updated 5/13/2005 6:19:00 PM ET 2005-05-13T22:19:00

A soldier convicted in the Abu Ghraib scandal testified Friday that it was he and not Spc. Sabrina Harman who handed wires to a hooded Iraqi prisoner forced to stand on a box for an hour in 2003.

Pvt. Ivan Frederick II, called as a prosecution witness, said he never saw the 27-year-old Harman participate in that or several other instances of mistreatment she is accused of at the Baghdad-area prison. A former soldier, however, testified that he saw Harman humiliate prisoners by helping to handcuff them together in an embrace.

The prosecution in Harman’s court-martial rested Friday after putting 10 witnesses on the stand; the defense is scheduled to open its case Monday.

Harman is the second soldier to go on trial in the scandal. Frederick, one of four Abu Ghraib guards to plead guilty, is serving an eight-year prison sentence.

Frederick said he was the person who took a widely seen photograph of Harman and Pvt. Charles Graner Jr. with a pyramid of naked prisoners. He said he did not see Harman around when guards forced a group of prisoners to masturbate and simulate other sexual acts — a scene she is accused of photographing.

Harman could get up to 6½ years in prison if convicted.

Another witness, Armin Cruz, who has finished serving his sentence for Abu Ghraib abuses and is now out of the Army, testified he saw Harman join Graner and Frederick in an episode of mistreatment in late October 2003.

Cruz said three prisoners suspected of raping a teenage boy prisoner were stripped and forced to roll around on a cold concrete floor. Cruz said Harman motioned to the men to roll and to crawl low to the floor, and that she helped handcuff them together in an embrace.

Cruz, then a soldier in a military intelligence unit working at Abu Ghraib, said Harman told him guards were allowed to do what they needed to keep “order and justice” inside the prison.

Defense attorney Frank Spinner said in opening statements Thursday the photos of the hooded prisoner, known as “Gilligan,” illustrated “a joking type of thing.” But prosecutor Capt. Chuck Neill said in his opening that Gilligan “was trembling, shaking, afraid he was going to be electrocuted.”

Frederick testified the prisoner did not appear to suffer any long-lasting effects from the box incident.

Sleep-deprivation strategy
Frederick said a criminal investigator had told him Gilligan was to be deprived of sleep to soften him up for questioning. The investigator said the prisoner may have had information about the whereabouts of four missing U.S. soldiers, the witness said.

Gilligan was released from U.S. custody; the prosecution has said the government tried but failed to locate him.

Frederick said Abu Ghraib was a chaotic, dangerous place operating under a murky chain of command that included military police officers, military intelligence and others.

“Nobody knew what was going on,” Frederick said. “I took orders from three different places.”

He and Harman were members of the Maryland-based 372nd Military Police Company.

Harman, a reservist from Lorton, Va., who once managed a pizza shop, is depicted in several of the prison’s most notorious abuse photos. Besides the pyramid image, Harman is shown with a prisoner on whose leg she is accused of writing “rapeist.”

Frederick testified it was not common practice to write a prisoner’s alleged crime on his body — a claim that contradicted what Spinner suggested Thursday.

Spinner also had said Harman had been taking photographs to document wrongdoing. The prosecutor disagreed, saying the alleged actions were clearly wrong.

Sentences for the Abu Ghraib guards who struck plea bargains ranged from no time behind bars to eight years. Pfc. Lynndie England, the most recognizable Abu Ghraib defendant, also made a deal with prosecutors, but it was thrown out by a judge last week.

Graner was convicted and sentenced to 10 years in prison; he’s expected to testify for the defense next week.

© 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments