Show: THE RACHEL MADDOW SHOW
Date: January 26, 2015
Guest: Paul Vance, Frank McCarton
CHRIS HAYES, MSNBC HOST: All right, that is ALL IN for this evening. Two
hours from when all vehicles except for essential emergency vehicles have
to be off of the road here in New York City. With that, I hand it off to
my friend and colleague, Rachel Maddow.
Good evening, Rachel.
RACHEL MADDOW, MSNBC HOST: Good evening, Chris. Thank you, my friend.
And thank you at home for joining us this hour. This is totally normal,
right? It is 9 o`clock right now on the East Coast where seven states in
the most densely populated part of the country are in a state of emergency.
As of right now 9:00 pm Eastern, no private cars are allowed on the road in
the entire state of Connecticut. A full travel ban is in effect for all
Connecticut roads. It applies to everybody other than emergency vehicles
and first responders. It has been illegal to drive in the city of Boston
for the past hour already tonight. That travel ban will extend to all of
Massachusetts as of midnight tonight.
In Rhode Island another travel ban tonight will go into effect at midnight
and I New York City, in 13 counties, across the state of New York,
including New York City, car travel will be banned as of 11:00 pm tonight.
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo today warning that anyone caught out on the
streets of New York City or I any of the affected counties in New York can
expect a $300 fine for the crime of driving during this weapon emergency.
In Massachusetts, it`s an even bigger fine. Massachusetts` brand new
governor, Charlie Baker says tonight that the fine for anyone caught
driving after tonight`s midnight travel ban in Massachusetts will be $500
just for driving.
If you want to get around by some means other than driving, you`re out of
luck. Transit systems are shutting down tonight or plan to be shut
tomorrow across the affected areas and it`s a very large chunk of the
country affected by this storm. It`s something like 30 million Americans
in the path of this giant snowstorm.
To get a sense of just how big this storm is and how worried authorities
are about it, consider one, a remarkable decision made today in the
nation`s largest city. New York City has a long history of dealing with
snowstorms, even really, really big snowstorms. New York is a resilient
city that can take it, can take a lot and has dealt with a lot over its
In the 100-plus year history of the New York City subway system, it has
never before been shut down for a snowstorm. Tonight, the New York City
subway system will be shut down for this snowstorm, the first time that has
ever happened in the history of the nation`s largest city.
Even outside the immediately affected areas, this storm is already having
some knock-on national effects. When thousands of flights were canceled
today throughout the Northeast, that created big disruptive ripples
throughout air travel across the country. This is the misery map showing
flight cancellations of website FlightAware posted this thing online.
These are the largest airports around the country, green on this map means
that flights are on time, red means cancellations and delays.
Obviously New York City is all but entirely shut down, because it`s right
in the middle of this storm system, but places like Denver or San
Francisco, they`re not affected by the storm directly, but they have a huge
portion of their flights canceled as well, just because of connections to
the East Coast that are now not going to happen.
So the air travel effects of this are nationwide. They will take a long
time to unwind.
Even in politics, tonight in the House of Representatives, they called off
their votes that had been scheduled tonight in the House. It`s not because
D.C. itself is getting walloped, D.C. will probably only end up getting a
few inches of snow from this storm, but there are so many members of
Congress from the Northeast, from the affected region, from this storm that
scheduling votes tonight just didn`t make sense for people being able to
get in and out of Washington.
Incidentally, I should tell you the cancellation of the votes in the House
tonight is also probably going to give the Republicans a very convenient
out for their anti-immigration bill which they thought they would pass this
week but it started falling apart on their own side.
Now they have a very great excuse for delaying the vote without it being
too painfully obvious that they just couldn`t get it together for their own
Basically what is going on tonight is there is a big portion of the country
getting absolutely thumped with snow. The word tonight in all of the
states that are getting thumped with snow is that people should just stay
down. Hunker down. The word from all of the governors in all of the
affected states tonight is this is not a storm you want to pick a fight
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
GOV. ANDREW CUOMO (D), NEW YORK: Do not take this lightly. I know we have
gone through a number of storms and sometimes people tend to be a little
casual about it. This is not a time to be casual.
GOV. CHRIS CHRISTIE (R), N.J.: You never know how bad these conditions are
going to be. Here is one thing we know for sure. Starting later this
afternoon, you should stay home if you can. You should only go out in the
case of an absolute emergency or necessity.
GOV. GINA RAIMONDO (D), R.I.: I have a simple message for the people of
Rhode Island. Use today to prepare. The snow is coming, the storm is
coming. It will be the most severe storm that we have seen in years, maybe
decades and I need you to keep yourself safe and keep your loved ones safe.
We have today to prepare so hunker down.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: Joining us now is MSNBC meteorologist Bill Karins.
Bill, thank you so much for joining us. I know it has been a big day and a
big night already.
What is the latest in terms of the progress of the storm?
BILL KARINS, AMS METEOROLOGIST: Hey, Rachel, sorry, I snuck up by you, I
was supposed today be over there and I snuck up on you.
I just got done looking at a lot of information. New stuff is coming in.
Forecast has changed a little bit for a few areas, it`s not like storm is
over, but the New York City forecast does not look quite as bad as it did.
That will get a lot of headlines.
Of course, at one point, Weather Service is saying 24-35. There is still a
blizzard warning in effect from the Weather Service. We`ll wait and see if
they make some changes when they get their update out probably sometime
around 10 or 11 o`clock.
But I did take New York City down from 16 to 20 inches down to 10 or 14.
And we already did get 5 inches of snow in Central Park. So if you do the
math on that, maybe only another 7-10, 11 inches in New York City. So it
may not be the paralyzing blizzard that was once advertised.
Now the storm, it is still off of the coast, we`re starting to see the
winds pick up, the snow starting to pick up as those bands are coming back
at us from the ocean. So, you know, it is always risky as a forecaster to
make changes before you get to the peak of the storm. But a lot of our
short-term data is telling us that the heavy band of snow, the one that we
could get the thundersnow with, the claps of thunder in the middle of the
night, will stay a little further out towards Long Island, the Providence
are , up to Hartford.
Hartford I lowered a little bit down to about 12 or 18. Still a
significant storm. But as far as people losing power, being stuck in their
homes, I think it will mostly be isolated to the eastern half of Rhode
Island. Very concerned with Cape Cod`s forecast, looks a little colder and
snowier now. So now they`re into the mix.
So just because one area gets a little improvement, Philadelphia definitely
a big improvement, New York City a little bit of improvement, it`s like a
ripple effect. It`s almost a little worse now. Boston are is still
getting nailed. All up to Portland, Maine, to Portsmouth area, New
Hampshire, all of those areas still getting hit hard by the storm with 2-3
feet and there will still be a spot, I`m sure, somewhere, maybe in the
Worcester Hills that could pick up 3 feet or plus.
So it`s not like the storm is over or called off, but you know how it
works, being in New York City and if New York City was saying possible
historic, it ends up being a 12-inch snowfall, we`ll take heat from it
KARINS: It`s part of what we signed up for.
MADDOW: It means the national impact of the storm, in terms of the effect
literally on the economy, the effect on the media, all of these things that
are nationalized in New York, but you`re saying you`re worried about parts
of Long Island, potentially worried about Cape Cod.
One of the things I was looking at with Cape Cod was the storm surge and
the tides, are they worried about erosion and the height of -- ?
KARINS: Yes, this storm is not any weaker. It`s still the same strength,
still having the 60-80 MPH winds. That will drive the storm surge, the
waves. High tide will occur in the Cape and Eastern Mass throughout the
night tonight between 3:00 am and 6:00 am. That`s when we expect a 2-4
foot storm surge.
We were never saying a historic storm surge. We were not expecting waves
to be into houses or washing them away like we did with Sandy or anything
like that. But still we`ll get a lot of overwash. We will see some
houses, especially -- there is a place called Plum Island out there that is
slowly falling into the ocean regardless of what storm it is. Stuff like
that we could get some dramatic pictures out of.
But the storm surge and the high tide this morning we will get some
headlines out of it. But I still think that when we see the worst of this
storm, it will be the power outages and how long it takes to get the power
back on for the people in Eastern New England when the wind chill is in the
single digits and people are stuck in their homes maybe until Thursday and
They may not be able to leave their homes because of the snowbanks. It`s
not like they can just drive to the nearest hotel. They had to get dug out
first and then the power crews have to get in there. So that will be the
battle. If we have life threatening weather, that`s how it will happen.
MADDOW: Bill Karins, thank you for being here. It will be a long time.
KARINS: Sorry for sneaking up on you.
MADDOW: It was kind of exciting actually. There was this man in black
looming out of the dark.
KARINS: (INAUDIBLE) your security detail.
MADDOW: This is very good.
I have security?
All right. We`re going to do sort of a whip-around now in terms of some of
the affected states.
We`re going to Connecticut now to talk to Lt. Paul Vance of the Connecticut
Lieutenant Vance, thanks very much for being with us tonight.
LT. PAUL VANCE, CONNECTICUT STATE POLICE: Sure, Rachel. Pleasure to be
MADDOW: Can you give us a update on the security situation in terms of the
roads, power outages and things like that in Connecticut and what you`re
VANCE: We`re still looking at the forecast as predicted. We`re getting
heavy snowfall, the DOT is out doing what they can. DPW out doing the
We`re certainly anticipating what`s been predicted, that we`re going to
continue receiving heavy snowfall in our state.
MADDOW: Lt. Vance, I know there was a travel ban instituted and announced
by the governor relatively early in the day, telling people to be off the
roads in Connecticut by 9:00. There was no end date announced for that.
How long do you anticipate the travel ban being in effect?
And how many resources do you anticipate having to use to enforce that?
VANCE: I think it was absolutely perfect to institute that simply because
we needed to make sure the roads were clear to be able to have our highway
crews keep the roads open and keep up with the storm.
Most of our customers, the people of Connecticut and the people that would
travel into Connecticut are heeding that warning and are making it
accessible for DOT to do their work. We don`t know how long it will take
for this storm to get through. Certainly it has been forecasted and
predicted. But we`re in a wait and see mode to see exactly what occurs
with this storm.
MADDOW: Lieutenant Vance with the Connecticut State Police, thanks very
much for being with us. And stay in touch with us over the course of the
night. I know it`s going to be a long one.
VANCE: Thank you very much.
MADDOW: Thank you, sir.
Joining us now on the phone is Frank McCarton. He`s the director of
operations for the Department of Emergency Operations in New York City.
Mr. McCarton, thanks very much for being with us tonight. Appreciate your
FRANK MCCARTON, DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY OPERATIONS, NYC: Thank you, Rachel
for having me.
MADDOW: Let me ask you about the revised forecast totals that we just
heard about from MSNBC meteorologist Bill Karins. New York City has never
imposed a system-wide shut down of the subway system because of a
snowstorm, was that a mistake if this turns out to be a 10-12 inch snow
event instead of the larger event that had been predicted earlier in the
MCCARTON: No, this is a serious storm. This is blizzard. New York City
has only seen so many of these in the past 21st century. Public safety is
the number one goal. The mayor and this office of emergency management has
to protect the citizens.
What we`re saying to the citizens is stay off of the roads, allow us to
clear the roadways so we can get people back to work as soon as possible in
the next day or so and get the system back up and running.
We saw it during Sandy, protection of the system is A number one. It`s a
very complex transit system and the transit authority knows that system and
can make those decisions.
MADDOW: When do you think transit systems will be back up and running at
this point if it is a 10-12 inch snow event, which is not unprecedented in
Does that give you any guide as to when things might be back to normal in
terms of people`s commutes?
MCCARTON: No, I do not. We`re looking at a crystal ball here. We have
not seen the worst of this storm. We`re being told by our National Weather
Service, the meteorologists, that the intensity of the storm will increase.
The first time you`re telling me that it`s going to decrease, I have not
seen those, that data.
But, you know, we can clean up here pretty quick. Our sanitation
department with the MTA officials can clean those tracks and get people
back and running. So once the snow stops and we can get, that`s why it is
important for people to stay off of the roads right now.
If they stay off of the roads and get home, we can prepare for the worst.
If it`s the best tomorrow when you and I wake up in the big city here that
we live in, then we`re doing much better than we were last night.
MADDOW: Yes. Overprepare instead of underprepare.
MCCARTON: Yes, because otherwise we got to be ready. And that`s what we
do in this business, emergency management. That`s what it`s all about.
MADDOW: Frank McCarton, deputy commissioner, New York City Emergency
Management, thank you for being with us tonight, I know it will be a long
night, sir, thank you.
MCCARTON: Yes, it will be. Thanks, Rachel.
MADDOW: All right. Appreciate it.
We have more ahead as we track this storm up and down the East Coast.
We`ll have live reports from several locations. Weather legend Al Roker
will join us a bit later.
And of course, because it`s us, there`s always the potential for political
follow up from a big storm like this and how it is handled by those in
charge. Stay with us. It`s a big, cold night ahead.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
QUESTION: Mr. Mayor, I just wanted to seek clarity on the 11:00 pm rule.
That applies to any sort of taxicab or car service and there are a few
folks on social media wondering about food delivery bicycles, whether they
might be allowed out?
MAYOR: A food delivery bicycle is not an emergency vehicle, so, no.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: I just ran in from outside. I can`t feel my hands. So If I do
something unusual with them, I can`t be held accountable.
All right, so -- it is cold out there. New York City is the largest city
in the country. Los Angeles is the second largest city in the country.
Chicago is the third largest city in the country.
In the history of our country there has only been one woman who was mayor
of one of those cities. In 1979, that`s when she was elected, her name was
Jane Byrne. She was elected mayor of Chicago. She got that job, she
became the only female mayor ever of one of the country`s three largest
cities largely because of a snowstorm.
The incumbent mayor, a guy named Michael Bilandic, had the misfortune of
being mayor of Chicago in the winter of 1978-1979, terrible winger. And
there was a particularly huge snowstorm in January 1979. And Mayor
Bilandic just could not get it done for that storm. The roads didn`t get
plowed; train system got snowed in.
He tried to put a brave face on it and tried to say everything was in hand,
everything was fine, but it really very obviously wasn`t. And Chicago
threw him out on his ear. Two months after that storm, they threw him out.
In the Democratic primary for mayor which is really all that mattered in
Chicago at the time, Jane Byrne defeated the incumbent mayor just a few
weeks after he botched that snowstorm. That`s the one time that one of the
three largest cities in America every elected a woman to be mayor.
Snowstorms themselves do not have politics. But snowstorms often can have
a big political impact.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED MALE (voice-over): The state of emergency continues in
Boston. People are not permitted to drive their cars and almost everything
is closed. The governor says it is worse than the hurricane of `38.
MICHAEL DUKAKIS, FORMER GOVERNOR OF MASSACHUSETTS: Well, `38 hurricane
obviously was obviously a mess, but what we`ve had here is a hurricane plus
a blizzard. And I`m not sure we`ve ever had anything quite like that.
MADDOW (voice-over): The year before Jane Byrne became mayor of Chicago,
it was the blizzard of 1978 in Massachusetts. And that was a defining
moment for Governor Michael Dukakis and his public image.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: Look at that sweater.
The state of Massachusetts was totally inundated with snow in the blizzard
of `78, basically shut down the whole state for three days. But Governor
Dukakis was ubiquitous on local TV and local radio, keeping people apprised
of what was happening and how the state was handling the disaster.
Before Dukakis and the blizzard of `78, it was New York City and the giant
snowstorm of 1969.
Mayor John Lindsay of New York City,, 15 inches of snow fell on New York
City that year but the city was not prepared at all even though that is not
a overwhelming amount. Fifteen inches the city should have been able to
But they were not ready. Part of it was a bad weather forecast. The
weather forecast that year predicted that storm would start as snow and
turn to rain. It didn`t turn to rain, it stayed all snow and the city
could not really handle it. They plowed some neighborhoods, they did not
plow all neighborhoods and Mayor John Lindsay never lived it down.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED MALE (voice-over): Those neighborhoods are now plowed for at
least three days. And they are angry. When Lindsay goes out there, to
walk the streets, he goes out and he walks the streets of Queens and he is
UNIDENTIFIED MALE (voice-over): By that time, they were throwing
snowballs, which is a great symbol of the (INAUDIBLE) John Lindsay, get out
of our neighborhoods. This is what you`ve done to us. And he is now in
four feet of snow.
UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE (voice-over): John Lindsay didn`t cause the snowstorm,
but he sent a message (INAUDIBLE) that they didn`t matter as much. They
UNIDENTIFIED MALE (voice-over): We move as fast as we can. It`s a very
heavy snowfall and a very wet one and it needs bulldozers. The ordinary
plowing equipment is only partially effective.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE (voice-over): After Mayor Lindsay made his tour of
Queens yesterday, there were a lot of words being said about having more
crews and more equipment out in this area to clean up these streets and
have them open for traffic, but it will take more than conversation to
convince the residents here at 241st Street that something is actually
MADDOW (voice-over): It tells you something about the management of storms
like this. The blizzard of `78 that Michael Dukakis dealt with in
Massachusetts, that one even now gets called the blizzard of `78.
But that snowstorm that crippled New York City nearly a decade before that,
that snowstorm that crippled not just New York City in general but
specifically Queens, that snowstorm doesn`t get called the blizzard of
1969, that is called the Lindsay snowstorm, like it`s his fault, like he
In 1982 it was Denver that was totally overwhelmed by a storm that hit on
Christmas Eve. The mayor of Denver had been in office for 14 years when
that storm hit. But when the city could not handle that storm at
Christmas time, Denver threw him out and elected Federico Pena just a few
In 1987, it was D.C. D.C. Mayor Marion Barry was in L.A., he was staying
at the Beverly Hills Hilton and getting ready to go to the Super Bowl in
Southern California that year while back home his city got thumped by a
In 2010, New York City got hit with a Christmas Day that left roads
unplowed for days. Hundreds of people were stuck in a dark cold subway
train that was marooned on the tracks for seven hours. There was a backlog
of over 1,000 9-1-1 calls.
And for that storm, Mayor Mike Bloomberg was in Bermuda. His staffers
didn`t want to say it publicly that he was in Bermuda, but he was in
Here is the thing though, Mike Bloomberg is not remembered in terms of his
mayoral tenure for being AWOL in Bermuda during that Christmas snowstorm.
That Denver mayor and that Chicago mayor, they both got turfed out after
mishandling big storms. But Michael Dukakis also got turfed out after the
blizzard of `78 and he actually did pretty well with that one.
Marion Barry paid no price for blowing it during the Super Bowl snowstorm
that he sat out at the Beverly Hills Hilton.
Even old John Lindsay got pelted by snowballs and they named the snowstorm
after his incompetence in 1969. But then later that same year John Lindsay
got reelected. It`s a mixed bag.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
Tonight, New York City and Boston may get some of the largest snowfalls
they have experienced as cities. The range of cities getting walloped runs
from Philly to Maine, hitting every major Northeast and New England city on
What does it take to be good at governing through something like this?
And who`s done it right?
Joining us now is the great Steve Kornacki, the host of "UP WITH STEVE
Steve, thanks very much for joining us.
STEVE KORNACKI, MSNBC HOST: Sure, happy to do it.
MADDOW: I mostly wanted you here because I wanted you to see the Michael
KORNACKI: That was wonderful. I get the sweater every time.
MADDOW: He is a Von Trapp.
MADDOW: Is there either a gold standard or the opposite of a gold standard
in terms of municipal governance and leadership for big storms like this?
KORNACKI: Yes, I think there is two components of it generally. The ones
who were seen as doing it successfully. One is that things have to run
smoothly. To a certain expect that is not in your control.
For instance, you saw the John Lindsay thing from 1969. Part of the story
in 1969 is that Lindsay had really poor relations with a lot of city
employees, certainly with cops, maybe with sanitation workers, too. There
was a lot of speculation that around `69 the sanitation workers basically
said we`re going to screw Lindsay over with this one, maybe we`re going to
miss streets and miss a few neighborhoods, maybe we`re going to take our
time on this one.
And that sort of compounded his political problems. So first of all, you
can`t have neighborhoods not getting plowed. That`s the basic part of it.
The other thing is communication, it`s public communication. It`s being
very visible. It`s giving the appearance of being in control. I have
ordered this, I have authorized this, I have asked for this, you know,
sorts of requests like that, being on television, Michael Dukakis in that
`78 storm in Massachusetts, local radio, local television. He was on it
And of course in `78 there was no cable TV. There`s no Internet. So
everybody in Eastern Massachusetts is sitting there. They can`t go out on
the roads. They have their radio tuned in to WBZ or whatever and they`re
hearing Michael Dukakis and he is this calming presence through the whole
MADDOW: Is the political communication skills end up being not just
helpful to your legacy, but also literally helpful to people. I think one
of the things that happened in the last five years or so when there is a
public emergency or event, where people are really tuning in to hear from
leaders, we get a long list of thank yous where they thank all of the
agencies and I`m sure it matters for the smooth functioning of government.
It doesn`t much matter to individual people wanting to know what they
should do and how they should cope for their family.
KORNACKI: Right. And that could be that you take that Lindsay example so
if you`re de Blasio and you`re thanking all of these heads of municipal
divisions or whatever, you`re giving them public acknowledgment and you`re
making maybe they`re on your team in a situation like that.
But when we talk about legacy, it`s interesting because Marion Barry passed
away just a few months ago. Obviously his obituary, he had a very
interesting life. There was a lot in his obituary but I do remember
reading in the obituary, the snowstorm made it in there. Being in L.A.,
being at the Super Bowl, when the city was buried in snow. So these
politicians think about their legacies a lot. And it does end up coming
into play for something like that.
MADDOW: When you look at these things over time and I know we`re looking
at them mostly in terms of the lens of the politicians, do you feel like we
get better at these things over time?
Do politicians and municipalities and states and cities learn from previous
KORNACKI: They definitely learn from the media standpoint. That has
definitely improve. And there`s -- it`s a pageant, it`s a well
KORNACKI: Like Chris Christie a couple years ago during one of the storms,
he started putting the fleece on. So governors have learned they want to
look like they`re about to go brave the elements. I think Christie created
a few pages in the playbook.
In terms of actually handling how you run the city during the storm, a lot
of times I often wonder is this a machine that runs itself in many ways?
And the mayor and governor are out there, whoever, and they`re the public
face on it, but how essential is the actual mayor, is the actual governor?
Sometimes you wonder about that.
MADDOW: Right, yes. Is there a coordinating role to be had or a
KORNACKI: Certainly in terms of communicating messages with the public it
MADDOW: Steve Kornacki, the show, "UP WITH STEVE KORNACKI" airs weekends
8:00 am Eastern.
Steve, if you have any trouble getting home tonight, I have a couch and a
liquor cabinet in my office. And you`re welcome.
KORNACKI: Forget it. I`m not going home.
MADDOW: All right.
We have lots more ahead on this big nor`easter tonight. We have a update
from the great Al Roker coming up, stay with us.
MADDOW: About 9:30 right now on the East Coast. This is the latest
projected path of the blizzard, making its way up the Northeast Coast
tonight. And if you`ve been following maps like that all day, you can
thank our National Weather Service for collecting and processing the data
that gives us this kind of information.
They take all that data. They run different models to project how the
storm is going to behave over time.
And our National Weather Service is something to be proud of. We do world-
class weapon forecasting in this country.
But sometimes Europe does it better.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
AL ROKER, NBC METEOROLOGIST (voice-over): Hurricane Sandy, a week before
the storm made landfall. The American model was predicting it would
continue heading out into the Atlantic. But it was the Europeans that
first foresaw the devastating left hook.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: We do have very good forecasting in this country, but Hurricane
Sandy, as Al Roker was just explaining there, Hurricane Sandy was one
important example of the European forecast just being better than the
Part of that is just because of brute computing strength. Earlier this
month with funding that was appropriated because of superstorm Sandy, our
National Weather Service upgraded their super computers to put them more on
par with Europe in terms of the ability to collect and process weather
Because that just happened, that big computing upgrade just happened,
tonight`s storm on the East Coast is going to be an important test case for
how well our newly upgraded system performs both in absolute terms and also
in comparison with the other models that are out there. The other models
that have, sometimes, done a better job of predicting the track of storms
in this country.
Basically all of the major forecasting models in the past couple days said
the same basic bottom line thing. They all say a big snowstorm headed
along the East Coast.
Where the models have differed is in how much snow certain parts of the
East Coast would get. For example, look at this. On Saturday, this was
the European model projection on the left-hand side there of where this
storm would be by tomorrow. It is a Saturday projection of where the storm
would be by Tuesday. The European model on the left and one of the
American models, the North American mesoscale (ph), the NAM on the right.
And if you look at this important difference, see where the bull`s eye is?
The center of the storm? It`s in a geographically different spot in each
of those models. The American model on the left puts the bull`s eye much
closer to New York, which meant more snow for New York. The American model
on the right had the bull`s eye further out toward the Atlantic Ocean and
that presumably would mean more snow on the ocean. But it would mean less
snow on people, and specifically less snow on the nation`s largest city of
So those were the competing projections, European on the left, American on
right on Saturday. Since then the American model shifted the bull`s eye
closer to where the European model put it. Same with the other big
American model, the global forecast system model, but it still shows the
storm going further out to sea and with less snowfall on land overall.
Earlier today, our National Weather Service called the global forecast
system model an outlier. They said the European model looked closer to
reality so they upped their expected snowfall totals for New York.
Again, bottom line, bottom line, forecast, no matter who you ask, is tons
of snow on a big swath of the East Coast. How much and when and for how
long, that depends on how good we are as a country at crunching the huge
amount of data, that go into coming up with these mapped forecasts, making
sure they`re not just awe inspiring and a little scary but they`re also
Joining us now is NBC`s Al Roker to help explain the forecast. Al will be
forecasting live throughout the night on NBC.com.
Mr. Roker, thank you so much for joining us.
ROKER: It`s great having you, being here, Rachel, thanks so much.
MADDOW: What is the latest you`re seeing in the course of the storm and
ROKER: Again, we`re watching it, we have 29 million people under a
blizzard warning right now. And we`re watching this system make its way
along the coast. Right now in Manhattan, a little less snow, but that
could pick up again tonight. But we really are watching from Montauk,
Nantucket, Boston, that`s where we see the activity getting itself
together, the heavy snow.
A blizzard, sustained winds, frequent gusts, 35 mph or more. Blowing snow,
dropping visibilities to less than a quarter mile. We could be talking in
Boston upwards of 24 inches of snow, especially as you get out toward
Nantucket it could be closer to 3 feet. There`s going to be a lot of wind,
a lot of blowing snow, power outages are going to be a problem. So this is
pretty much living up to what we thought.
On Long Island, getting hammered right now. Visibilities at near zero.
Wind gusts upward of 50-55 mph. So it is a big deal.
MADDOW: Have there been important differences over the past couple days
and into today in terms of the different models and types of forecasting?
We heard a lot about the contrast between the U.S. and European models in
the past, is that important for this storm?
ROKER: Here is the interesting thing. As you mentioned, the National
Weather Service has upgraded, they changed some of their software and put
some money into numbers-crunching super computers and what was interesting
is the American model picked up on the intensity of this system before the
European model did.
So we`re seeing more parity coming up and there are a number of, there is a
suite of models, for example, the NAM you were talking about, a lot of
times for the winter, that doesn`t handle it quite so well and we tend to
discount that model.
We look more at the GFS, the RPM. We`re looking at a whole suite of
models. And you watch, you look and you try to finesse that suite of
models. And over time you see which one does a better job. European does
a great job. But I do think that there wasn`t as significant of a
difference between the main grouping of American models on the European
model this time.
MADDOW: One question that may just be my fault and not the fault of how
this has been described, but it felt to me that for a storm of this
magnitude, I should have heard about it later than I might have expected.
In past big winter storms, especially affecting a large portion of the
U.S., I felt like we had more warning.
Did this one not get much media attention, or was it not forecast until
later than you might expect?
ROKER: That is part of it. For example, Friday night we were not thinking
this would be that big of a deal. It was coming out as a clipper. It was
going to pop out along the mid-Atlantic coast, make its way up, be a fairly
But as we got into Friday night and especially Saturday night, overnight
Saturday night into Sunday morning, and the models came more into focus, we
realized this is going to be a problem. This is going to be bigger than we
MADDOW: NBC`s Al Roker, Al, thank you so much for being with us tonight, I
really appreciate it.
I should tell you you can follow Al as he broadcasts throughout the night
tonight on NBC.com. And if you want Al to answer your questions you can
tweet them to him and he will answer them. Tweet your blizzard questions
to him using the #Rokerthon.
He will be there all night, I swear. Lots still to come storm wise and
otherwise. Stay with us.
MADDOW: One thing to keep in mind for this big storm, the U.S. Commerce
Department ranks U.S. metropolitan areas by GDP, by how much they
contribute to the economy.
Of the top 10 metropolitan areas in terms of GDP, four of the 10 are in the
direct path of tonight`s snowstorm. If you shut those four metro areas
down for a couple days or longer, the country will feel that as an economic
We`re hitting our stride now in terms of recovery from the Great Recession
as a country. 2014 overall was great for the resurgence in jobs, consumer
confidence and economic growth. But it was not great uniformly. We had a
contraction in the economy in the first three months of 2014. And that was
because of the polar vortex.
The group Macroeconomic Advisors estimates that the brutal cold of last
year`s polar vortex winter reduced the growth of the national GDP by almost
a point and a half in the first three months of last year, just because of
the cold and because of those storms.
Now in terms of what is happening tonight, this is one storm. Measuring
the economic impact of one storm is not an exact science or an easy one.
Property damage, insurance claims, lost work hours, cities hemorrhaging
money for snow removal. The federal government`s sending money to help
state and localities with all these states declaring states of emergency.
It is a complicated thing to figure out the economic ins and outs here.
But there is little doubt that shutting an entire region of the country for
a day or two, especially the region that includes things like Wall Street
will have a broad impact. We just don`t know what that impact is yet and
we won`t know until we`re through this storm. And right now we`re still
very much in the middle of this storm. In fact, we`re getting pretty close
to what we expect might be the height of this storm.
Joining us now from outside Boston in Framingham, Massachusetts, is NBC
News correspondent Rehema Ellis.
Rehema, I know you`re driving in Framingham right now, what can you safely
tell us while keeping your eyes on the road?
REHEMA ELLIS, NBC NEWS CORRESPONDENT: I can tell you that traffic is a lot
lighter. Every hour that we`re out here, the traffic diminishes
considerably. People are wise enough to get off the streets. We`re seeing
more of the snowplows and the sands and salt machines that are out trying
to clear these, on Massachusetts State highways we have 7,300 miles of
state road and something like 4,000 state plows that will be out on these
roads trying to take care of them.
It is a daunting task that lies ahead of them. We were stopped a few
moments ago and the snow was not coming vertical, but it was coming
horizontal at us. The winds have picked up and they say it is something we
should look out for as the night progresses, that the wind and the snow
gets heavier and heavier.
That`s going to make driving out here really treacherous. It`s piling up
on the roads now. We`re going a lot slower than some other drivers who are
a lot more courageous than I. But hopefully we`ll all get to our
Back to you.
MADDOW: NBC News correspondent Rehema Ellis, Rehema, thank you very much.
Do be safe out there.
Again, we have states of emergency in seven states. We have driving bans
tonight in effect already in Connecticut, in Boston, driving bans due to go
into effect at midnight in the rest of Massachusetts and Rhode Island. An
11:00 pm driving ban due for New York City and for 13 counties in New York.
We`ve had requests for people to stay off the roads in other places,
including parts of New Hampshire and New Jersey.
So it is a big area of the country being affected by this. Tonight and
into the dawn hours we`re told the weather will get heavier. So if you`re
not out now, don`t go out now. In the morning make an educated and
commonsensical decision about how much you need to be on the road.
In very good local good news, I can now feel my hands. I`ll figure out
something to do with them right after this. Stay with us.
MADDOW: In non-snowstorm news today, in terms of the former Virginia
governor, Bob McDonald, is not going to prison, at least not yet. After
his conviction on a dozen felony corruption charges earlier this year, the
former governor had been told to report to federal prison to start his two-
year sentence as of February 9th. He was due to start his first day in
prison two weeks from today.
But today a federal appeals court reversed that decision and told Governor
McDonald that he can remain free while his appeal goes forward. Oral
arguments will be starting on his appeal mid-May. He will be free at least
We`ll be right back.
MADDOW: Busy night around here. We`re keeping an eye on this historic
storm tonight. We`re going to have much more on that in just a moment.
But there is some other news to get to tonight including some unexpected
and dramatic news out of Iowa, a story that is still developing tonight
that you should know about.
All the political attention in the country this weekend was focused on
Iowa. Iowa conservatives held what was basically a big showcase for most
of the potential Republican presidential candidates for 2016.
Whatever you think of the potential Republican field this year, you should
know that Republican insiders are very, very excited about this crop of
candidates, who all gave speeches this weekend in Iowa.
In the wake of that big event, though, something worrying has happened
involving the Republican governor of the great state of Iowa. His name is
Terry Branstad. Terry Branstad later this year is due to become the single
longest serving governor in U.S. history. He was just reelected to his
sixth term as Iowa`s governor. This is his second stint being governor.
He served the first time in the `80s and `90s.
Earlier today Governor Branstad was speaking at a ribbon cutting event in
Johnston, Iowa. And people who were there say that the governor started to
stumble over his words during his speech. He reportedly then got a little
wobbly and began to lose his balance at the podium. Organizers at the
event then laid the governor down on the ground. They called for an
Governor Terry Branstad was then taken out on a stretcher and brought by
ambulance to a local hospital in Des Moines, which is where he remains
tonight. The governor`s office says that he is alert and conscious
tonight, but that he will be kept in the hospital overnight for
Early today, Governor Branstad appeared at a press conference where he and
his lieutenant governor both said that they had not been feeling well
recently. It was during an appearance after that event today when the
governor started to struggle with his speech and his balance and then had
to get into an ambulance. Obviously we wish the best for the governor and
his family as he has this overnight hospital stay tonight in Des Moines.
We`ll keep you posted as we learn more. And we`ll be right back here in
just a moment with the latest on that winter storm that continues to churn
up the East Coast.
MADDOW: Watch this tape. We just got this in. This is from WNBC, which
is the local NBC station in New York.
This is a reporter named Stacy Bell here. And she`s doing a live report.
This is not at all staged. Watch how cool and calm she is as this happens
during her live report. She`s doing a live stand-up on the side of the
road in Long Island tonight and watch what happens.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
STACY BELL, WNBC: As the snow continues to fall overnight only time will
tell. Reporting live from Nassau County, in the storm as the snow
continues to fall overnight --
MADDOW (voice-over): Stacy Bell, WNBC, the NBC station -- look at that --
the NBC station in New York City tonight. She`s completely calm, cool and
collected as that happens during her stand up while she`s doing a live
report from Long Island, just incredible.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: We are now approaching 10 o`clock on the East Coast at this hour.
Mayors and governors from D.C. to Massachusetts have urged their citizens
to basically shut it down, get home and stay home and maybe think about
staying home tomorrow, too. Seven governors have declared a state of
emergency. As of tonight in some places authorities are urging people not
to travel unless they absolutely must.
There are travel bans in place already or due to go into effect shortly in
New York City; 13 other New York counties and Massachusetts and Rhode
Island and Connecticut. In those places with the travel ban, it`s not just
a request that people not go out, it is a necessity. Only emergency
responders are being allowed out on the roads.
Major cities saw a huge rush today as people jammed onto subways and
commuter trains ahead of them shutting down, trying to get home. New York
City is going to finish closing its entire subway system just an hour from
now. This is the first time they`ve ever closed the entire subway system
because of a snowstorm.
Amtrak has reduced service throughout the region, the most heavily traveled
train corridor in the country. Amtrak says service will be suspended
throughout New England tomorrow.
Airlines canceled 2,800 flights today. They`ve canceled another 3,900 and
counting flights tomorrow. Those are obviously flights that are being
canceled and airports that are being shut in the most directly affected
area in the Northeast. But that has a knock-on effect for air travel
across the country. You are seeing cancellations across the country well
beyond the areas that are being affected by the storm just because flights
can`t make the connections.
With driving bans, with mass transit going dark, with flights canceled,
thousands canceled all over the country, right now, if you are within the
sound of my voice and you are not already where you intend to be and where
you intend to be is somewhere on the East Coast tonight, we are now
approaching the moment when you might find it very difficult to get
anywhere you are not already.
It`s going to be a long night. The forecast has been changing over the
course of the night. We are told to expect very heavy snowfall in all the
affected areas between now and dawn. The overnight hours are going to be
crucial in terms of the overall magnitude of this storm. It`s still
expected to be of potentially historic proportions, particularly in New
But that does it for us, at least for now. Stay with MSNBC for live
coverage of the storm throughout the night. Now it`s time for "THE LAST
THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY
Copyright 2015 CQ-Roll Call, Inc. All materials herein are protected by
United States copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed,
transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the prior written
permission of CQ-Roll Call. You may not alter or remove any trademark,
copyright or other notice from copies of the content.>
Show: THE RACHEL MADDOW SHOW