IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Tax credit fuels surge in April home sales

A now-expired homebuyer tax credit and low mortgage rates helped boost sales of previously occupied homes in April. The improvements aren't likely to last.
Image: house for sake
A sold sign is posted outside a home April 27 in Mariemont, Ohio. Home prices rose in nearly 60 percent of U.S. cities in the first quarter of this year, thanks in part to a government tax credit.Al Behrman / AP file
/ Source: The Associated Press

A now-expired homebuyer tax credit and low mortgage rates helped boost sales of previously occupied homes in April. The improvements aren't likely to last.

The tax credit is now gone. And economists caution that Americans are facing so many financial obstacles that falling rates alone won't be enough to lift the housing market.

"Although mortgage rates have fallen sharply, the combination of high unemployment, heavy indebtedness and tight credit suggest to us that demand will stumble," said Paul Dales, an economist at Capital Economics.

Sales of previously owned homes rose 7.6 percent to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 5.77 million, the National Association of Realtors said Monday.

The sales increase sparked a rise in home prices. The median price for a new home rose to $173,100, up 4 percent from a year ago.

Mortgage rates fell last week to the lowest level for the year. The average rate on a 30-year loan ticked up slightly to 4.87 on Monday, according to financial publisher HSH Associates. That was just above the record low of 4.83 percent last December,

Worries over the European debt crisis have sent investors rushing into the safety of U.S. government bonds, whose yields affect some mortgage rates.

Rates had been expected to rise after the Federal Reserve ended a mortgage-buying program that pushed rates down to record lows last year. But the uncertainty in Europe has helped drive rates down for anyone who's closing a home purchase or looking to refinance. Rates on 30-year home loans are generally tied to the yield on 10-year Treasury bonds

Still, Americans with adjustable rate mortgages could see slightly higher rates. About 70 percent of such loans reset based on the London Interbank Offered Rate. That's the rate large international banks use when extending short-term loans to each other. This rate has been rising because of the turmoil in Europe. It's still well below year-ago levels.

In a healthier economy, extraordinarily low mortgage rates would pump up demand for homes. But economists say the job market is too weak and credit too tight.

"Having a good mortgage rate helps affordability, but we've had low mortgage rates for a long time now and sales have stayed below 5 million, except when the tax credit was involved," said Patrick Newport, an economist at IHS Global Insight.

The tax credit's impact is expected to linger for a couple of months. Buyers had to have a signed sales contract by April 30. But they have until the end of June to complete their sales. First-time buyers were eligible for a tax credit of up to $8,000. Current owners who bought and moved into another home could qualify for a credit of up to $6,500.

The first-time buyer's credit was a boon to Tiffani Burleson, 29, and her husband Tony. They are on track to buy a four-bedroom $202,000 home outside Portland, Ore., by the end of June.

The couple saved for nearly a year to afford the 3.5 percent down payment required by their Federal Housing Administration-backed mortgage. They even moved in with friends for several months.

Without the tax credit, she said, "We would have eventually done it, but we would have waited a lot longer."

The annual rate of home sales remains 20 percent below its peak in September 2005. But it's 27 percent above the bottom, set at the start of last year.

April's sales rose in all parts of the country except the West. The gains were led by a 21 percent jump in the Northeast and a 10 percent rise in the Midwest. Sales also rose nearly 9 percent in the South. Sales in the West dropped by 6.2 percent from March.

The big question facing the housing market is what happens now that the government's tax credits have expired.

"What really matters right now is consumer confidence and job growth and home prices not going down much from here," said Josh Levin, a homebuilding analyst at Citigroup Inc. "That really matters a lot more than rates."

Even with April's rise in sales, the market is saturated with homes and growing. It would take 8.4 months to sell all the homes on the market at last month's sales pace. By contrast, a healthy supply would take six months to sell.

The number of homes on the market is expected to grow further as banks put more foreclosed properties up for sale.

"With supply growing and demand expected to fade, it is a bad picture for prices," wrote Tim Quinlan, an economist with Wells Fargo Securities.