Joaquin Palting  /  Getty Images file
The idea behind the "fat-burning zone" is that high-intensity exercises like running up stairs don't melt the fat as well as easier activities. Sound too good to be true? It is, experts say.
By MSNBC contributor
msnbc.com
updated 5/10/2005 2:23:04 PM ET 2005-05-10T18:23:04

Which exercises help you lose the most weight? If fat truly burns off, then why can it reappear? And does sitting in the sauna help you shed pounds? Smart Fitness answers your queries. Have a fitness question? To send us an e-mail, click here . We’ll post select answers in future columns.

Q: I'm confused about all the weight-loss advice lately. For instance, I have read several times that exercising within the "fat-burning zone" is not the most effective way to lose weight. But that makes no sense to me. If it's true, then which exercises are best? Also, if fat burns off, why can it reappear (when people regain the weight they lost)?

A: Let me first address your question about why fat can reappear. When you "burn" fat, you're not completely wiping out fat cells — they're just shrinking. And they can bulge at the seams again if you consume more calories than you expend through physical activity.

"The fat cells are always there, and they're always hungry," says Barbara Ainsworth, a professor of exercise and nutritional sciences at San Diego State University.

So which type of physical activity is best to help you shrink those fat cells and lose weight? That depends.

Targeting the "fat-burning zone" — a level of exercise intensity that's low to moderate — has been widely touted as the ideal way to lose weight. And various types of exercise equipment have digital readouts that tell you when you're working out at this level.

At first glance, the idea of a fat-burning zone seems sound. It's true that our bodies burn a greater percentage of body fat during low- to moderate-intensity exercise (around 60 percent) than during high-intensity activities (roughly 35 percent). As we increase exertion, the body relies less on fat as fuel and more on carbohydrates, explains Ainsworth. Carbohydrates are stored in muscle and can be quickly released when our bodies need them for vigorous activity.

So does that mean that 20 minutes of walking will help you lose weight (in the form of fat) much better than 20 minutes of running? No. (Little wonder you're confused).

Why? Because what ultimately matters in weight loss is how you balance your calories. To lose weight, you need to expend more calories than you take in. To lose a pound of body fat, for instance, you need to create a deficit of 3,500 calories. And minute for minute, high-intensity exercise will help you lose weight fastest because it burns the most calories.

It's also important to note — and this math indeed gets a little confusing — that even though you burn a smaller percentage of fat at high intensities, you can still actually burn more total fat calories at this activity level because you're burning more calories overall, and a good number of them are coming from fat.

Now, what's the best exercise for you? That depends on a lot more than just how many calories a particular exercise burns. Running may burn the most calories but if you hate it and aren't likely to do it on a regular basis, it's not the best exercise to help you lose weight even though it's keeping your neighbor slim and trim.

  1. Don't miss these Health stories
    1. Splash News
      More women opting for preventive mastectomy - but should they be?

      Rates of women who are opting for preventive mastectomies, such as Angeline Jolie, have increased by an estimated 50 percent in recent years, experts say. But many doctors are puzzled because the operation doesn't carry a 100 percent guarantee, it's major surgery -- and women have other options, from a once-a-day pill to careful monitoring.

    2. Larry Page's damaged vocal cords: Treatment comes with trade-offs
    3. Report questioning salt guidelines riles heart experts
    4. CDC: 2012 was deadliest year for West Nile in US
    5. What stresses moms most? Themselves, survey says

"It's better to work out at an intensity that you're comfortable with and will be consistent with," says Gerald Endress, fitness manager at the Duke University Diet and Fitness Center in Durham, N.C.

You can burn just as many calories as your neighbor if you pick a moderate-intensity exercise like brisk walking — you'll just have to devote more time to exercise so that you burn enough calories to lose the weight.

There's no single exercise regimen that's best for everyone. The key is to find the right plan for you — one that you'll stick to.

SWEATIN' IN THE SAUNA
Q:I go to the sauna after I work out because wishful thinking leads me to believe that sweating will shed fat! But, in reality, am I really just wasting my time going in the sauna and sweating for 15 minutes, or is it actually doing something for me?

A: In response to the high heat of a sauna, your body will sweat to try to keep you cool. So you'll shed weight, but it's just water weight. When you gulp water after leaving the sauna because you're dehydrated and thirsty, you'll quickly put the weight back on.

This has been shown time and time again by wrestlers trying to "make weight," says Ainsworth. The weight is gone when they get on those scales but it quickly returns when they drink.

So, yes, if your goal is to lose weight and keep it off, you're wasting your time.

But a good sweat in the sauna isn't without merit. It may help you to relax. Just remember to replenish your fluids afterward.

Smart Fitness appears the second Tuesday of each month.

© 2013 msnbc.com Reprints

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments