The London Stock Exchange on Monday spurned a fresh takeover bid from The Nasdaq Stock Market Inc., saying it “substantially undervalued” the London Market.
Nasdaq, taking its second try to take over the LSE, offered to buy the more than 70 percent of the shares it doesn’t already own in a deal which values the entire London bourse at $5.1 billion.
“We believe Nasdaq’s final offer fails to recognize the outstanding growth record and prospects of our group on a standalone basis let alone the exchange’s unique global position,” said Clara Furse, chief executive of the London Stock Exchange.
New York-based Nasdaq, which accumulated 25.1 percent of LSE shares during a takeover bid earlier this year, on Monday offered 12.43 pounds ($23.56) per share in cash for the rest. It then announced further purchases which raised its stake to 28.75 percent.
The offer represents a premium of 54 percent on LSE’s closing share price March 10, the day before the LSE said it had received an approach, and was the minimum bid it could make under British takeover rules.
“This is a long game that we’re playing, and I’m optimistic we’ll engage with the London Stock Exchange board in a relatively short period of time,” Nasdaq Chief Executive Robert Greifeld told analysts after being informed of the rejection. “As the process moves along, the likelihood we’ll engage with the board increases day by day.”
LSE shares traded above the offered price, rising 5.9 percent to 12.90 pounds ($24.45) in afternoon trading in London. Nasdaq shares rose 47 cents to $37.04 in trading on the Nasdaq Stock Market.
The combination would be the world’s largest equity market by listings, Nasdaq said, with more than 6,400 quoted companies with a total market capitalization of about $11.3 trillion — a giant ready to slug it out if necessary with a new European exchange which seven major investment banks say they plan to create.
It would also create a trans-Atlantic rival to the company that would be created by New York Stock Exchange’s proposed acquisition of the four Euronext exchanges.
The London Stock Exchange, Europe’s oldest, now takes about half of the initial public offerings in Europe including a many of the flotations from Russia and Eastern Europe.
Earlier this month, the LSE reported that first-half net profit more than doubled to 54.1 million pounds ($103.2 million), as electronic trading increased 56 percent and income from initial public offerings rose.
“In the year to October, the exchange has underlined its position as the world’s primary listing venue with 22.3 billion pounds ($45.3 billion) raised through IPOs, 96 percent more than the same period in 2005 and more than any other exchange so far this year,” the LSE in rejecting the Nasdaq bid.
Katrina Preston, an analyst at Bridgewell Securities, had anticipated that the LSE would reject the offer, arguing that it “does not represent sufficient value compared with trading valuations of rival exchanges.”
But Fox-Pitt Kelton analyst Andrew Mitchell said the bid was shrewdly timed following last week’s slump in the share price below 13 pounds, and that it would be “difficult for London to defend itself.”
Earlier this year, Nasdaq made an offer of 9.50 pounds per share for the LSE, but abruptly withdrew in March.
Australia’s Macquarie Bank Ltd., Germany’s Deutsche Bourse AG and Sweden’s OM Gruppen have all failed in previous overtures to take over Europe’s oldest exchange.
Mitchell said Nasdaq has no obvious rivals this time around.
“Deutsche Boerse attempted before at a much lower level and you can’t rule them out entirely, but they are an unlikely candidate,” he said.
The New York Stock Exchange owner, NYSE Group Inc., agreed in June to pay $9.96 billion for Euronext, which operates the Paris, Amsterdam, Brussels and Lisbon exchanges. The bid subsequently rose to $13 billion.
The combined sales of Nasdaq and LSE would be about $1.4 billion, based on their last set of full-year results. That compares with about $2.3 billion for NYSE-Euronext.
Nasdaq’s Greifeld said he wasn’t concerned about last week’s news that seven major investment banks — Citigroup Inc., Credit Suisse Group, Deutsche Bank AG, Goldman Sachs Group Inc., Merrill Lynch & Co., Morgan Stanley and UBS AG — plan to launch their own European equities exchange next year.
“It’s important to note that Nasdaq was not born through a historical monopoly. It has had to compete. We clearly have our competitive instincts engaged,” Greifeld told reporters.
Greifeld said Nasdaq would cut transaction fees as trading volumes rise.
“That will be a hallmark of the combined entity,” he said.
Analyst David Buik of Cantor Index said the investment banks’ plan was a strong reason for a Nasdaq-LSE tie-up.
“The ramifications of dismissing Nasdaq’s overtures could be serious,” Buik said, adding that bourses must cut their fees to remain competitive.