Court tosses White House appeal on visitor logs

/ Source: The Associated Press

A federal appeals court on Friday set back the White House's efforts to keep the names of its visitors secret.

The three-member panel of judges threw out the government's appeal in a case brought by a watchdog group trying to find out how often prominent religious conservatives visited the White House and Vice President Dick Cheney's residence.

The Bush administration was appealing a federal judge's decision last December that the government should gather the records the watchdog group wants.

Despite the ruling against the White House, public disclosure of visitor logs is by no means assured.

The Bush administration can still raise a variety of legal arguments in an attempt to keep the identities of White House visitors secret.

But appeals court Judge David Tatel said the document request from Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington is narrowly drawn and can be processed.

Handling CREW's request would not require the president, Cheney or their staffs to sort through mountains of files, said Tatel.

The burden "should prove minimal," he added.

The case now goes back to U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth, who ruled that White House visitor logs are public documents subject to disclosure requests under the Freedom of Information Act.

The Bush administration argued that releasing those documents would trample on the president's right to seek private, confidential advice.

Secret Service exemption
White House calendars are not normally considered public, but Lamberth said logs maintained by the Secret Service are not covered by that exemption.

While Friday's ruling was a loss for the Bush White House, the wait for the ruling delayed activity in the case for seven months, bringing the administration that much closer to the time when President Bush leaves office.

In the midst of the Jack Abramoff lobbying scandal several years ago, the Secret Service acquiesced as the White House and Cheney's office took control of the White House visitor records.

President Clinton's political opponents made extensive use of 1990s Secret Service logs documenting White House visits by donors, fundraisers, pardon-seekers, and former White House intern Monica Lewinsky.

Tatel, the judge who wrote the appeals court opinion, is a Clinton appointee. The other two members of the panel were Chief Judge David Sentelle, an appointee of President Reagan; and appeals judge Merrick Garland, a Clinton appointee.

CREW brought its lawsuit for the records against the Department of Homeland Security, of which the Secret Service is a part.

The appeals judges rejected the Bush administration's reliance on a 2004 Supreme Court ruling that the judicial branch of government should hesitate before putting the president or vice president in the position of having to invoke specific privileges. The appeals court said it found that separation-of-powers argument unpersuasive in the current case.

In the 2004 ruling in favor of the Bush administration, Cheney himself was being sued for records of meetings between company executives and lobbyists and the vice president's energy task force, which drafted a report highly supportive of the energy industry's agenda.