008
presidential candidate. Michael Steele was RNC chair. And Joan Walsh is
the editor-at-large with Salon. All are MSNBC political analysts.

Anyway, South Carolina senator Lindsey Graham, who`s good friends with
Senator John McCain, is going after Trump.


becoming a jackass at a time when we need to have a serious debate about
the future of the party and the country.


MATTHEWS: Well, today, Trump traveled to Graham`s home turf in South
Carolina and jabbed back.


What a stiff! What a stiff, Lindsey Graham. By the way, he`s registered
zero in the polls, zero! He`s on television all the time -- a total
lightweight. Here`s a guy, in the private sector, he couldn`t get a job,
believe me. Couldn`t get a job! And then I watch this idiot Lindsey
Graham on television today and he calls me a jackass -- He`s a jackass.


MATTHEWS: Anyway, that was just the beginning of Trump`s attack
today. Watch what happens next.


TRUMP: Then I said to myself, Hey, didn`t this guy call me, like,
four years ago? Yes. He called me four years ago, three, four years ago,
Lindsey Graham. I didn`t even know who he was. He goes, Mr. Trump, this
is Senator Lindsey Graham. I wonder if it would be possible for you to
call Fox. And he wanted to know whether or not I could give him a good
reference on "Fox and Friends," OK?

What`s this guy, a beggar? He`s, like, begging me to help him with
"Fox and Friends." So I say, OK, and I`ll mention your name. He said,
Could you mention my name? I said, Yes, I`ll -- and he gave me his number.

And I found the card! I wrote the number down. I don`t know if it`s
the right number. Let`s try it -- 202-(DELETED).


TRUMP: So I don`t know, give it a shot.


TRUMP: Your local politician, you know? He won`t fix anything, but
at least he`ll talk to you.


MATTHEWS: You know, and he really did. Trump really did give away
Senator Graham`s private e-mail address -- or phone number, actually, his
private phone number. He actually did it. Graham tweeted back, quote,
"Probably getting a new phone."


MATTHEWS: His camp also put out a statement, Graham`s, and a fund-
raising plea saying "Donald Trump continues to show hourly that he is ill-
prepared to be commander-in-chief."

Well, anyway, I don`t know where to begin, but I`ll start with you,
Michael Steele, former chair of the Republican National Committee. It
wasn`t quite as much fun when you were chair.


had this kind of...


MATTHEWS: What are the other Repubs doing now? And they`re thinking
about this. They`re -- they`re -- nobody`s paying any attention to...

STEELE: They`re not happy. They`re not happy.

MATTHEWS: ... people like Ben Carson. They`re all disappearing.

STEELE: They`re -- none of them are happy. There`s no one right now
in the Republican leadership or candidates running for office who are happy
right now.

We`re seeing the opening of every newscast, every show with Donald
Trump. And leading into this debate in two weeks` time, if this is the
continual motion, the level of frustration on that stage is going to be so
high, you will cut it with a knife.

And anything could happen. The explosion could be monumental because
they`re frustrated. They don`t know how to get in front of the story.
They don`t know how to create their own news because every microphone in
their face is, "Donald Trump said."

Lindsey Graham is raising money off of it. God bless him. He`s
taking advantage of it. He`s loving that opportunity. But there comes a
point where it`s a drag, and the question is, how long does the drag

MATTHEWS: You know, Steve Schmidt, I can`t wait to hear you because
I`m thinking if you`re driving a good-looking car down the street and
somebody`s got a junker coming out and you start getting into little
bumping matches, where you say, I`m going to lose this one because they --
his car`s already a junker. Mine`s going to be one.

If you get into a match with that guy, Trump, right now, do you lose

Look, I think this is the ultimate character test for the other 15
candidates that are in the race. This is not conservatism. This is not
what the Republican Party should be about. This has to be confronted.

Tomorrow, Rick Perry has announced that he`s going to give a speech
that does just that. We will see the candidates who have the guts, who
have the courage to lead, to communicate to Republicans that this is not
the toxic path that we want to go down.

This is opposite the virtues of goodness embodied in men like Ronald
Reagan and Dwight Eisenhower...

MATTHEWS: Yes, well, that`s...

SCHMIDT: ... and Abraham Lincoln and the giants that have sat as
members of our party in the seat of the presidency of the United States.

MATTHEWS: But that`s woulda, coulda, shoulda because right now, Trump
is leading your party in the polls, and rather dramatically. He`s way
ahead of Jeb, who everybody knows who Jeb Bush is. Everybody knows him,
and they choose Trump over him in the polls. What do you make of that?
Because that`s the reality...

SCHMIDT: Chris, you have...


SCHMIDT: Chris, you have covered American politics for a very long
time. You are a historian.

MATTHEWS: Nothing like this!


SCHMIDT: You know that these numbers -- that these numbers...

MATTHEWS: Hey, Steve, nothing like this!

SCHMIDT: ... don`t mean an awful lot at this moment in time in the

MATTHEWS: Yes, but...

SCHMIDT: We cover this like a thoroughbred horse race.

MATTHEWS: Yes, I know.

SCHMIDT: There`s a long way to go. We live in a time when trust has
completely collapsed in nearly every institution in the country. People
are fed up. They don`t think the system`s on the level.

MATTHEWS: Yes, I know.

SCHMIDT: They don`t think the political...

MATTHEWS: Trump doesn`t, either.

SCHMIDT: ... (INAUDIBLE) is on the level. And he is in the tradition
of the Roman emperors. This is bread and circuses for the masses.


SCHMIDT: And I don`t think that this will prevail, that it will last.
But we`ll see.

MATTHEWS: Joan, I just want to ask you...


MATTHEWS: I want to ask you a non-ideological question, Joan,


MATTHEWS: ... because I want your -- in this battle, who is the
fastest on their feet? Name any Republican, forget ideology or any --
who`s faster on their feet than Trump? In other words, when they get in
that debate in a couple weeks and Trump pounds them again and again,
(INAUDIBLE) he shots back. He shoots back.

WALSH: You know what? Chris...

MATTHEWS: He`s never going to let them get the last word.

WALSH: Chris Christie. This should be a good moment for Chris
Christie. Lindsey Graham has shown he`s fast on his feet. I think he`s
doing himself a lot of favors, but he doesn`t have much to lose.

I just want to take issue with something Steve`s saying. I agree it`s
early, and I don`t think Democrats should get their hopes up. He`s not
going to be the nominee. But there`s one thing that`s very different from
2012. In 2012, everybody took a turn. Herman Cain was at the top.

The thing we also said about 2012, though, was that that was a
terrible field. It had a bunch of people, and Mitt Romney.


WALSH: Nobody was ever going to break out except Mitt Romney. This
is a dream field for the Republican Party, right? We`ve got sitting
governors. We`ve got at least four. We`ve got three -- at least three --
four senators. I mean, it should be tailor-made for a great year against,
supposedly, Hillary Clinton. And they can`t get out of their own way
because of Donald Trump.

So I think it`s a little -- I think it`s -- I know Steve`s worried,
and I totally agree. I am so happy Steve is saying what he`s saying, but I
don`t know how many people are listening because they`re scared of this

MATTHEWS: I`m not afraid of anything here, Michael. And I want to go
back to Steve. I`m not afraid. The American people are paying attention
to this. The same vote they get in any other poll, they`ve given to him.


MATTHEWS: For whatever reason, they`re sending a message they want to
hear more from this guy right now. What do they want to hear? That`s what
I want to know.

STEELE: And what they want to hear is what he`s giving them, and that
is something that, whether you like it or not, whether it`s inside the
Beltway or not, is irrelevant. It`s authenticity for these folks out there
across the country who finally found someone who`s saying what they feel.

MATTHEWS: What is that?

STEELE: Well...

MATTHEWS: What is that?

STEELE: I`m angry. I`m frustrated. I`m sick and tired of these guys
pontificating on what they`re going to do when then...


MATTHEWS: Is he Howard Beale?

STEELE: ... to do something -- yes, a little bit. Yes. Absolutely.
And I think that that`s part of the momentum. You look at where he`s gone
in just a week`s time, where the gap between him and Jeb Bush -- I mean,
it`s 24 to 16.


STEELE: I mean, that`s -- that`s not something that...

MATTHEWS: Let`s take a look at...


MATTHEWS: And Steve, you previewed this. Donald Trump also took a
shot at personal hot today at former Texas governor Rick Perry, who has
called Trump a toxic demagogue. Here`s Trump.


TRUMP: I see Rick Perry the other day, and he`s so -- you know, he`s
doing very poorly in the polls. He put glasses on so people will think
he`s smart.


TRUMP: And it just doesn`t work! You know, people can see through
the glasses. But he`s got the glasses, the whole deal, Oh, oh, oh, Trump,
oh -- I say he did a lousy job on the border. But I see him. He`s so
vicious. You know, used to be really a nice guy. He used to come to see
me for contributions and support.

All of a sudden, he`s -- all of a sudden, he wants to show he`s a
tough guy with Trump. So tough. So I tweeted that Rick Perry should have
to have an IQ test before getting on the debate stage.



MATTHEWS: So Governor Perry`s going to get into a fight with this
guy. How`s that going to win for him? I don`t get it. Go ahead, Steve.

SCHMIDT: Look, this is a test. This is a moment of testing for all
these candidates inside the Republican Party. You know, Joan talked about
this through the prism of this not being good, obviously, for the
Republican Party. This isn`t good for the country. And it`s not good for
the Democratic Party...

WALSH: I agree.

SCHMIDT: ... because you can be the most liberal person in the
Democratic Party. In a country with a two-party system, you need both
political parties to be healthy.

And this anger that he is channeling is real. I understand that
people across this country are upset. They have a right to be upset about
a number of different issues and reasons, but this anger is not what the
conservative movement and the Republican Party should be about. And it`s
so opposite the virtues and character of our last great conservative
president, Ronald Reagan, on whose tomb is inscribed...


WALSH: I really...

SCHMIDT: ... "In my heart`...

STEELE: Hey, Steve...


WALSH: I agree with Steve. I agree with Steve completely that this
is not good for the Democratic Party, either, and it`s terrible for the
country because this is the kind of hate -- I mean, he started on President
Obama. He rode the birther wave. He whipped up that frenzy about the
president really wasn`t born here. He`s not eligible. We haven`t seen his
college grades. Then he went on to Mexican immigrants.

He`s playing not just to frustration but to sometimes racism and to a
real kind of nihilism about the political process. That`s not good for
Democrats. It`s definitely not good for the country.

MATTHEWS: But to make a point here, because we have two Republicans
on the show -- when he was making fun of the president, he was an illegal
alien, that he was secretly born in Kenya...

WALSH: Right.

MATTHEWS: ... there was no roar of disapproval from the Republican

STEELE: No, there wasn`t.

MATTHEWS: You guys enjoyed that clown act. You enjoyed -- not you
personally, but the party enjoyed that.

SCHMIDT: Well, Chris -- Chris, there was certainly -- there was
certainly disapproval on that from the two Republicans you have on this
show today.


SCHMIDT: We said it was despicable then.

STEELE: Right.

SCHMIDT: It was wrong then. It was racist. It undermines the
legitimacy of the duly elected commander-in-chief. It was wrong, and
Republicans should have repudiated it. And we paid a price for it, and to
some degree, we`re reaping what we sowed by a feckless political class that
didn`t call it out.

MATTHEWS: Exactly what I`m going to say at the end of the show
because that is the terrible -- it`s a tragic reality. Let`s call it that.
The Republican Party that giggled in their back seats...

WALSH: Right.

MATTHEWS: ... while he was talking about all this birther crap,
loving it because it helped to bring down the president, it helped to
miniaturize him. The whole plan (INAUDIBLE) burdening of this guy. He
could take it, by the way, but it put more burdens on his shoulder that the
-- have to come out and show your papers, like some South African black --
I got to show my papers.

WALSH: Horrible.

MATTHEWS: I`m legal here. That was ridiculous. And that was Trump.
And he bragged about forcing the president, like they stopped him in a car,
let`s see your license, the president of the United States.

And that miniaturization of his persona was part of the Republican
plan. And everybody loved it when it was working for the party. Now you
see the clown act writ large, and he`s going after your own people. So,
oh, tut, tut, tut. We shouldn`t have Donald Trump in our midst. Well, you
got him.

Steve Schmidt, thank you. Thank you, Michael Steele. Thank you, Joan
Walsh. You`re all smart tonight.

Coming up, while Donald Trump`s making noise, John Kasich`s trying to
make some real news. The Ohio governor announced today he`s running for
president. He`s the 16th Republican to do so. He`s got a good story to
tell, and he could give Jeb Bush a real fight, believe it or not. Watch
this guy. He`s for real.

Plus, President Obama is pushing his nuclear deal with Iran, and
today, he`s blasting the hawks. He says the same people who oppose the
deal right now with Iran are the same people who pushed us into war in
Iraq, and he`s dead right.

And it`s Tuesday, time for the Tuesday clown car, as I said. And
tonight, Mitch McConnell hitches a ride and warns Hillary Clinton that she
can`t win the presidential election by just being a woman. Big news there.
And that`s all she`s doing, he claims.

Finally, "Let Me Finish" with the excitement Donald Trump is causing
in the Republican presidential campaign, the bad excitement.

And this is HARDBALL, the place for politics.


MATTHEWS: "The Washington Post"/ABC News poll has new potential
matchups in the 2016 general election. Let`s check the HARDBALL

Among registered voters, Hillary Clinton beats Jeb Bush in a two-man
race, a two-way race, 50 percent to 44 percent. But if Donald Trump runs
as a third party candidate, Clinton takes 46 percent, about the same, Jeb
Bush is down to 30 percent and Trump`s at 20. We`ll see who wins that one.

We`ll be right back.



run for president of the United States.


KASICH: I have the experience and the testing, the testing, which
shapes you and prepares you for the most important job in the world.

Policy is far more important than politics, ideology or any of the
other nonsense we see!


KASICH: I know what needs to be done. I have been there at all
levels, OK?


MATTHEWS: Welcome back to HARDBALL. That was Ohio governor John
Kasich announcing his 2016 bid for the White House earlier today. Kasich
becomes number 16 in the crowded field of Republicans vying for the
Republican nomination.

Joining me right now from Ohio is MSNBC`s Kasie Hunt, who was there
for Governor Kasich`s announcement this afternoon.

Kasie, you`re smiling, as always, but this is a great moment. I think
it was a very positive speech at a time when there`s a lot of negativity
out there.

KASIE HUNT, NBC CORRESPONDENT: Well, Chris, I think you heard Kasich
focus on this idea that the country needs to be united, not divided. And
he hit on themes that a lot of the other Republicans, most of whom I`ve
been to their announcements, didn`t hit on. He talked a lot about the
working poor, about the mentally ill, about the developmentally disabled.
He says that that comes from his own background as the son of a mailman.

Now, his speech was a little bit rambling. He didn`t use notes. He
didn`t speak from a teleprompter. So we had some pretty classic John
Kasich up there, but definitely some differences in tone than we`ve heard
from other people.

MATTHEWS: Well, let me ask you about the crowd reaction because he
wasn`t giving them red meat, like, some of the people on the right have
been doing. He didn`t blast Obama, I don`t think. He didn`t blast the
political world. He seemed to be just saying, Here`s my personal story of
a working class guy who`s had problems, you know, the tragedies in his
life, lost his parents. And he seemed to be talking about his uncle
George, his uncle Steve, guys who fought in the war, in World War II.

It was great story telling. It sounds like my family to some extent.
But it was so to me American and positive. That`s what I liked about it.

HUNT: Well, I don`t think that it was red meat, Chris, you`re
definitely right about that. And the reaction in the crowd was, to a
certain extent, I think, muted by that fact. That said, these are a bunch
of people who know John Kasich. They know his story, and they know that
he`s not the guy that can be out there attacking President Obama and
offering that kind of thing up.

I mean, this is a guy who didn`t just expand Medicaid in Ohio, but who
fought with a Republican legislature to expand it, and whose argument in
favor of it is to say, You know what? When I get to the pearly gates of
heaven, St. Peter isn`t going to ask me how much I cut the government, he`s
going to ask me what did I do to help the poor?

MATTHEWS: Well, the party that likes to hear about the numbers of
executions in Texas -- will they cheer this?

HUNT: You know, Chris, I think that`s the real test for Kasich. I
think his advisers know that Iowa`s not going to be the place for him.
That kind of -- this kind of a candidate is probably not going to play with
the conservative activists who hold sway there.

They think that the place he can make a stand is New Hampshire, that
that`s a place that`s picked maybe more establishment Republicans,
Republicans who...


HUNT: ... you know, the establishment feels can do a better job in
the general election. But you know, that`s a pretty crowded place, too,
Chris. You know, Jeb Bush making likely his major stand there, Chris
Christie. There`s a lot of people who are going to live or die in New
Hampshire, no pun intended, in the "Live Free or Die" state.


HUNT: But Kasich`s advisers will privately say that they need Jeb
Bush to make a big mistake for him to be able to rise to the top of that

MATTHEWS: I think that pun was intended. What do you think?


MATTHEWS: Thank you, Kasie Hunt. Great reporting. We felt like we
were there. Thanks for coming to us from Columbus.

HUNT: Thanks, Chris.

MATTHEWS: Governor Kasich isn`t your typical conservative, by any
means, in the 2016 field.

For one thing, he boasts a 60 percent job approval in Ohio. He
expanded Medicaid under President Obama`s Affordable Care Act. He`s open
to a path of citizenship for illegal immigrants. He supports Common Core
in education. He voted for the assault weapons ban in Congress and he says
it`s time to move on from the same-sex marriage debate.

As Kasie Hunt just reported, when a major GOP donor and the wife of
the owner of the Arizona Diamondbacks questioned his decision to expand
Medicaid coverage, Kasich responded by saying, "I don`t know about you,
lady, but when I get to the pearly gates, I`m going to have an answer for
what I have done for the poor."

The Ohio governor also comes from a regular working-class background,
as I said, and has a good story to tell. Here`s what he said today about
his family and how it inspired him.


inspiration from the people who came before me.

And I want to tell you about a few of the ones that inspire me. I
would like to start with my uncle Steve. Uncle Steve was a tough guy, you
know, the son of a coal miner, rough and gruff and tell it like it is. And
uncle George, he`s here today, he`s right over here. He`s 89 years old.


KASICH: I so love my uncle George. He`s the patriarch of our family.

Where my father-in-law -- we call him Popsy -- grandfather, joined the
Marines at the age of 17, wanted to serve his country.


MATTHEWS: As it stands now, the two-term governor is polling at just
2 percent nationally and looks unlikely to make the cutoff for the first
debate on August 6, which is being held there in Cleveland.

Joining me right now is former Ohio Secretary of State Ken Blackwell.

Ken, people like me tend to like this guy. That`s probably why people
like you don`t, because I think the hard conservatives have a hard time
with a guy that says let`s move on from the same-sex debate and let`s not
keep arguing that one over and over again, and also think that Medicaid
should cover people who are near working poor and not just the ultimate
poor, and who believes that, somewhere along the line, people who come here
illegally should have a chance to become legally, if they do everything
right once they`re here because they`re here anyway.

Your thoughts?

think John Kasich has been a very successful governor in the state of Ohio,
and he won his last election by 38 points.

But on a policy basis, he`s going to have to make the case. There are
hardworking, decent Americans that believe that our borders are porous and
that this is not only a domestic problem, it`s a national security problem.
There are good and decent people who are concerned about the numbers.

The numbers of the folks who are not working -- unemployment is down,
but labor participation rate is also down. So, as a consequence, you have
good, decent people who are concerned about public policy issues that
Kasich is going to have to make the case if he, in fact, is swimming
against the grain.

That`s what primaries are for. John is -- at times, he can be edgy
and, at times, he can be the compassionate person that you heard speaking
about his family, speaking about the poor. But, at the end of the day,
people are going to want to know, what are you going to do to get the
economy growing at a rate that we can get the labor participation rate back
up? What are you doing to make sure that we`re fighting global terrorism,
that we`re protecting the integrity of our borders?


BLACKWELL: So, this is what primaries are -- this is what primaries
are for.

MATTHEWS: Thank you, Ken Blackwell, for coming on.

Up next: Mr. Insult. Is it going to be Donald Rickles or Donald
Trump? We have rounded up our best insults from Trump.

And this is HARDBALL, the place for politics.


MATTHEWS: Welcome back to HARDBALL.

Donald Trump seems to lower the bar every day on what`s acceptable.
And "The Washington Post" has released its list of the top 25 places,
people and things that Donald Trump has trashed.

There are obvious targets, like Senator John McCain`s time as a
prisoner of war in North Vietnam.



FRANK LUNTZ, FOUNDER, LUNTZ GLOBAL: He`s a war hero, five-and-a-half
years as a prisoner...


TRUMP: He is a war hero -- he is a war hero because he was captured.
I like people that weren`t captured.

He`s a war hero because he was captured. OK?

And I believe perhaps he`s a war hero.


MATTHEWS: And, of course, his opening salvo on immigrants coming from


TRUMP: When Mexico sends its people, they`re not sending their best.
They`re not sending you. They`re not sending you.

They`re sending people that have lots of problems. And they`re
bringing those problems with us. They`re bringing drugs. They`re bringing
crime. They`re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.


MATTHEWS: Well, he said that all the way back in June, fairly
recently. And he certainly lacks a certain reverence for his own religious
rights. Here he is.


TRUMP: You know, when we go in church and when I drink my little
wine, which is about the only wine I drink and have my little cracker, I
guess that`s a form of asking for forgiveness. And I do that as often as
possible because I feel cleansed.


MATTHEWS: Eats his little cracker. What is he, a parrot?

Anyway, there isn`t time enough for tonight to go through all the list
of who Trump has trashed, or dissed, if you will.

Joining me right now is Lizz Winstead, co-created "The Daily Show,"
who once had to decide professionally what was in and what was out.


MATTHEWS: So, let`s go through some of this -- through a lightning

And, Lizz, thanks for joining me.

Here`s number one. Personal phone numbers, Trump doesn`t seem to
think they should be kept personal. Here`s how he fired back at Lindsey
Graham today after Graham called him a jackass.


TRUMP: He gave me his number. And I found the card. I wrote the
number down. I don`t know if it`s the right number. Let`s try it, 202


TRUMP: I don`t know. Maybe it`s -- you know, it`s three four years
ago, so maybe it`s an old number.



MATTHEWS: You know, Lizz, whatever you think of the destructiveness
of his nature, he`s like an old hit -- pitch man on the Atlantic City
boardwalk. He`s selling that stuff, selling the Japanese steak knives.
Whatever he`s got on the counter, he`s selling.


MATTHEWS: He sells an old phone number. I got the piece of paper
right here. He went after the glasses. He puts his hands over his eyes,
the glasses that Rick Perry`s wearing now, and says you can see right
through it.

It`s all visual graphic showbiz. Your thoughts? What`s -- but what`s
-- are there any limits to this? Or is it going to get worse and worse and

if there`s no repercussions, I think it is going to get worse and worse and

Donald Trump has sort of replaced bedbugs as America`s number one


WINSTEAD: He just won`t stop.

And to announce Lindsey Graham`s phone number? The irony of
announcing Lindsey Graham`s phone number is I think John McCain might
answer it.

MATTHEWS: Yes, well, that`s funny. Aren`t you funny?


MATTHEWS: Anyway, one thing people aren`t going to do is talk, what
do they call, quietly with him anymore. They are going to assume it`s all
going to get used in the next stump speech.

Anyway, Trump is against gay marriage. He says he`s in favor of
traditional marriage. Here he is.


TRUMP: I`m traditional marriage. It is changing rapidly.

JAKE TAPPER, CNN: But what do you say to a lesbian who is married or
a gay man who is married who says, Donald Trump, what`s traditional about
being married three times?

TRUMP: Yes, I have a great marriage. I have a great wife now. And
my two wives were very good.



MATTHEWS: If he`s not embarrassed by that question, I don`t know what
he`s capable of being embarrassed by, Lizz.

WINSTEAD: I think he believes in traditional divorce.



MATTHEWS: Well, serial marriage doesn`t seem to bother him as a
canard at all.


MATTHEWS: Anyway, here`s Trump going after Rick Perry again today --
and this is pretty funny -- for wearing glasses. Here he is.


TRUMP: I see Rick Perry the other day, and he`s so -- he`s doing very
poorly in the polls. He put glasses on, so people will think he`s smart.


TRUMP: And it just doesn`t work. People can see through the glasses.

But he`s got the glasses, the whole deal, huh, huh, huh, Trump, huh?
I say he did a lousy job on the border.


MATTHEWS: God, there`s a (INAUDIBLE) aspect to this guy, huh, huh,
bingo, you know?

But the glasses thing -- you know, when the Hollywood guys always
testify before Congress or do fund-raisers, they do wear glasses. He`s
right. It`s a way of showing some sort of gravitas. And he nailed the
poor guy from Texas, I thought.

Your thought?

WINSTEAD: Well, I will say that, with Rick Perry, the glasses may be
half empty.


WINSTEAD: But for Donald Trump to mock Rick Perry for his glasses,
and not look in the mirror and look at what`s on top of his own head, that
contraption he calls a hair...


WINSTEAD: I think that this is all buffoon -- it`s just -- the
buffoonery is insane.

And I just -- I`m sure all of the Republicans are just going like this
that this guy is at the top of the polls.

MATTHEWS: OK. But they`re not going to like this. He`s at the top
of the polls. The applause meter is going high for this guy.

In this political idol show, he`s getting the reaction from the
audience. Why it is working as an act? Question to you, Lizz.


WINSTEAD: Maybe it`s working as an act because people need an act.

But, really, people need to take a breath and realize that they`re
going to need a presidential candidate. And it`s just so interesting to
have watched the segment before mine, where a guy who I disagree with, but
who has gravitas and ideas, who might not even be on the stage, when this
one`s going to have blowup shoes and a squirting flower, and we...



MATTHEWS: You mean John Kasich.

Anyway, Lizz, here`s a tweet by Trump going after the courageous
American doctors who went over to East -- West Africa to fight Ebola --
quote -- "The U.S. cannot allow Ebola-infected people back. People that go
to faraway places to help out are great, but must suffer the consequences."


MATTHEWS: He`s banishing, banishing the doctors who go to save lives.
How can you beat that?

WINSTEAD: You know, at some point, you have to say, who has he not
offended and how big is that constituency? Because anybody who is buying
this, it`s like I`m terrified that they can vote.


MATTHEWS: Lizz, my comic dear, he`s watching right now. Beware.
He`s coming after both of us.

Lizz Winstead, thank you very much. I know. Thanks for coming on.

Up next, if it`s Tuesday, it`s time for the HARDBALL clown show.
We`re already in it with Donald Trump, but today it rolls through Kentucky,
driven by Mitch McConnell, who just hitchhiked a ride. He says Hillary
Clinton is playing the gender card. Is she?

You`re watching HARDBALL, the place for politics.



Defense officials say the leader of the Khorasan terror group was
killed in a U.S. airstrike in Syria. The U.S. was offering a $7 million
reward for information about his location.

A federal appeals court in Chicago has thrown out five counts against
former Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich. The ex-governor may end up
serving less time behind bars as a result.

And it`s another day of stifling summer heat in the Southern and
Eastern U.S. Advisories are in effect from Virginia to Louisiana -- now
back to HARDBALL.

MATTHEWS: Welcome back to HARDBALL.

If it`s Tuesday, it`s time for the clown car. And we have got a
crowded one this week.

Let`s start with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, a hitchhiker
in the car. This week, he warned Hillary Clinton that playing the gender
card won`t be enough for her.


arguing vote for me because I`m a woman is enough. You may recall my
election last year.

The gender card alone is not enough. I beat my opponent with women in
my race because the gender card alone is not enough. I`m sure there are
millions of Americans who would love to have a woman president, but the
question is, a woman president to do what?


MATTHEWS: Clinton responded during a Facebook chat.

She said -- quote -- "Mitch McConnell really doesn`t get it. There`s
a gender card being played in this campaign. It`s played every time
Republicans vote against giving women equal pay, deny families access to
affordable child care or family leave, refuse to let women make decisions
about their health or have access to free contraception."

Well, this isn`t the first time McConnell made a controversial comment
about gender. Speaking at the Conservative Political Action Conference two
years ago, McConnell had this to say about Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden.


MCCONNELL: Don`t tell me Democrats are the party of the future, when
their presidential ticket for 2016 is shaping up to look like a rerun of
"The Golden Girls."



MATTHEWS: I don`t think that would work with the Democratic Party.

I`m joined right now by tonight`s roundtable, April Ryan, to my left,
White House correspondent and Washington bureau chief for American Urban
Radio Networks, "Washington Post" opinion writer Jonathan Capehart, and
"The Wall Street Journal" Carol Lee.

Thank you.



Association of White House...


MATTHEWS: Congratulations. So, you get to be the emcee of the next

Ask me -- I don`t mean about this -- I don`t think Hillary`s run
entirely on her gender. Of course, it more this time than last time. But
why is a guy, a guy going after this one? It seems to me a stupid thing to
argue if you`re a guy. Don`t go after somebody being a woman and making
that something of an issue.

RYAN: Several reasons.

Number one, Hillary Clinton is out of the GOP fray right now. They`re
fighting amongst one another, giving out each other`s cell phone numbers
and calling each other jackass. So, they`re trying to bring Hillary back
into the fray.

But Hillary Clinton is a woman, but guess what? She has a pedigree
that no one else has. And I have said it on the show before. She`s been
secretary of state. She`s dealt with international issues. She`s been a
senator. I mean -- and she`s been a first lady.

So, she has a pedigree. She is someone to be fearful of. And that`s
why McConnell threw that out there.

MATTHEWS: Let`s take a look at this other one. Next up, a strange
article from the conservative "National Review" writer Kevin Williamson,
explained why Bernie Sanders, a Democratic socialist from Vermont, is
actually -- you`ll love this -- a national socialist, in other words, a

In writing this, he said, "In the Bernieverse, there`s a whole lot of
nationalism mixed up with socialism. He is, in fact, leading a national
socialist movement, which is a queasy and uncomfortable thing to write
about a man who is a son of Jewish immigrants from Poland and whose family
was murdered in the Holocaust. But there is no other way to characterize
his view and his politics."

Williamson went on to say that Sanders, quote, "national socialism
wasn`t the kind that persecutes racial minorities." Quote, "He`s a
national socialist in the mode of Hugo Chavez. He isn`t driven by racial
hatred. He`s driven by political hatred. And that`s bad enough."

Anyway, making the Nazi comparison has become somewhat commonplace in
political discourse lately. Let`s watch.


HANK WILLIAMS, JR., COUNTRY SINGER: Remember the golf game? That was
one of the biggest political mistakes ever.

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: You mean when John Boehner played golf with
President Obama?

WILLIAMS: Oh, yes, yes. And Biden and Kasich, yes. Uh-huh.

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: What did you not like about it? It seems to be
a really pivotal moment for you?

WILLIAMS: Come on, come on. That would be like Hitler playing golf
with Netanyahu.

RUSH LIMBAUGH, RADIO TALK SHOW HOST: Now, what are the similarities
between the Democrat Party of today and the Nazi party in Germany? Well,
the Nazis were against big business. They were for abortion and euthanasia
of the undesirables, as we all know, and they were for cradle-to-grave
nationalized health care.

There are far more similarities between Nancy Pelosi and Adolf Hitler
than between these people showing up at town halls.

UNIDENTIFIED MALE: I`ve been told that he said we`re living in a
Gestapo age. What do you mean by that?

BEN CARSON (R), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: I mean, very much like Nazi
Germany -- and I know you`re not supposed to say Nazi Germany, but I don`t
care about political correctness.


MATTHEWS: You know, I don`t get it. I mean, can`t someone stamp, you
know, with a big cement seal, never compare anybody to Hitler but Hitler.


MATTHEWS: Just do it right this. Just keep it there.

CAPEHART: It seems like every four years or every election cycle, you
know, you can`t just oppose your opponent`s ideas. You have to root them
in evil and plans to murder and enslave people. Why can`t we just -- look,
if you don`t like Bernie Sanders, just talk about how you think Bernie
Sanders` ideas are out of the political mainstream or too left of center or
not good enough for America, not that he`s trying to outright kill people.

MATTHEWS: And both these guys say, I know it`s odd to call a son of
Jewish immigrants a Nazi but. And the other guy says, I know it`s
politically incorrect but. They seem to know it`s a trip wire, and they go
crashing right to it.

Let`s take a look at this, Carol. Up next, presidential candidate
Scott Walker, he strongly criticized the Supreme Court in this country,
their decision to legalize gay marriage. He also said he supports a ban of
openly gay Boy Scout leaders on CNN this week and he refused to answer
whether he thought homosexuality is a choice.

Let`s watch.


DANA BASH, CNN: Do you think that being gay is a choice?

that`s not even an issue for me to be involved in. The bottom line is I`m
going to stand up and work hard for every American regardless of who they
are, no matter where they come from, no matter what their background.

BASH: To do that properly, you have to have to understand or at least
have an opinion on who they are and where they`re coming from?

WALKER: But again, in any -- no, I don`t have an opinion on every
single issue out there. I mean, to me, that`s -- I don`t know the answer
to that question.


MATTHEWS: Carol, why is that the default position on so many issues,
climate change, all kinds of things now, candidates now say I don`t know,
as if that absolves them. It makes them look stupid.

is --

MATTHEWS: Because you would have an opinion on that because everybody
is furious (ph) about it. Most people do.

LEE: Of course you would. If you`re running for president of the
United States, you should have an opinion on that.

The problem with the answer that he gave is that this -- that kind of
sentiment, that kind of wishy-washy, you know, not taking a stance one way
or another is what this electorate is really unhappy about. They don`t
like the -- you know, the blow dried poll-tested politicians. They`re
showing that in the rise of Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump`s rise as well.

An answer like that -- when you don`t answer the question, for voters,
that doesn`t resonate with them in any sort of meaningful way. And
frankly, you know, everybody`s running -- obviously, Scott Walker`s going
to run to the right. His answer later to the question of how he would
represent every American is more of a general election --

MATTHEWS: I got to ask Jon.

Jon, what do people in the gay community think when they hear a guy
say something that dumb? I mean, what do -- do they think is he playing a
game? Or what do you think he`s up to?

CAPEHART: No, they don`t -- well, they think he`s playing a game in
that he doesn`t think we exist. I mean, I`m an out gay man. So, I`ll say

He doesn`t think we exist. He doesn`t have the vocabulary to talk
about us. He doesn`t think that we are a part of the American fabric. He
has nothing to propose to us. He doesn`t want our votes. We are not
welcome. And that is the problem for the GOP.

MATTHEWS: Say my name.


MATTHEWS: You heard that the other day, say my name.

Anyway, the roundtable`s staying with us. And up next, President
Obama takes his message on the road tying critics of the nuclear deal to
those who pushed us into the war in Iraq. I think he`s right on most of

This is HARDBALL, the place for politics.


MATTHEWS: President Obama traveled to New York today for his seventh
and final appearance on "The Daily Show", which is tonight. He made his
debut eight years ago when he was still a candidate for president. Jon
Stewart is in his final weeks, as we know, as host of "The Daily Show"
finale set for, well, it`s coming up, August 6th. It`s all going to be

Trevor Noah begins his host worth on September 28.

We`ll be right back.



another conflict, I believe that sending our sons and daughters in the
harm`s way must be always be a last resort, and that before we put their
lives on the line, we should exhaust every alternative. That`s what we owe
our troops, that is strength and that is American leadership.


MATTHEWS: We`re back with the round table, April, Jonathan and Carol.

And that was President Obama, of course, today addressing the Veterans
of Foreign Wars at their annual convention down in Pittsburgh, and defining
the nuclear deal with Iran, the president stressed the need for diplomatic
engagement as a way to avert more wars in the Middle East, and he slammed
the opponents of the deal by pointing that the same voice opposing
diplomacy are now the ones who misled us in that war in Iraq.

Here he is hitting them.


OBAMA: In the debate over this deal, we`re hearing the echoes some of
the same policies and mindset that failed us in the past, and some of the
same politicians ands pundits that are so quick to reject a possibility of
a diplomatic solution to Iran`s nuclear program are the same folks who are
so quick to go to war with Iraq and said it will take a few months. And we
know the consequences of that choice and what it costs us in blood and


MATTHEWS: Those remarks, which were reminiscent of his 2008 campaign
argument opposing the Iraq war came as his opponents in Congress tried to
assemble enough votes to scuttle a deal with Iran.

April, I don`t think that it`s fair to say, just people are wrong,
once they`re wrong again.

But in some cases, it`s true. Your thoughts?

RYAN: Well, what I`m hearing is the fact that this is such a serious
issue. Number one, we don`t know as much about Iran as we thought that we
knew. And we don`t know much about that in the context of, what happened
with WMD? We thought that we had the information and the intelligence.

MATTHEWS: Did you think that?

RYAN: I heard our intelligence was faulty at the time. I heard our
intelligence --

MATTHEWS: Did you think that was the reason we went to war with Iraq?

RYAN: I know that wasn`t the reason. But I`ll just say that was --


RYAN: No, no, but our intelligence we don`t have the intelligence on
Iran yet. We`re getting information now. And a high ranking official that
used to be at a White House told me, he said, look, if we ever want to go
war with Iran, that Iraq would be a walk in the park compared to what

MATTHEWS: It`s a real country. Iran is a real country.

RYAN: Yes.

MATTHEWS: But I think hawks are hawks, generally, and doves are doves
generally. In my case, I`m a dove most of the time. I`m a dove. And I
know the hawks tend to be hawks.

CAPEHART: And the president is a dove. Remember, one of the reasons
why he was able --

MATTHEWS: He got elected --


RYAN: As a dove.

MATTHEWS: The Cairo speech was critical to me once he got in office.

CAPEHART: And so, you know, the president campaigned on bringing the
troops home.

RYAN: Yes.

CAPEHART: He is now as president of the United States, he`s brought a
lot of the troops home, but now, he`s dealing with a much more complicated
war that he anticipated as a candidate and now, he`s with this Iran deal,
he is trying to say once gain to all of those people who are clamoring for
some confrontation with Iran, look, no, we`re going to exhaust every
diplomatic avenue possible before we ever send troops into harms way again.

And he is not only talking to Republicans, but he`s also talking to a
war weary nation that does not want to go into another war.

MATTHEWS: Let me ask you a question, Carol, just a minute left. Do
you think the people who are hawks on this really want to bomb Iran?

LEE: Well, I think --

MATTHEWS: Do they? Do they want us to Iran?

LEE: Well, I think that what you`re seeing -- the president is
certainly making that case. But let`s look why he is making that case.

MATTHEWS: His opponents want to do that?

LEE: Yes, and the reason he is making that case is because he has to
win over at least Democrats, for them to hold the line so that the veto of
any rejection of this deal is not overridden. And so, he is making this
simple case as he possibly can.

This is a very complicated deal. The White House says that it`s not a
perfect deal, there`s a lot of ways to come at his with criticism, and
they`re having to make that case.


LEE: At the end of the day, like you said 2008, that war argument is
powerful with Democrats, and that`s why --

MATTHEWS: By the way, Menendez, the chairman of the Foreign Relations
Committee, was, you know, he is getting all of this money to pay -- pro-
Israel guys are paying his legal defense fund. Some of these guys are not
looking completely on the level here. Some of these people voting in

Anyway, thank you, April Ryan. You know what I`m talking about.

Jonathan Capehart, you know what I am talking about.

Carol Lee, I don`t know you.


MATTHEWS: Just kidding.

When we return, let me finish with the excitement Donald Trump is
causing in Republican presidential campaign. The bad excitement.

You`re watching HARDBALL, the place for politics.


MATTHEWS: Let me finish tonight on the excitement that Donald Trump
is causing on the campaign. Get this, get it good. He is the front
runner. Yes, according to the Republican voters, he is the best they`ve
got, the best person around to sit in Lincoln`s chair.

Is this insane? Is that the way you look at it? Well, you might want
to get used to it, because I`ve got the sense that Mr. Trump isn`t going

As we once said of Hillary Clinton, he`s found his voice, not that he
ever lost it. But let`s not forget and let`s not let the Republican panda
bears forget where this political jack and the beanstalk first sprouted

It was way back when he was talking about running for president the
last time, back when he`s stock and trade was telling the world that
President Obama was an illegal alien and never ever forget how the
Republican big shots and wannabe big shots gave him one big gigantic pass.
How they giggled when the man from Gotham straw the networks barking that
the president of the United States was a con artist, some street corner guy
who had conned his way into the presidency, some guy whose mother ran off
to Kenya to have him and then snuck back into the country to sell him into
a political career.

Well, the image was clear, and powerful. Obama who did everything
right and played ball in high school, gotten into good schools, became
editor of the Harvard Law Review, and blind competition had foresworn the
easy money to work for his community, had shown the guts to run statewide
and then country-wide. That according to Trump, he was nothing more than a
street corner hustler, a guy from the hood who conned his way into the
White House, a place where nobody like him could have ever gotten into
legitimately, of course.

Well, you got it. In seeing this crap never bothered the Republican
big shots, not one bit. It didn`t bother them, that a man claiming to be a
member of their party was selling this kind of cheap ethnic catnip as long
as it added to all of the other burdens they were putting on Obama, all the
Mitch McConnell and Newt Gingrich`s strategy of killing the guys presidency
in its crib.

Well, it didn`t work, did it? And now, the Republicans have Donald
Trump, the man who entertained them, kicking the hell out of them right
now. They`ve got no one -- not the Democrats, not the media to blame, just
themselves. They made Trump by letting him say the dumb, stupid, nasty
things, anything that came out of his mouth.

That`s HARDBALL for now. Thanks for being with us.

"ALL IN WITH CHRIS HAYES" starts right now.


Copyright 2015 CQ-Roll Call, Inc. All materials herein are protected by
United States copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed,
transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the prior written
permission of CQ-Roll Call. You may not alter or remove any trademark,
copyright or other notice from copies of the content.>