IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Don’t kill the krill, fishery experts urge

Arguing the shrimp-like creatures are more valuable in the ocean because of their role in the marine food chain, fishery managers have urged the federal government to prohibit krill fishing off Pacific waters.
Krill are tiny, shrimp-like creatures that other marine wildlife, from seabirds to whales, rely on for their diets.Benjamin Saenz / AP file
/ Source: The Associated Press

They're tiny but live in massive underwater swarms. They make salmon flesh red. Humpback whales eat them by the ton.

They are krill, shrimp-like creatures that scientists say are the ocean's fundamental food source.

But despite their huge volumes, scientists worry that the growth in fish farms may produce a  krill market off the West Coast to feed captive fish.

Those fears were allayed Wednesday when fishery managers, meeting this week in Seattle, moved to prohibit krill fishing off Pacific shores.

The Pacific Fishery Management Council, an advisory board to the National Marine Fisheries Service, approved the krill harvest ban. The recommendation must now be approved by the agency.

Concern about krill surfaced in 2004 when managers of the Monterey Bay, Gulf of the Farallones Island and Cordell Banks National Marine Sanctuaries in California raised a preemptive red flag.

Key to marine food chain
Since krill are a vital part of the aquatic food chain — they are the diet of everything from fish and seabirds to giant baleen whales — the scientists said they should be absolutely protected.

"Our concern is that a targeted krill fishery would threaten the health of the region's fishing economy and culture," said Rachel Saunders, spokeswoman for Monterey Bay sanctuary.

Fishermen, environmental groups and scientists supported the council's actions. Krill fishing already is banned in state and federal waters off Alaska.

One lone fisherman, Ryan Kapp, of Bellingham, Wash., said he thought it would have been "neat" to try out krill fishing on a small scale off the coast of Oregon and Washington.

He said had been krill fishing in Canadian waters, where limited harvests are allowed.

"I thought heck, if they have something, I thought we could have something," he said.

But Kapp was a lone voice in opposition. About 6,000 comments filed with the council urged the ban.

Loophole exists now
A federal ban would fill a loophole that exists in state law. California, Oregon and Washington prohibit krill harvesting for local fishermen. But fishermen from other states could harvest krill in the area and then land the catch in their home ports. And with no federal ban until now, foreign fisherman also could have fished for krill off the West Coast.

Although officials said there is no known interest in krill harvesting, the idea wasn't beyond the realm of possibility. Most krill fishing is done with huge trawlers in the Antarctic. The vessels travel thousands of miles and spend months at sea, said Roger Hewitt, a biologist with NOAA Fisheries.

He said about 100,000 tons of krill are caught there annually. Smaller catches are made off Japan and British Columbia. Krill is a fragile catch that must be immediately frozen once brought aboard, Hewitt said.

The market for krill may be on the rise, officials said. Krill is eaten by people in Japan and Russia and its oil is sold in U.S. health-food markets as an anti-aging remedy.

But mostly, krill is used to feed fish, from home aquariums to fish farms. Fed to farm-raised salmon, krill give the fish the reddish hue found in their wild counterparts.

Easy to ‘wipe out’ krill patch
Schools of krill, miles long and wide, swarm on deep underwater cliffs off the West Coast and are easy prey for marine life like blue whales.

The concentrations also make krill an easy catch for human fishers, who scoop them up with giant, fine-meshed nets.

"You could wipe out a krill patch pretty quickly," said Don Croll, a biology professor at the University of California at Santa Cruz.

Krill also are vulnerable to ocean conditions, Hewitt said. When cold water is drawn down from the north, krill populations thrive.

But when the trend is reversed, in so-called El Nino years, the krill suffer — and the impact is felt up the food chain. This occurred last year and several seabirds died as a result.

Now that the council has proposed a federal ban, Ben Enticknap, a spokesman for the environmental group Oceana, said they'll move to extend the ban to all U.S. waters.

NMFS likely will make a final decision on the ban in the next six months.