IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

‘Enemy combatant’ Hamdi to be released

The United States has agreed to release U.S. citizen Yasar Esam Hamdi after two years of detention as an "enemy combatant" and allow him to move to Saudi Arabia, where he was raised.
U.S. citizen Yaser Esam Hamdi is shown with arms tied following his capture in Afghanistan in this file photo from December 2001.Terry Richards / AP file
/ Source: Reuters

The United States has agreed to release American-born, Saudi-raised Yaser Esam Hamdi after holding him as an “enemy combatant” without charges for more than two years, the Justice Department said Wednesday.

His case prompted a Supreme Court ruling in June on the limits of presidential power in wartime.

Hamdi, who was detained at a U.S. naval jail in Charleston, S.C., will be sent to Saudi Arabia under an agreement in which he renounces any claim to American citizenship, which he held because he was born in Louisiana in 1980.

Hamdi, 23, has been in U.S. military custody since he was captured on the battlefield in Afghanistan in November 2001 and accused of fighting for the Taliban. Officials said he would be released within days.

The Justice Department said the U.S. government, Hamdi and his lawyer had signed an agreement for the release.

Limits on travel
This includes a pledge by Hamdi never to return to the United States and his acceptance that he will be restricted from traveling to Afghanistan, Iraq, Israel, Pakistan, Syria, the West Bank and Gaza. Hamdi is also obliged to notify Saudi officials if he ever plans to leave that country, according to people involved in the case.

“As we have repeatedly stated, the United States has no interest in detaining enemy combatants beyond the point that they pose a threat to the U.S. and our allies,” Justice Department spokesman Mark Corallo said in a statement.

Corallo said the government had decided to release Hamdi “subject to strict conditions that ensure the interests of the United States and our national security.”

Hamdi’s lawyer, Frank Dunham, said his client had accepted a deal for release with strings attached rather than fighting in court despite his strong legal case because victory “wasn’t guaranteed.”

Too great a risk
“But a loss could have him locked up for many, many, many more years. So we chose guaranteed, immediate release with restrictions over the vagaries of continued litigation,” Dunham said.

“He’s been in solitary confinement and couldn’t stand it any more. Anything that would get him home in the short term to his family would be preferable to almost any other alternative.”

Hamdi was born to Saudi parents on Sept. 26, 1980, in Baton Rouge, La., while his father worked in the oil business.  His family moved back to Saudi Arabia when he was a toddler.

In January 2002 Hamdi was taken to the U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, where hundreds of al-Qaida and Taliban suspects are imprisoned. He was moved in April that year to a naval prison in Norfolk, Va., when U.S. officials discovered he had been born in Louisiana. Hamdi later was moved to the Charleston jail, but no charges were ever brought.

The United States designated him an “enemy combatant” — a status conferring few rights that has also been assigned to hundreds of non-Americans imprisoned at Guantanamo.

Another U.S. citizen deemed an enemy combatant, former Chicago gang member and al-Qaida “dirty bomb” suspect Jose Padilla, remains in the Charleston jail.

Dunham sued in May 2002, challenging the legality of Hamdi’s detention and arguing that the government had violated his constitutional right to due process by holding him indefinitely while denying him access to a lawyer or trial.

The Bush administration argued the president had the right during wartime to declare those who fight against the United States “enemy combatants” and restrict their access to the court system.

On June 28 the Supreme Court ruled that U.S. citizens held in America as enemy combatants have the right to lawyers and to challenge that designation and their indefinite detention.