Former House Speaker Dennis Hastert pleaded not guilty Tuesday afternoon to charges he lied to the FBI about illegal bank withdrawals — money he allegedly used for payoffs to keep sexual misconduct accusations under wraps.
The 73-year-old Illinois Republican was thronged by media as he entered a federal courthouse in Chicago ahead of his scheduled arraignment.
He answered a few questions in a voice that was barely more than a whisper, and his new high-powered attorney, Thomas Green, a veteran of political scandals, entered the plea on his behalf.
As part of his bond conditions, Hastert had to turn over his passport, and he must remove any firearms from his property.
U.S. District Judge Thomas Durkin presided over the hearing, but he may not continue with the case. He revealed that because he was friends with Hastert's son, he made donation's to the congressman's 2002 and 2004 campaigns — and he gave both parties two days to decide whether he should be disqualified.
Hastert, who retired from Congress in 2007 and became a lobbyist, is accused of structuring bank transactions to avoid triggering red flags. Court papers say he agreed to pay a person — identified only as Individual A — $3.5 million in hush money to conceal "prior misconduct."
Federal sources have said "Individual A" was a student at Yorkville High School in Illinois, where Hastert was a teacher, wrestling coach and football coach between 1965 and 1981, before he took public office. They say the misconduct was sexual in nature.
Have information about this story or suggestions for other stories NBC News should investigate? Click here.
The identity of Individual A was not disclosed at the arraignment — and could remain secret for months.
"It does not have to come out," said Sergio Acosta, a former federal prosecutor who is now a white-collar attorney.
He predicted that prosecutors will ask for a protective order to keep the name out of the public arena as the case moves toward trial.
Even if the case does go to trial, prosecutors could seek to keep the witness anonymous, although that would be very unusual.
"There is an effort to protect anonymity of victims, particularly if the alleged victim is someone who has suffered sexual abuse," said Dan Collins, another former federal prosecutor turned defense lawyer.
While the man referred to in court papers remains a mystery, the name of another alleged victim has been made public. Jolene Burdge said her brother, Steven Reinboldt, who died of AIDS-related complications in 1995, told her Hastert abused him.
"I just hope more people will come forward," Burdge said over the weekend.
Related: Allegations Cast New Light on Hastert's Time as Speaker
But many of Hastert's ex-wrestlers say they can't imagine their former coach doing anything inappropriate.
"He was always fair, never showed any favoritism," said Mike Pfingston, who grappled on the 1981 team. "We went to wrestling camp with him, six to eight of us, he took us to Colorado, and there were no problems there."
Pfingston said he doesn't understand how the allegations, if true, could have remained secret for so many years in a town that was filled with cornfields back in the '70s and '80s.
Related: Sister of Alleged Hastert Victim Hopes Others Come Forward
And he is concerned that Hastert is being shamed — his name was taken off a program at his alma mater, Wheaton College, and an abuse group wants his portrait removed from the walls of Congress — before he's had his day in court.
"Nothing has even been proven," Pfingston said.
