Influential Iranians break ranks with state after Ukrainian jet downing
"Apologies for lying to you for 13 years," said a state TV host, announcing on Instagram that she was quitting.
Kimia Alizadeh, pictured celebrating her bronze medal in taekwondo at the Summer Olympic Games in Rio de Janeiro in 2016, posted an attack on the "hypocrisy" of the Iranian government. Laurence Griffiths / Getty Images file
Breaking News Emails
Get breaking news alerts and special reports. The news and stories that matter, delivered weekday mornings.
"Apologies for lying to you for 13 years," Gelareh Jabbari, a host on the state-run Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting TV network, wrote last Monday in an Instagram post. The post has since been deleted, but it was seen by NBC News.
The prominent movie director Masoud Kimiai and the popular actors Navid Mohamadzadeh and Taraneh Alidoosti were among several filmmakers, actors and musicians who announced that they were boycotting the coming Fajr film and theater festivals.
In a statement picked up by the liberal newspaper Arman Melli, they were among 14 directors, actors and musicians who offered their condolences to those who lost relatives.
According to the newspaper, the statement also criticized the authorities and demanded that they explain the delay in admitting responsibility.
Alidoosti, one of Iran's most popular actors, who starred in the Oscar-nominated "The Salesman," told her 5.8 million followers on Instagram this month that "we are not citizens, we are captives, millions of captives." The post was also seen by NBC News before it was deleted.
Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.
The government's handling of the incident has served only to "confirm an existing sense of moral bankruptcy that the Islamic Republic is accused of," said Afshin Shahi, an associate professor of Middle East politics at Bradford University in England.
"The Islamic Republic is facing the worst legitimacy crisis in its 40-year history, and the pressures are mounting from every angle," he said, adding that state repression, censorship and the country's economic woes in the last three years had created a profound sense of disillusionment. "The gap between the state and society has widened to an extreme extent."
In a sign of how seriously Iranian authorities are taking the backlash, the country's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, delivered a sermon at last week's Friday prayers praising recent strikes on Iraqi bases hosting U.S. forces.
The last time Khamenei spoke at the service was eight years ago to mark the annual 10 days of celebrations of the 1979 revolution that overthrew Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi.
As for allegations of repression, Alireza Miryousefi, a spokesman for Iran's mission to the United Nations, said: "Iranian citizens are free to express their opinions, as has been witnessed over the last months. And they are free to seek or refuse employment as they wish."
"It is only natural that in a nation of over 80 million people, there will always be a wide range of opinions," he added. "In recent days, the government has very clearly and repeatedly apologized in the aftermath of the Ukrainian Airlines tragedy. The government has also pledged a full investigation and to hold those responsible to account for this mistake."
Over the decades, sporadic unrest has often been met with a harsh response.
In 2009, the government suppressed the so-called Green Movement, which drew millions of people to the streets in the wake of a disputed presidential election.
But protests in Iran have become more frequent and widespread over the past two years. They have coincided with harsh economic sanctions imposed by the United States after President Donald Trump pulled the United States out of the landmark Iran nuclear deal in May 2018.
The protests over the airliner, however, are "a watershed moment," said Hadi Ghaemi, executive director of the New York-based Center for Human Rights in Iran, who said the downing of the Ukrainian airliner had "become a national symbol of what Iranians suffer daily from government forces and the bureaucracy."
"People are completely fed up with the political system and the repression and, especially in this case, the lies, cover-up and incompetence of their government," said Ghaemi, whose nonprofit seeks to document rights abuses in Iran.
The artistic boycott of the Fajr festivals and Alidoosti's comments were examples of an "unprecedented" level of consensus among members of the artistic community in Iran who are disillusioned and frustrated with the Iranian state, said Shahi, the Bradford University professor.
Traditionally, critics in Iran have made a distinction between hard-liners and more moderate members of the establishment, Shahi said. But that appears to be changing.
"What is interesting is that they have gone beyond the factional politics of the Islamic Republic and criticize the entirety of the system," Shahi said.
And then there are those who have defected in recent months.
Kimia Alizadeh, 21, who became the only woman from Iran to win an Olympic medal when she took bronze in taekwondo at the 2016 Summer Games in Rio de Janeiro, posted a scathing attack on Instagram about the "hypocrisy" of Iran's administration. She implied that she had left the country but did not say where to.
In December, Iran's Chess Federation said top-rated champion Alireza Firouzja had decided not to play for Iran over its informal ban on competing against Israeli players. And three months earlier, the International Judo Federation said Iranian judoka Saeid Mollaei had refused to return home over fears for his safety.
Chris Doyle, director of the Council for Arab-British Understanding, a nonprofit activist group, said that it wasn't just widely known Iranians who had defected and that the brain drain was well established in Iran and across the Middle East.
"These tend to be people such as doctors and lawyers on the wealthier end of the spectrum with the ability to do so," he said.
But working-class Iranians have also voiced their discontent, and Shahi said many were also leaving, which he described as "muscle drain."
"Iran is suffering from the politics of hopelessness," he said.
CORRECTION (Monday, Jan. 20, 2020, 12:35 a.m. ET): An earlier version of this article misstated the date a Ukrainian jetliner was shot down after takeoff from Tehran. It was shot down on Jan. 8, not Jan. 15.