In the past 12 months, home prices have skyrocketed in some major U.S. cities. In Phoenix, according to real estate information site Trulia, asking home prices increased by 26.9 percent between November 2011 and November 2012. Of course, that's after home prices in the area plummeted by more than 50 percent peak-to-trough. A new report released by Trulia points out that just because home values are rising rapidly in certain area doesn’t mean these market are healthy.
Trulia’s latest report, “2013’s Top 10 Healthiest Housing Markets,” reviews the largest housing markets in the country based on what Trulia identifies as the three fundamental characteristics of a healthy housing market: strong job growth; low, but manageable, vacancy rates; and low foreclosure inventory. These are the best housing markets for 2013.
In an interview with 24/7 Wall St., Trulia’s Chief Economist Jed Kolko explained that while housing markets have increased in the last year, many of the increases are rebounds following big declines in home values. As a result, "markets with the biggest price increases are some of the boom and bust markets," including Phoenix, Las Vegas, Miami and Detroit. Housing prices in these places increased significantly, year over year.
Employment growth is also an important measure for housing demand. "When people have jobs, they are able to spend more on renting or buying, and they are more likely to buy,” Kolko said. The 10 metro areas projected to be the healthiest in 2013 have among the highest job growth in the U.S. All 10 are within the top 20 percent for job growth, primarily benefiting from vibrant technology and energy sectors. In Houston, one of best housing markets for 2013, employment grew by 3.6 percent between October 2011 and October 2012 -- the largest job growth of any major metro region.
Having low vacancy rates is also important to the long-term health of these markets. “High vacancy rates hold back price increases, they hold back construction, they hold back the recovery,” Kolko explained. A lower vacancy rate, while better for the health of the market, should not be too low, as extremely low vacancy constricts availability and drives up prices too much. All 10 of these markets have a vacancy rate below the average of 3.4 percent among the 100 largest metropolitan areas, but only two are among the 10 with the lowest rates.
Finally, these places have low foreclosure inventory. Places with low foreclosure inventory had less severe declines during the recession. Of the 10 healthiest housing markets for 2013, few had severe declines, peak-to-trough, in home value. Because of this, there are fewer homes on the market that had been foreclosed. In these cities, rising home prices can be more fairly said to be the result of a growing market rather than the result of depressed prices due to the market being flooded with foreclosed homes. Bethesda, one of the metro areas on this list, had a foreclosure inventory of just 2.7 per 1,000 units, the fourth-smallest proportion in the country.
24/7 Wall St. reviewed the housing markets identified in Trulia’s “2013’s Top 10 Healthiest Housing Markets.” To make this list, these markets needed to have high job growth, low vacancy rates, and low foreclosure inventory. Job growth was calculated over 12 months through October. Vacancy rate is for November, and foreclosures per 1,000 units is for October. In addition to these data, Trulia also provided year-over-year change in home prices through November, year-over-year change in asking price through November, year-to-date construction permits per 1,000 units through October and the peak-to-trough decline in home prices during the recession.
These are the best housing markets for 2013.
1. Houston, Tex.
· Job growth: 3.6 percent
· Vacancy rate: 3.0 percent
· Construction permits: 15.4 per 1,000 homes
Houston is projected to be the nation’s strongest housing market in 2013. The area’s job market grew by 3.6 percent over the previous year through October -- higher than any other major housing market. At 7.7 homes per 1,000 units, the area also had a larger foreclosure inventory than many of the other top markets for 2013. Asking prices also remained low despite growing demand at a median of just $86.03 per square foot -- lower than most major markets. According to Trulia’s Kolko, “affordable home prices have attracted people and jobs to Houston, and in turn, we’ve seen strong construction activity continue there.” Commercial real estate is also booming, according to The New York Times, with especially high demand for properties in the Woodlands planned community.
2. San Francisco, Calif.
· Job growth: 3.4 percent
· Vacancy rate: 1.7 percent
· Construction permits: 4.6 per 1,000 homes
The big thing going for the San Francisco housing market has been its job market, which grew by 3.4 percent during the first 10 months of the year. This was fourth-highest job growth of the top 100 metro areas. Even with the market taking a bigger hit than most during the housing downturn, it has made a comeback recently. Year-over-year asking prices as of the end of November were up 9.5 percent, among the best growth in the country. San Francisco homes were the most expensive on a square foot basis, with a median square foot asking price of $476.55 within the last 12 months.
3. Bethesda-Rockville-Frederick, Md.
· Job growth: 2.8 percent
· Vacancy rate: 1.2 percent
· Construction permits: 6.7 per 1,000 homes
The 2.8 percent job growth in the first 10 months of 2012 was one of the highest rates in the United States. Area home prices have been pushed upwards by limited supply: the Bethesda-Rockville-Frederick area had one of the nation’s lowest vacancy rates, at 1.2 percent in November, as well as one of its lowest foreclosure inventories, at just 2.7 homes per 1,000 units during October. Through November, the asking price per square foot for homes in the area was lower than only 14 other metro areas. Over the last year, asking prices have risen just 5.5 percent and median price per square foot was $169.15, slightly higher than Washington, D.C.
4. San Antonio, Texas
· Job growth: 2.7 percent
· Vacancy rate: 2.8 percent
· Construction permits: 8.5 per 1,000 homes
San Antonio is one of four top housing markets for 2013 located in Texas. Through November, the median asking price per square foot in the area was just $88.44, less than nearly two-thirds of the nation’s largest real estate markets. Also, as of November, asking prices in the area had risen just 0.8 percent from the year before, less than any other top market for 2013. But like other areas in Texas, including Austin, Fort Worth and Houston, San Antonio is building rapidly. For the first 10 months of 2012, there were 8.5 construction permits per 1,000 units in the metro area, faster than all but 14 other areas in the United States. The region also was relatively unaffected by the housing crisis, as home prices fell by 3.2 percent from peak-to-trough.
5. Austin, Tex.
· Job growth: 3.5 percent
· Vacancy rate: 1.2 percent
· Construction permits: 21.5 per 1,000 homes
The Austin metropolitan area has benefited from a combination of job growth and declining vacancy rates.The 3.5 percent job growth in the first 10 months of 2012 was the third largest of all metro areas driven by a surge in job growth in sectors such as technology, education, health care and construction. Meanwhile, the 1.2 percent vacancy rate was the third-lowest of all metropolitan areas. Construction levels were at 120 percent of local historical normal levels in the first eight months of 2012, while there were 21.5 construction permits per 1,000 residents in the first 10 months. Both figures were better than any of the 100 largest housing markets.