IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Prosecution Rests in Fatal Porch Shooting of Renisha McBride

Theodore Wafer's defense team challenged Dearborn Heights, Michigan, police on whether they had properly handled the investigation.
Get more newsLiveon

Prosecutors rested their case Wednesday in the murder trial of Theodore Wafer, who shot unarmed Renisha McBride to death on his Detroit-area porch last year, as the defense hammered away at what it suggested was an inadequate investigation.

Wafer, 55, of Dearborn, Michigan, is charged with second-degree murder, but he says he shot McBride, 19, before dawn on Nov. 2 in self-defense. Wafer's lawyers say he felt threatened by the 5-foot-4, 184-pound McBride, who an autopsy found was "extremely" drunk when she knocked on Wafer's door about 4:30 in the morning after she crashed her car.

Defense attorney Cheryl Carpenter contended that Dearborn Heights police Detective Sgt. Stephen Gurka mishandled the investigation because he'd already made up his mind about the case, allowing evidence to get away that could have proven that McBride was trying to break into the home. But on cross-examination Wednesday, Gurka insisted: "It wasn't a whodunit. We had Mr. Wafer saying it was an accident. We had a firearm. We had the victim."