IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Daughter, boyfriend allegedly confess to slayings

A 29-year-old daughter and her boyfriend have admitted they killed her parents and four other family members in rural Carnation, court documents showed.
Image: Ben Anderson, grandson of a couple killed along with four other family members, watches during a hearing in a King County Jail courtroom
Ben Anderson, grandson of a couple killed along with four other family members, watches during a hearing in a King County Jail courtroom on Thursday in Seattle. Anderson's aunt and her boyfriend were accused of killing her parents and four others on Christmas Eve.Elaine Thompson / AP
/ Source: The Associated Press

A woman and her boyfriend confessed to methodically gunning down her parents, her brother and sister-in-law, and then her 6-year-old niece and 3-year-old nephew in a Christmas Eve slaughter in rural Carnation, according to court papers filed Thursday.

Michelle Andersen, 29, and Joe McEnroe, 29, were ordered held without bail after an initial court appearance Thursday. Formal charges have not yet been filed, but both were arrested Wednesday for investigation of six counts of homicide.

In flat, unemotional prose, sheriff's Detective John Pavlovich described the horrific killings outlined by McEnroe.

First, Pavlovich wrote, the couple shot her parents, Wayne and Judy Anderson, using large-caliber pistols and dragged the bodies to a shed. A short time later, the dead couple's son, Scott, his wife, Erica, their son, Nathan, and daughter, Olivia, arrived for a Christmas Eve visit.

"Knowing that Scott and his family were potential witnesses, Joe and Michele shot them," Pavlovich wrote. "Joe shot Scott with the 9mm (once); he then shot Erica at least (once) with the 9mm and then turned his attention to Olivia and Nathan. He shot them both in the head (once), killing them."

Both McEnroe and Anderson confessed to authorities, according to court papers. Anderson said both of them shot her parents, brother and sister-in-law, while McEnroe killed the children, according to a separate affidavit. Neither document gives a motive for the deaths.

Suspects lived nearby
McEnroe and Anderson, who had been together for six years, lived in a trailer about 200 yards from her parents' house.

The court documents indicate the couple tried to flee to Canada after the killings, but returned to the scene the following day for some reason, where they were detained and confessed.

Both defendants waived their right to appear in court before King County District Court Judge Mark Chow.

McEnroe appeared briefly in the courtroom, with disheveled brown hair, dressed in a white jumpsuit, but then left with his attorney, who came back and said he waived his right to appear.

The county prosecutor's office expects to have a decision regarding charges Friday.

Michele Anderson's attorney, public defender George Eppler, said he spoke with her briefly before the hearing.

"She was bearing up well. She was speaking to me with ... some stoic forbearance. She asked the appropriate questions that showed keen insight," asking about the next legal steps in the case, Eppler said.

When asked if she admitted guilt, Eppler said, "We limited our conversation solely to the issue of today's court appearance."

911 call made Christmas Eve
The victims were discovered at the elder Anderson's rural home near Carnation, about 25 miles east of Seattle, on Wednesday morning by a co-worker of Judith Anderson, who was worried when she did not show up for her job at the Post Office.

Investigators are trying to determine why deputies, responding to a 911 call made from the home on Monday, stopped at a locked gate.

A relative, Ben Anderson, told reporters outside his grandparents' property late Wednesday that money could have been a factor in the deaths.

"She felt she wasn't loved enough and everyone didn't appreciate her and she was pushed out of everyone's life," he said, referring to Michele Anderson.

A family friend, Mark Bennett, described Wayne as a hardworking Boeing Co. engineer who liked to hunt fish and hunt, and said Judy was a Postal Service worker who "always had a smile and a happy face on her route delivering mail."

"There's nobody ever who's going to say a bad thing about them," he said.