IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Wall Street falls, then rises, after chaotic debate fuel investors' fears of contested election

"Trump is very clearly laying the groundwork to dispute the election," said one analyst.
Image: President Donald Trump and Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden participate in their first 2020 presidential campaign debate held on the campus of the Cleveland Clinic at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio
President Donald Trump and Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden participate in their first 2020 presidential campaign debate held on the campus of the Cleveland Clinic at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio, Sept. 29, 2020.Morry Gash / Reuters
/ Source: Reuters

Wall Street turned positive on Wednesday morning, paring losses after a chaotic presidential debate between incumbent Donald Trump and Democratic challenger Joe Biden heightened fears that a disputed ballot could lead to a messy transfer of power.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose by around 200 points, with the S&P 500 up by 0.4 percent and the tech-heavy Nasdaq up 0.2 percent.

Nagging doubts over whether President Trump would agree to hand over the keys to the White House if he loses have grown in recent weeks. During the first debate on Tuesday, Trump declined to commit to accepting the results, repeating his unfounded complaint that mail-in ballots would lead to election fraud.

"The debate drew further attention to the potential for a contested election," said Hani Redha, a portfolio manager at Pinebridge. "It is likely market participants will continue to price in this issue, heightening volatility all the way to election day and its immediate aftermath."

Options on the S&P 500 index showed investors bracing for volatility in November and December — likely because the use of mail-in ballots by voters concerned about the coronavirus could mean delays of weeks or even months in announcing the winner.

"You can see the concern especially if you look at the shift in U.S. index futures pre-debate to post debate... certainly the concern was centered on the scope for post-election disputes," said Chris Bailey, European strategist at Raymond James.

Trump declined last week to commit to a peaceful transfer of power if he loses, and said he expected the election battle to end up before the Supreme Court.

"Trump is very clearly laying the groundwork to dispute the election," said John Woolfitt, director of trading at Atlantic Capital Markets, a brokerage.

"Many Americans do not understand their own electoral process, it is not officially called on the night, it is usually unofficially called by the press and it requires the president (or challenger) to concede."

Biden, 77, has held a consistent lead over Trump, 74, in opinion polls, although surveys in the battleground states that will decide the election show a closer contest.

More than a million Americans are already casting early ballots and time is running out to change minds or influence the small sliver of undecided voters.

The first of three scheduled debates came at a fraught moment on Wall Street. The S&P 500 tumbled around 10 percent from record highs this month before paring some of those losses as investors fretted about the coronavirus impact and election uncertainty.

Some investors view Biden as more likely to raise taxes, and see a second term for Trump, who favors tax cuts and deregulation, as better for the stock market. However, a Trump win could spell more tensions between Washington and Beijing.

Before the 2016 election, investors widely predicted that a Trump victory would hurt stocks due to his unpredictability and trade war threats against China and Mexico. However, the S&P 500 surged 5 percent in the month following his unexpected election win.