The Buffalo Bills on Saturday released punter Matt Araiza, one of the NFL’s rising stars, days after he was accused in a civil lawsuit of raping a teenager at a college party.
General manager Brandon Beane and head coach Sean McDermott announced the move. Beane said that Araiza needed to focus on the accusations and that the alleged behavior would make the player "a no-go for us" if it is true.
The suit, filed Thursday in San Diego County Superior Court, detailed the accuser's narrative of meeting Araiza at an off-campus Halloween party on Oct. 17, when he played for San Diego State University.
Araiza denies the accusations of rape and other parts of the lawsuit.
“The facts of the incident are not what they are portrayed in the lawsuit or in the press,” he said in a statement shared Friday evening on Twitter by the NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport. "I look forward to quickly setting the record straight."
The lawsuit alleges that Araiza, who was 21 at the time, gave a 17-year-old girl an alcoholic beverage, asked for oral sex and had sex with her in a side yard before he took her to a bedroom, where he and two other men are alleged to have gang-raped her.
She reported it to authorities the next day and underwent a rape examination, the suit says. The school said San Diego police asked it to pause initiating its own Title IX investigation to give detectives necessary leeway.
Early this month, San Diego police sent the results of their investigation, without making any arrests, to the local district attorney's office, which said the matter was still under review.
San Diego State said it wasn't until July 22 that police said it was free to pursue its own investigation.
The Bills, who fielded backup quarterback Matt Barkley in place of Araiza in Friday night's preseason game against the Carolina Panthers, said the suit was a surprise.
Araiza was drafted in the sixth round and went to Buffalo as college football's best punter last year.
Araiza's lawyer, Kerry L. Armstrong, said by email Saturday night that Araiza is "very disappointed but is not upset with the Bills."
"He is staying positive and knows he will eventually return to the NFL," Armstrong said.
The team said in a statement Friday that it was recently made aware of a civil complaint involving Araiza.
Beane reiterated that at a news conference Saturday in which he announced that Araiza was being released. He also said the team became aware of the accusations in late July.
"We tried to be thorough and thoughtful and not rush to judgment," Beane said, adding that the information the team had was limited.
He said that a culture of following the law and good behavior is core to the Bills and that if the team had known about the accusations it would not have drafted Araiza.
"We did not know about this, and the league did not know about this," Beane said.
"This is bigger than football," he said.
Dan Gilleon, an attorney for Jane Doe in the lawsuit, told The Buffalo News that the team made the right decision to release Araiza but that it did so too late.
“The Buffalo Bills had no choice but to cut their young punter after so badly botching their response to our claim: they ignored us, as though what I warned them would happen could be avoided if they just kept their heads in the sand. This is what enablers do,” he said in a statement.
He said his client’s life was “forever scarred in October 2021.”
"She handled herself with grace and dignity," he said. "Her only ask was the kind of justice that might save other young women from the hell she experienced."
Gilleon claimed that Araiza’s attorney offered Jane Doe money to settle the case, which she and her legal counsel rejected. Yet, Araiza’s lawyer allegedly referred to Gilleon's client as “an opportunistic grifter” to the media, Gilleon said.
"If Matt Araiza had shown 1% of the grace that my client has, perhaps by offering an apology and donation his money to a charity serving rape survivors, he would still be a Buffalo Bill and his parents could sit in the stands and watch their son with pride," Gilleon said. "Instead, he decided to hire an attorney who knew only to viciously attack the young woman his client had raped. Now Mr. Araiza’s life is forever scarred too. Perhaps this is the self-inflicted justice he deserves."