IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Sen. Collins' Democratic rival portrays her in debate as in pocket of Trump, McConnell

The Republican incumbent is regarded as one of the most endangered GOP lawmakers in November.
Image: Susan Collins
Senator Susan Collins after the weekly Republican Party caucus luncheon at the U.S. Capitol on Feb. 26, 2019.Jonathan Ernst / Reuters file

PORTLAND, Maine — Republican U.S. Sen. Susan Collins and her Democratic opponent Sara Gideon sparred on health care and the nation’s coronavirus response during a Thursday debate that saw the two candidates heavily criticize each other’s records in office.

Collins, a 24-year senator, and Gideon, the speaker of the Maine House of Representatives, are in a heated, expensive race that could help determine control of the U.S. Senate.

Both candidates were on the offensive Thursday, with Collins criticizing Gideon for the Maine Legislature’s failure to meet since March and Gideon portraying Collins as beholden to Republican President Donald Trump and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell.

"We do have a judiciary that has been politicized. President Trump had a concerted and successful effort to move the judiciary to the right," Gideon said, according to News Center Maine. "He has done that with the help of Mitch McConnell and with the help of Susan Collins. Those 181 judicial nominees that she chose to confirm, some of them were rated unqualified by the American Bar Association and some of them came with distinct social and political agendas."

Gideon also charged Collins with jeopardizing the Affordable Care Act.

“Right now we need leadership at the federal level and we need to know that no matter what happens to the Affordable Care Act, we have a Congress that is actually going to protect and expand people’s health care,” Gideon said, according to the Portland Press Herald. “Mitch McConnell and Susan Collins have said there is no plan in place even as that lawsuit moves to oral arguments the week after Election Day.”

When Gideon touted the possibility of a public option for health coverage, Collins described that as a “first step toward a government takeover of our healthcare.”

The Maine Republican also blasted her challenger for legislative inaction.

“The legislature has been out of session since March, and she has done nothing,” Collins said after touting her own work in support of the Paycheck Protection Program.

Gideon responded that Maine has a lower rate of coronavirus cases than most of the country and the state’s economy hasn’t suffered as much as others.

“Neither of those things is an accident,” Gideon said. “That’s in direct contrast to the lack of leadership from the federal government. I am proud of us coming together.”

Independent candidates Max Linn and Lisa Savage also participated in the debate. Savage, a Maine Green Independent Party member running as an independent, advocated for “Medicare For All” and bold climate action during the debate.

Linn, a conservative activist, portrayed himself as an outsider not beholden to political parties. His behavior attracted attention in previous debates in which he cut up a mask in protest of coronavirus-inspired facial covering requirements and used profanity on air.

Maine Public hosted Thursday’s debate, which was the third featuring the four candidates. The race is one of a handful of pivotal contests — including others in Iowa, North Carolina, Arizona and elsewhere — that are likely to decide control of the Senate. It’s also the most expensive race in Maine’s history, with Collins and Gideon raising more than $40 million between them.

The tight race with Gideon is an unfamiliar position for Collins, who has typically cruised to reelection in previous bids. Democrats and liberal groups mounted a campaign to unseat Collins after her vote to confirm Justice Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court in 2018.

Collins, however, is the only Senate Republican to say she will not vote to confirm Trump's current Supreme Court nominee, Amy Coney Barrett, given the proximity to Election Day.

The senator's stance prompted Trump to lash out at her on Friday.

"Well, she didn’t support Healthcare or my opening up 5000 square miles of Ocean to Maine, so why should this be any different. Not worth the work!" Trump tweeted.

Linn and Savage are longshot candidates, but they could factor heavily in the outcome because of ranked choice voting. Because voters can rank all four candidates, second and third choices could come into play if no candidate cracks 50% of the total votes cast. Most polls show a close race between Collins and Gideon, so it’s possible the ranked votes could make a difference.

Maine is the only state in the U.S. that uses the voting method to elect U.S. senators.