IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Detroit auto show has electric atmosphere

Automakers at this year’s Detroit auto show are doing all they can to paint themselves as the greenest automakers in town. But don’t believe the hype. By Dan Carney.
Image: Toyota Prius 2010
Toyota predicts the 2010 Prius will achieve a combined 50 miles per gallon in EPA highway and city testing. That compares to 46 mpg in the older model hybrid.Marijan Murat / EPA

The curious dichotomy of the 2009 Detroit auto show is that, while the showmanship has diminished from years past (no Dodge Ram cattle drive past the Cobo Center, for instance), in other ways hype is still at an all-time high.

This year automakers are doing all they can to paint themselves as the greenest in town. The result is a tangle of fact, fiction and flat-out lies that can be tough to decipher.

Some start-ups and established manufacturers are unashamedly exhibiting science project cars purportedly running on electric power and promised for the not-too-distant future.

Others are making concrete advances, showing actual production hardware that will be in dealer showrooms in coming months, selling for prices regular consumers can afford and in volumes that can start to make a difference to drivers aiming to save on gasoline.

Of course, the reception these new models receive when they reach showrooms will be colored by the current price of gas.

“If all of these [cars] were introduced in last July’s fuel climate (consumers) would be delighted,” said Lindsay Brooke, senior editor for Automotive Engineering International magazine, an industry trade journal.

But as gas has fallen from a July peak of over $4 a gallon to well under $2 a gallon, consumers quickly have returned to their old habits. The U.S. market share for small and fuel-efficient vehicles, which rose to 25 percent in the summer as gas prices spiked, already has returned to the pre-summer level of about 15 percent, said Jim Farley, Ford vice president of marketing and communications, who joined the company from Toyota.

The leader of the hybrid movement, both in popular perception and in claimed fuel economy, is the all-new third-generation 2010 Toyota Prius, which goes on sale in the spring and was unveiled for the first time Monday.

Toyota predicts the new sedan will achieve a combined 50 mpg in EPA city and highway ratings, up from 46 mpg for the current edition.

(Because of the design of Toyota’s electric-heavy hybrid configuration — an approach shared by Ford — city fuel economy is better than highway because of the greater opportunity to rely on stored electric power.)

In an approach that would evoke scoffs from skeptics of domestic manufacturers, the new Prius uses a larger, 1.8-liter inline-four-cylinder engine to achieve improved highway fuel economy. The bigger engine doesn’t work as hard and can spin at lower rpm, so it uses less gas at highway speeds and during cold startup times when the Prius must bring the gas engine up to operating temperature before it can begin its electric-only operation.

The new Prius is also quicker, accelerating from zero to 60 mph in 9.5 seconds.

“A little larger engine displacement allows a state of tune that lets [Toyota] reach a compromise for a little better efficiency and power,” observed Kevin Smith, editorial director for

By increasing its power, Toyota said it was responding to complaints from current Prius owners that the car is sluggish, but “I don’t imagine that a lot of prospective Prius buyers are very concerned with zero-to-60 times,” Smith said.

Building on its experience with hybrid technology, Toyota was able to shrink the electric hardware under the hood of the new Prius, whittling away 20 percent of the weight of the electric power inverter, motor and transaxle.

The car itself is incrementally larger, but the company was able to pack an extra five cubic feet of cabin space inside, thanks in part to moving the roof peak back a few inches. This increases headroom inside and smoothes airflow outside because of the resulting “wedgier” shape.

Toyota predicts it will sell 180,000 of the new Prius in the U.S. annually, topping the 160,000 unit-high watermark of the previous version. Price for the new version has not been set. The current model starts at about $22,000 for the standard version.

On Sunday, Honda officially unveiled its Insight hybrid model, which observers noticed bears a strong resemblance to the Prius. That’s because both cars were shaped by the same dictates of minimal aerodynamic drag and maximum cabin space rather than an attempt by Honda to ape its Japanese rival.

The Insight’s hybrid design is philosophically different from Toyota’s, functioning as a primarily gas-powered vehicle with an electric assist motor, a decision that produces better highway fuel economy than city mileage. The Insight also has the potential to cost less than the Prius because it uses a smaller battery and electric motor.

As with the Prius, Honda has not announced the price of its new Insight, but said that it will be below that of its Civic hybrid, so look for it to start around $20,000.

Ford, meanwhile, applied an electric-heavy design to its new Fusion hybrid, which the automaker is showing this year in Detroit. The car is aimed to compete more directly against the Toyota’s Camry hybrid rather than the Prius.

The hybrid Focus features a 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine designed to give the car muscle on the highway, but its city-centric electric drive system is so efficient that its regenerative braking system recovers 94 percent of available energy, according to Praveen Cherian, Ford’s hybrid project leader.

As a result, Ford claims the Fusion hybrid can go more than 700 miles on a tank of gas in city driving conditions.

Why is the Fusion hybrid’s drive system so efficient? It’s critical to size the hardware correctly, said Cherian. With the right hardware in place, software programmers spend countless late nights perfecting its operation.

“It comes down to calibration smarts,” he explained. “With all of these power conversions and losses, the [companies] who succeed are the ones that minimize the losses.”

Hybrid technology might not be here forever. It is a “bridge” technology meant to help consumers move from gasoline to electric power in a world where there is no electric infrastructure yet in place, said Smith of

“How long that bridge will be remains to be seen,” he added.

Ultimately, pure battery-run electric cars and fuel cell cars should displace hybrids, once the necessary infrastructures are in place to support them, Smith said. Ford announced plans to sell a pure battery electric van to commercial customers in 2011, and it promises to offer a car to retail consumers in 2012.

However, electric vehicles running on batteries will be marginal for some time because of limited range and opportunities to recharge them.

Tesla showed its battery-powered roadster in Detroit, but it costs just over $100,000 so is not a practical solution for the near future. Exotic carmaker Fisker Automotive and two Chinese car manufacturers — Brilliance and BYD — also showed electric cars that seem unlikely to have a dramatic effect on mainstream consumers. 

Even Chrysler resorted to offering some solutions that are not terribly practical, showing an all-electric two-seater based on the same Lotus platform as the Tesla. For now, it seems, car consumers must still dream of a future unshackled from the vagaries of gas prices.