IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Kentucky Community Still Fearful 20 Years After Erica Fraysure Disappears

Erica Fraysure was last seen in her hometown of Brooksville, Kentucky on October 21, 1997. She has never been seen or heard from since.

With a population of fewer than 650 people, everyone seems to know each other in the small town of Brooksville, Kentucky.

Which is why it's so strange that a 17-year-old could disappear without anyone in the town knowing.

Yet, on October 21, 1997, Erica Fraysure disappeared from that small Kentucky town, and hasn’t been seen since.

17-year-old Erica Fraysure at the time of her disappearance.
17-year-old Erica Fraysure at the time of her disappearance.

For 20 years, people in Brooksville have lived with the fear that the same person who might have taken Erica, could be right down the street, simply waiting for another opportunity to abduct another unsuspecting teen.

Amanda Lang, Erica’s best friend, tells Dateline that her life plans changed dramatically after Erica disappeared. Suddenly, she was too afraid to leave her house or go away for college.

“I was supposed to go to the local university for college on a graphic arts degree. And I was too scared to leave. So I stayed home and I went to the community college. And I just never left,” Amanda said. “I was always too scared.”

Erica vanished after a night of cruising the streets in her Pontiac Bonneville with friends -- a normal thing for teenagers to do in the town back then.

“Back then, to hang out with your friends on a Friday night or a Saturday night, you got in your parents’ car, or your own car if you were lucky enough, and you went to Brooksville and you cruised town,” Amanda told Dateline. “That’s what we did.”

People in Brooksville had started to notice Erica hanging out with what Amanda called a “rough crowd.” So when Erica’s mother called police to report that her daughter hadn’t returned home that October night, friends assumed she was just out being a willful teenager.

“I thought, ‘She’s a teenager, she probably went and got drunk and she fell asleep at somebody’s house and they’ll find her’,” Amanda said.

As night turned to day, there was still no word from Erica. According to Amanda, the principal of Bracken County High School, where Erica was a student, made a school-wide announcement telling students to share any information they knew about Erica’s whereabouts the night before.

Chief Deputy Bob Scott from the Bracken County Police Department told Dateline that authorities found Erica’s car abandoned on a country road later that day. The keys were missing and her purse was still inside the car, untouched. However, there wasn’t enough evidence to help investigators piece together what happened the night Erica disappeared.

“There was nothing in the car that would lead anyone to believe there was foul play,” Chief Deputy Scott said. “We weren’t even able to find fingerprints. There were no foreign hairs, nothing in the purse.”

Amanda told Dateline she and Erica spent every day together, laughing and passing notes in class. They even shared a locker in high school. That day in school though, just before Erica went missing, the two friends had argued. It would be Amanda’s final memory with her best friend.

“I just remember feeling sorry for myself that first day, because I was alone,” Amanda said. “It turns out I was alone for the rest of the senior year.”

Amanda says the most traumatizing part of Erica’s disappearance, for her, came the following spring, when she saw Erica’s empty seat at graduation. She -- and the rest of her 1998 graduating class -- was forced to come to terms with the idea that one of their classmates might be gone for good. In Erica’s case, her best friend might be gone for good.

And now 20 years have passed, and Amanda and the entire Brooksville community are left with the same unanswered questions.

Age-progression photo shows Erica to be 30 years old. Photo from 2010.
Age-progression photo shows Erica to be 30 years old. Photo from 2010.NamUs

“We don't know any more about what happened to Erica now than we did the day we first examined her vehicle,” Chief Deputy Scott told Dateline.

Amanda wasn’t with Erica cruising around town in her car that night, but another friend was: Shane Simcox. Simcox was 20 years old at the time, and in a 1997 interview with ABC affiliate WCPO he admitted to being the last person to see Erica alive.

Simcox hasn’t spoken out about that night since.

Chief Deputy Scott identified Simcox as a person of interest in the case in 1997, and requested that he take a lie detector test to prove that he wasn’t involved in Erica’s disappearance. Simcox refused to take the test. Chief Deputy Scott told Dateline there were other persons of interest in the case, but authorities couldn’t charge them because of a lack of hard evidence. In fact, no suspects have been named in Erica’s case.

Both of Erica’s parents have died since their daughter’s disappearance.

“Her mom lived in torment,” Amanda said. “Her parents died without ever knowing a single thing about what happened, and it’s not right.”

Amanda told Dateline she didn’t realize how important Erica’s friendship was to her until Erica was gone.

“When people talk about her now, they don't really know the side that I knew,” she said. “She would walk through fire for the people that she loved. I had no idea that I had this ruby -- this diamond -- of a friend.”

Kentucky State Trooper Charles Loudermilk says the case is ongoing, but without new information, the case is at a standstill.

“We know that she went out, we know that her car was found, but we don’t know that middle piece,” State Trooper Loudermilk told Dateline. That middle piece, he said, can make the difference in solving this puzzling case.

Since the day Erica went missing, Amanda says the community hasn’t been the same.

As Erica’s former classmates started having children of their own, Amanda says they’ve become helicopter parents, hovering over their children’s every move, in an attempt to keep them safe.

“I don’t even let my kids walk to the mailbox -- and my daughter is almost 13 -- because I’m scared,” she told Dateline. “It changes you. It really changes who you are , and how fast you had to grow up.”

Before Erica disappeared, “I was fearless,” said Amanda. “I thought I was invincible like every teenager, but we all grew up. We grew up way too fast. I see teenagers now and they don’t get it. And I hope they don’t have to.”

Amanda told Dateline, if someone would come forward and tell what they know about Erica’s disappearance, she thinks the community could finally have the closure they’ve waited on for two decades.

“I think it would certainly bring me peace. Maybe if I knew that she was murdered and we knew who it was,” Amanda said. “Then I think we would all be able to find some peace and not live so scared anymore.”

Trooper Loudermilk urges anyone with information about what happened to Erica to call the Kentucky State Police at 859-428-1212.