IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

How Hong Kong’s Tiananmen memorials are being erased

The Chinese territory, whose annual vigils marking the 1989 crackdown in Beijing were a symbol of its relative freedoms, may not hold a public commemoration for the first time. 
People hold lighted phones in the Causeway Bay district of Hong Kong last June after police closed Victoria Park, the traditional site of the Chinese territory’s annual Tiananmen vigil.Isaac Lawrence / AFP - Getty Images file

HONG KONG — The Chinese territory of Hong Kong, once the home of the world’s largest June 4 vigil for victims of the 1989 Tiananmen Square crackdown in Beijing, may hold no public commemoration for the first time amid an intensifying assault on the city’s long-held freedoms.

With many of its organizers jailed and a Beijing-imposed national security law creating uncertainty, those who would have attended the annual vigil are being urged to light candles at home instead. 

“The June 4th vigils in Hong Kong have been the core spirit of the city’s decency, humanity,” Wu’er Kaixi, a leader of the Tiananmen protest movement who now lives in Taiwan, told NBC News. But they have also been “a thorn in the eyes of Beijing.” 

Arresting the organizers is the ruling Chinese Communist Party’s attempt to “put that (spirit) in prison,” Kaixi said. 

Stamping out a movement

For 30 years, thousands of people would solemnly file into Hong Kong’s Victoria Park every June 4, lighting candles and listening to emotional speeches about the Chinese military assault on pro-democracy protesters in and around Tiananmen Square, in which hundreds and perhaps thousands were killed. (The Chinese government has acknowledged that people were killed in what it calls “counterrevolutionary turmoil.”)

The vigils — which would be impossible to hold in mainland China, where most discussion of the Tiananmen protests is banned — were seen as a symbol of the freedoms Hong Kong was guaranteed for 50 years when the former British colony was returned to Chinese rule in 1997, including freedom of expression and assembly. 

In 2019, the 30th anniversary of the crackdown, turnout at the June 4 vigil was especially large — organizers estimated 180,000 people attended, while police put the crowd at 37,000. The vigil came less than a week before the start of anti-government protests that roiled the city for months until the start of the pandemic.

Hong Kong officials banned the vigil in 2020 and 2021, citing pandemic restrictions on public gatherings. In 2020, thousands defied the ban to gather at Victoria Park anyway, with at least two dozen activists later sentenced to up to 15 months in prison for organizing, taking part in or inciting participation in the vigil. Last year, police blocked off the park entirely, though smaller, more mobile protests still took place. 

Image: andlelight vigil at Victoria Park
Organizers said there were record crowds at Victoria Park in 2019, the 30th anniversary of the Tiananmen crackdown.Philip Fong / AFP via Getty Images file
Image: Protesters hold their candles during a moment of silence
Thousands defied a ban to gather for the Tiananmen vigil in 2020. Tang Yan / LightRocket via Getty images
Image: Hong Kong Police Bans Annual Tiananmen Vigil For The Second Straight Year
Lights illuminate the closed-off soccer pitches at Victoria Park on June 4, 2021. Justin Chin / Bloomberg via Getty Images

Since then, efforts to stamp out Tiananmen commemorations have only accelerated. 

The city’s June 4th Museum, which had already been forced to close, was raided in September by national security police who carried away boxes of exhibits. Access to its website was blocked in Hong Kong, which unlike mainland China has a relatively unrestricted internet. 

Leaders of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, the group behind the vigils as well as the museum, were arrested under the national security law, which Beijing imposed in 2020 in response to the 2019 protests. Facing growing legal pressure, the group voted to disband in September.

In December, the University of Hong Kong removed a Tiananmen memorial sculpture that had stood on campus for more than 20 years. Three other universities quickly followed suit, removing their own Tiananmen artwork.

Even an episode of “The Simpsons” with a Tiananmen reference is inaccessible in Hong Kong on the Disney+ streaming service.

And last week, the Roman Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong canceled its annual Tiananmen memorial Mass, citing concerns about the national security law.

Asked whether residents would face legal consequences if they gathered at Victoria Park on Saturday, Carrie Lam, Hong Kong’s departing chief executive, said any public activity in Hong Kong must be conducted in accordance with the law.

“As far as any gathering is concerned, there are a lot of legal requirements,” she said at a news conference Tuesday, citing the national security law, social distancing rules and the need for permission from the venue owner. 

Current pandemic restrictions in Hong Kong cap public gatherings at four people. At a news conference on Thursday, a top police official warned the public: “Do not try to challenge the law’s bottom line.”

On Friday, the government announced that part of Victoria Park, including the soccer pitches where the vigils are usually held, would be closed from 11 p.m. that night until early on June 5, “in order to prevent any unauthorized assemblies.”

‘No regrets’

The Tiananmen demonstrations in 1989 had a profound impact on Hong Kong, which was still a British colony at the time but was preparing for its return to Chinese rule.

“I consider June 4th coverage war reporting,” said S.K. Yip, a videographer from Hong Kong who took a wider version of the famous “Tank Man” photo. “While I did not see people getting shot in front of me, I saw lots of blood on victims. … It was definitely shocking to me.”

Also on the scene was Lee Cheuk-yan, co-founder of the Hong Kong Alliance and a member of the city’s Legislative Council for more than 20 years.

Like many of Hong Kong’s democracy activists, Lee is now in prison, after being convicted in multiple cases stemming from the 2019 protests as well as his role in the banned 2020 vigil.

Image: Lee Cheuk-yan
Lee Cheuk-yan, a leader of the group that organized the Tiananmen vigils, has been charged under a national security law imposed by Beijing.Kin Cheung / AP file

He has also been charged under the national security law along with fellow Alliance leaders Albert Ho and Chow Hang-tung.

The vaguely written security law, which Beijing says was necessary to restore order after the sometimes-violent protests, criminalizes secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign forces. Lee, 65; Ho, 70; and Chow, 37, have been charged with “incitement to subversion,” which could carry a 10-year sentence.

Speaking in court last year, Lee said that he had “no regrets” and that “if I must go to jail to affirm my will, then so be it.”

He said the vigils symbolized “the struggle of memory against forgetting.”

“The people of Hong Kong who took part needed no person or organization to incite them,” he said. “If there was a provocateur, it is the regime that fired at its own people.”

An attack on artwork

Late one night just before Christmas, while students were on winter break, workmen and security personnel at the University of Hong Kong erected yellow barricades around a 26-foot, 2-ton copper sculpture and started drilling.

The blood-orange sculpture, a monument to Tiananmen victims called the Pillar of Shame, is a tower of human torsos twisted together in anguish. It had been at the university since 1998, when the student union voted to permanently display it on campus. It was carted away in two pieces.

In a statement at the time, the university said that it had never given permission for the sculpture to be displayed on campus and that there were concerns it could pose safety issues.

“The decision on the aged statue was based on external legal advice and risk assessment for the best interest of the university,” the university said.

Image: Pillar of Shame
The Pillar of Shame, left, a sculpture commemorating victims of the Tiananmen Square crackdown, at the University of Hong Kong in October 2021 and the same site, right, after the sculpture was removed. Peter Parks / AFP - Getty Images

Within days, the Chinese University of Hong Kong and City University of Hong Kong had ordered the removal of Goddess of Democracy statues on their campuses, while Lingnan University removed a Tiananmen relief sculpture. 

Jens Galschiot, the Danish artist who created the Pillar of Shame, said its removal was “a quite brutal thing to do.”

He is now trying to retrieve the sculpture from storage, but is unwilling to travel to Hong Kong himself unless authorities guarantee he won’t be arrested. A dozen local transport companies have refused to help him, though he said there appeared to be no opposition from the university or authorities in Hong Kong or mainland China.

“It is my clear feeling that the rejections are rooted in uncertainty,” Galschiot said in an open letter in April, “because everyone in Hong Kong is insecure about what the future will hold for the city.”

But the sculpture’s removal has also given it new meaning, he said: In addition to Tiananmen victims, it’s now also about the erosion of Hong Kong’s freedoms.

Image: Hong Kong Police Bans Annual Tiananmen Vigil For The Second Straight Year
Police prepare to detain people near Victoria Park last June. Paul Yeung / Bloomberg via Getty Images file

A full-scale replica of the sculpture was unveiled last week at the University of Oslo in Norway, where it will be on display for a month. Galschiot said he had also received offers to display the sculpture in the United States, Britain, Canada, Denmark and Taiwan.

Galschiot has also released his copyright on the sculpture to allow others to make 3-D copies. “Instead of one sculpture in Hong Kong they don’t like in China, they now have thousands and thousands of sculptures around the world,” he said.

So far, over 3,000 people have downloaded an open-source 3-D model of the work provided by an online group called LadyLibertyHK.

Alex Lee, an artist and activist from Hong Kong who is a member of the group, said Tiananmen memorials would continue overseas.

“People can’t go to Victoria Park anymore for vigils, but people can still commemorate the victims through painting, creative projects and small gatherings,” he said. “With 3-D printing, more people can join this campaign. We want the custom to go on — Hong Kongers kept it going for over 30 years.”