IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

1988 murders of N.Y. couple could be reopened

Double Murder Confession
Convicted of murdering his parents in 1988, Martin Tankleff enters a Riverhead, N.Y., courtroom for his bail hearing on Dec. 27 after his conviction was overturned. He was later released.Kirk J. Condyles / AP
/ Source: The Associated Press

The state's attorney general said Saturday he will lead a new investigation into the 1988 murders of a couple whose son served 17 years in prison before an appeals court said he might be innocent.

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo said Gov. Eliot Spitzer appointed him as a special prosecutor in the case of Arlene and Seymour Tankleff, who were bludgeoned and stabbed to death at their home on Long Island.

"I'm confident that we can look at it independently, with a top team of prosecutors, that will follow the evidence wherever it leads," Cuomo said.

Martin Tankleff was charged with the murders at age 17 and convicted in 1990, but a state appeals court overturned his conviction last month, saying new evidence about other possible suspects was compelling enough to warrant a new trial.

Tankleff's lawyers have contended for years that forensic evidence never supported his disputed confession, and that police had ignored evidence suggesting that the murders were the work of a disgruntled family business associate.

He was released from prison on bail and Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota announced that he would drop the case rather than try to put on a new trial. The charge was to be formally dismissed next Friday.

However, Cuomo told The Associated Press on Saturday that, with the new investigation barely under way, he is unlikely to make a decision by Friday on whether to have the charge dismissed as Spota planned.

"We'll want to preserve all of our options," Cuomo said.

Tankleff's attorneys have demanded for years that a special prosecutor be appointed to replace Spota, but they said Saturday that any delay in the dismissal of the charges would be unfair.

"My concern is needlessly delaying the inevitable," said one of Tankleff's lawyers, Barry J. Pollack. He said he was confident, however, that Cuomo's investigative team would also conclude that Tankleff should not face a retrial.

Spota said in a statement that he supported the appointment of a special prosecutor and would cooperate "fully and completely" with Cuomo's office.

Tankleff was convicted largely on the strength of a confession he gave to police on the day of the murders.

Investigators used a ruse, telling him his father had regained consciousness and implicated him.

"Could I have blacked out ... and done this?" Tankleff said. He then allegedly told police that his memory was returning, and gave an account of the killings.

Almost immediately, however, Tankleff retracted the confession and claimed it had been the result of emotional manipulation.