Nightly News   |  May 22, 2011

Tucson shooter might be unfit for trial

Court documents suggest that doctors appointed by Jared Loughner's lawyers and prosecutors alike have concluded he's mentally unfit to stand trial. NBC's Pete Williams explains what will happen to Loughner if the judge finds him unfit.

Share This:

This content comes from a Full-Text Transcript of the program.

LESTER HOLT, anchor: At a federal court in Tucson , Arizona , hearing is scheduled on Wednesday for Jared Loughner on whether the suspect in the shooting of Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords and 18 others is mentally competent to stand trial . We get the story from NBC 's justice correspondent Pete Williams .

PETE WILLIAMS reporting: It could be the single most important court hearing for Jared Loughner , accused of killing six people and wounding 13 others in a Tucson parking lot in January at a meet and greet event hosted by Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords . Loughner 's own lawyers have described him as, quote, "gravely mentally ill ." Now after five weeks of psychiatric evaluation at a federal prison hospital in Missouri , court documents suggest that doctors appointed by both Loughner 's lawyers and the prosecutors have concluded that he's mentally unfit to stand trial . If the judge agrees, the court proceedings against him would stop without a trial .

Professor IRA ROBBINS (American University Washington College of Law): The defendant can't be railroaded. The defendant has to participate in the proceedings. If as a result of a mental disease or defect he's not able to do that, then the proceedings cannot continue.

WILLIAMS: If Loughner is declared mentally unfit to stand trial , he'd be sent to a prison hospital for treatment. If he later improved, he could be brought back to court and put on trial . But if he didn't get better, he'd stay in the prison hospital. He would not be released. It's happened before. Russell Weston is still in a prison hospital today, never put on trial for running into the US Capitol building 13 years ago and killing two policemen. His attack prompted Congress to build a $600 million visitors center where tourists are screened through metal detectors. A declaration of mentally unfit for trial is different from not guilty by reason of insanity . That's a verdict that follows a trial , as in the case of John Hinckley Jr. , who shot President Reagan . But a finding that Jared Loughner is mentally unfit would mean no trial in Tucson for now and, perhaps, forever. Pete Williams , NBC News, Washington.