President Bush drew startling criticism Tuesday night from Republican White House hopefuls unhappy with his handling of the Iraq war, his diplomatic style and his approach to immigration.
“I would certainly not send him to the United Nations” to represent the United States, said Tommy Thompson, the former Wisconsin governor and one-time member of Bush’s Cabinet, midway through a spirited campaign debate.
Arizona Sen. John McCain criticized the administration for its handling of the Iraq war, and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney said, “I think we were underprepared and underplanned for what came after we knocked down Saddam Hussein.”
Rep. Duncan Hunter of California said the current administration “has the slows” when it comes to building a security fence along the border with Mexico.
Rep. Tom Tancredo of Colorado recalled that White House aide Karl Rove had once told him “never darken the door of the White House.” The congressman said he’d tell Bush the same thing.
The Republicans sprinkled the criticism of Bush throughout a two-hour debate that ranged over topics from war to immigration legislation pending in Congress to religion.
Sen. Sam Brownback of Kansas and Hunter both said they would pardon Vice President Dick Cheney’s former aide I. Lewis “Scooter” Libby, sentenced to 30 months in prison earlier in the day for lying and obstructing a CIA leak investigation.
Former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, a former prosecutor, said the sentence was excessive, which “argues in favor of a pardon.”
Much of the debate focused on Iraq.
McCain and Brownback both admitted they voted to authorize the U.S. military invasion of Iraq without reading the formal national intelligence estimate in advance.
The confession drew a jab from former Gov. Jim Gilmore of Virginia. Members of Congress “ought to read at least that kind of material,” he said.
Hunter said he had, the only member of Congress on the debate stage to make the claim.
Both McCain and Brownback said they had received numerous briefings on the situation in Iraq before they cast their votes in 2002.
National intelligence estimates are compilations of the best thinking of U.S. intelligence agencies, meant to provide the broadest guidance to government policymakers.
But they can be wrong. A 2002 assessment, for example, concluded that Iraq had continued its development of weapons of mass destruction, held arsenals of chemical and biological weapons, and “probably will have a nuclear weapon during this decade.”
Jab at Sen. Clinton
McCain drew loud applause from the partisan debate audience when he turned a question about the war in Iraq into criticism of one of the leading Democratic presidential hopefuls, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York.
“When Senator Clinton says this is Mr. Bush’s war, President Bush’s war,” she is wrong, he said. “When President Clinton was in power, I didn’t say Bosnia was President Clinton’s war,” the Arizona senator said.
“Presidents don’t lose wars. Political parties don’t lose wars. Nations lose wars,” he added.
The criticism of Clinton and the Democrats was standard campaign fare for Republican candidates.
Harsh words for Bush
But the jabs at the Republican president — traveling overseas — was a reflection of his poor poll ratings and the need of even members of his own party to campaign on platforms of change.
McCain has long criticized Bush for fumbling the aftermath of Saddam’s fall, and Romney has recently begun to make some of the same criticisms.
Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee added his voice to those criticizing the war effort. He added that the Bush administration “lost credibility” with its response to Hurricane Katrina in 2005.
Thompson’s answer was perhaps the most startling, coming from a man who had once served in the president’s Cabinet as secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services.
Bush’s support for the pending immigration legislation was the source of Tancredo’s criticism, and the issue figured prominently in the debate.
McCain, alone among the contenders on the St. Anselm College debate stage, supports the measure, and he sought to fend off criticism from some of his rivals.
“We cannot have 12 million people washing around America illegally, my friends,” he said.
But Giuliani said the legislation was flawed, “a typical Washington mess.”
He said it lacks a uniform method of identification for immigrants in the United States, and overall, “it is quite possible it will make things worse.”
Romney passed up a chance to criticize McCain, who has accused the former Massachusetts governor of a flip-flop on immigration.
“I’m not going to make this a matter of personal politics,” he said. He went on to criticize a feature of the legislation that gives the estimated 12 million immigrants currently in the country illegally a permanent visa while they wait to have their status changed.
“It’s simply not fair to say those people get put ahead in the line of all the people who’ve been waiting legally to come to this country,” he said.