Basketball legend Earvin “Magic” Johnson endorsed Antonio Villaraigosa for mayor Monday, giving the challenger one of the race’s prized endorsements and another A-list supporter in the politically crucial black community.
Speaking at one of his health clubs in the San Fernando Valley, Johnson’s announcement became as much a denunciation of Mayor James Hahn’s leadership as an embrace of Villaraigosa’s candidacy. The former Los Angeles Lakers star said the administration had been crippled by an ongoing corruption investigation.
“You can’t point to the Hahn administration and find 10 things he has accomplished because he was so bogged down by the scandal situation,” Johnson said. “The city was not moving forward.”
One of Southern California’s most popular figures and now a successful businessman, Johnson endorsed Hahn over Villaraigosa in their runoff four years ago, part of a surge of black support that helped secure Hahn’s victory in 2001.
The May 17 mayoral election is a rematch of that race, in which Hahn defeated Villaraigosa 53 percent to 46 percent.
Johnson was outraged, like many blacks, when Hahn helped push out the city’s black police chief, Bernard Parks, in 2002. There were other problems, too — most important, Hahn’s failure to do more to create jobs, Johnson said.
“I expected him to be like his dad, and that didn’t happen,” Johnson said, referring to late county Supervisor Kenneth Hahn, a revered figure in the Los Angeles black community.
Hahn’s campaign dismissed the value of the endorsement.
“Villaraigosa got lots of endorsements in the last race. Did they matter? If they mattered then, he would have been elected mayor in 2001,” consultant Kam Kuwata said.
Earlier in the day, Hahn proposed a series of reforms for troubled Martin Luther King Jr./Drew Medical Center, which serves largely black South Los Angeles.
Villaraigosa’s compelling story
Villaraigosa's story would be compelling in any language. The son of a Mexican immigrant, raised by a single mother, Villaraigosa dropped out of high school yet rose to become speaker of the California Assembly, an adviser to John Kerry's presidential campaign and, now, the front-running candidate for mayor of Los Angeles.
A Villaraigosa victory would mark another milestone for Hispanics, whose political influence has been expanding from California to the White House. But to unseat Hahn, a fellow Democrat, Villaraigosa must capture a significant number of black votes in the nation's second-largest city.
With the May 17 election less than six weeks away, the race is challenging assumptions that blacks are reluctant to support Hispanic candidates because of lingering tensions over who gets the spoils of political power.
Blacks were a key factor in Hahn's 2001 runoff victory over Villaraigosa, with eight in 10 black votes going to Hahn. But if Hahn, who is white, inherited the black vote from his father — a long-serving county supervisor lionized in black South Los Angeles — the days of political hand-me-downs appear to be over. This time around, a string of marquee black endorsements for Villaraigosa coupled with the mayor's lukewarm black support in the March 8 primary suggest a new playing field.
"It's the politics of subtraction. (Villaraigosa) has to subtract a large element from the mayor's base — African-Americans," said John Pitney, a political scientist at nearby Claremont McKenna College. "That will be a giant step toward winning."
It's not just blacks. The liberal Villaraigosa, a former labor activist and one-time head of the local American Civil Liberties Union, must court other political communities that have looked at him with distrust, including moderates and Republicans.
But unlike 2001, Villaraigosa, 52, has lined up earlier prominent black endorsements from Rep. Maxine Waters, a Democratic icon who, like Johnson, supported Hahn four years ago, and Parks, whose ouster as police chief in 2002 damaged Hahn's standing in the black community.
Issue not skin color
For black voters, the issue is not skin color or family legacy but "what are you doing for the community?" said Franklin D. Gilliam Jr., a political scientist at the University of California, Los Angeles, who studies racial politics.
"In the primary, roughly half of black voters voted for a non-black (Villaraigosa), even with a black in the race," Gilliam said, referring to Parks, who finished fourth and didn't qualify for the May 17 runoff. "It's a bit of a dramatization to say blacks just won't vote for Latino candidates."
Regina Robertson, 37, a black school worker who voted for Hahn four years ago, said she is leaning toward Villaraigosa because of frustration over dead-end schools and gang violence.
"We are losing our kids. They are crying out for help," Robertson said.
Despite Los Angeles' large and growing Hispanic population — 46.5 percent, according to the 2000 census — the city hasn't had a Hispanic mayor since 1872.
The mayoralty "is part of the jewels of the crown as far as political integration into California," said Harry Pachon, director of the Tomas Rivera Policy Institute at the University of Southern California.
Pachon, noting that Hispanic and black political leaders have worked together for years in California, said black-Hispanic friction tends to play out at the "street level" over jobs and in prisons.
In Los Angeles, Hispanics have gradually filled many hotel jobs that once went to blacks. In addition, Hispanics have been moving into historically black areas of South Los Angeles.
In interviews, black voters acknowledged some friction — but said that's changing.
"We can't run L.A. without the Hispanics," said 63-year-old real estate salesman Alex Greene. "I don't have the fear of the Hispanic takeover."
Still, in a diverse city, Villaraigosa's ethnicity demands a political balancing act. He does not want to turn his back on his Hispanic roots nor be defined by them — a candidate who happens to be Hispanic, not the Hispanic candidate. On the campaign trail, he moves easily between English and Spanish.
Some analysts say Villaraigosa's ethnicity became a fatal flaw in 2001, when Hahn's campaign pummeled him for seeking the pardon of a convicted drug trafficker, a move that linked drugs and race.
While the city's Hispanic population has been growing, the black population has dipped to about 11 percent. Still, blacks made up 16 percent of the turnout in the March primary, with Hispanics at 22 percent, according to a Los Angeles Times exit poll.
Hahn, 54, has been highlighting the city's lower crime rate and job growth while depicting Villaraigosa as a vacillating leader. Other election factors could include the Hispanic turnout and an ongoing corruption probe at City Hall.
And, of course, blacks dissatisfied with Hahn could simply stay home on election day.
"There's enough residual stuff there that it's not a slam dunk (for Villaraigosa)," Gilliam said.