A Bush is running in a Trump-love primary and the race is getting ugly
Walker Stapleton's familial relation to the Bush dynasty would be an asset in another era. But in Colorado's GOP contest for governor on Tuesday, the president reigns supreme.
State Treasurer and Republican gubernatorial candidate Walker Stapleton, a Bush cousin, delivers a speech during the Colorado Republican State Assembly in Boulder, Colorado, on April 14, 2018.Hyoung Chang / Denver Post via Getty Images
Breaking News Emails
Get breaking news alerts and special reports. The news and stories that matter, delivered weekday mornings.
WASHINGTON — Bush has become a four-letter word in this contest.
In Colorado, where the GOP will select its gubernatorial nominee Tuesday, a Bush cousin is finding that his ties to the family that once defined Republican politics have tripped him up in a party increasingly defined by a new family — the Trump family.
The frontrunner, state Treasurer Walker Stapleton, shares more than a name with George Herbert Walker and George Walker Bush, who headlined a fundraiser for the candidate in February.
Stapleton is a cousin of both former presidents, got married at the family's compound in Kennebunkport, Maine, and his campaign and super PAC have accepted close to $30,000 from a dozen different Bushes, including Jeb and his wife, Columba.
Former state legislator Victor Mitchell, who polls place in second behind Stapleton, has hammered the Bush connection on the campaign trail and in TV, radio and digital ads.
"Walker Stapleton claims he's a Trump guy. But Stapleton's a Bush cousin, taking big bucks from the Trump-hating Bush family network," says the narrator of one Mitchell radio ad.
A web ad goes further, depicting two tennis-playing country club stereotypes scheming about their plans to elect Stapleton. "Don't vote for a Bush insider," the ad concludes as the players, wearing all white outfits, laugh maniacally.
Steve Barlock, who co-chaired Donald Trump's presidential campaign in Colorado and ran for governor himself before being eliminated at the party convention, said the Bush name is "a huge liability" with Trump voters.
"It's just the numbers," Barlock said, citing a poll showing 86 percent of Colorado Republicans approve of the president. "If you tie anybody to Bush, that's anti-Trump."
Stapleton's troubles come as the Trump-Bush family feud has heated up recently — Donald Trump Jr. just canceled a fundraiser with George P. Bush, who is running for reelection as Texas land commissioner; President Trump is bragged recently about beating "the Bush Dynasty"; and Laura Bush condemned the Trump administration earlier this week for separating undocumented immigrant families at the border.
Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.
After Rep. Mark Sanford's recent defeat in a Republican primary in South Carolina — whom the president opposed — it's another sign that Trump has become the alpha and omega of today's GOP.
Stapleton's father, who comes from a different political family, was a co-owner of the Texas Rangers with George W. Bush and later won a plum appointment as Bush's ambassador to France.
But as Stapleton's GOP rivals attack him in TV ads for "taking big money from the Bush Never-Trump Network," he’s found himself running from the Bushes and toward Trump — just as his cousin George P. Bush did earlier this year in his GOP primary.
There's been no reconciliation between the families since Trump's brutal primary campaign against "low energy" Jeb two years ago (Exhibit A: Trump skipped Barbara Bush's funeral in April "out of respect for the Bush family.")
George P. Bush was the only Bush to endorse Trump in 2016, and Trump returned the favor earlier this year. But now even that relationship appears to be on the rocks after Jeb, George's father, slammed Trump's family family separation policy.
Children shouldn’t be used as a negotiating tool. @realDonaldTrump should end this heartless policy and Congress should get an immigration deal done that provides for asylum reform, border security and a path to citizenship for Dreamers. https://t.co/OOjv0vNeVg
Cinamon Watson, a Colorado Republican strategist, doubts the attacks will resonate with GOP voters or stop Stapleton on Tuesday.
"He established himself as the front-runner early on and so far nobody has been able to put a mark on him," she said, adding that Colorado Republicans still admire the Bushes. "I think people look back on those years fondly. Nostalgia will reign supreme."
Still, it's remarkable that connections to Republican presidents who won Colorado three times (twice for George W. Bush and once for George HW Bush) have become anything but an asset in a GOP primary.
Greg Lopez, another candidate in the gubernatorial primary, has told voters, "I'm grassroots. I don't come from the high Bush family."
Ironically, Mitchell, who has led the anti-Bush crusade, didn't even vote Trump. And his Bush attacks may be an attempt to shift the focus off that as much as anything else. Meanwhile, a fourth candidate in the race, investment banker Doug Robinson, is a nephew of Mitt Romney.
"All the Trump people know none of (the candidates) supported Trump, but now they're all trying to get the support of the Trump people," Barlock said.
When it comes to the Bushes, Stapleton has ignored questions, declined an invitation to call himself a "George Bush Republican," and said he thinks "labels are hogwash and a bunch of political bull that don’t mean anything."
"I also happen to be related to Chris Stapleton, the country music performer who sells out Red Rocks. Just because he's my second cousin doesn’t mean that I sing like him," he told the Villager.
And in a statement to NBC News, Stapleton said he's focused on the state: "People support my campaign because they know I'm a commonsense Colorado conservative."
At the same time, he's played up his alignment with Trump — and hit Mitchell for not backing the president.
A new TV ad out Tuesday focuses on the danger of sanctuary cities. "I'll stand with Donald Trump to get illegal aliens who commit crimes deported," Stapleton says to the camera. And a mailer from Stapleton’s campaign says he "helped President Trump pass tax reform," while Mitchell "campaigned against President Trump."
At a GOP event in January, Stapleton invited the audience to Google everything he's said about Trump, saying, "You will not find one disparaging comment I've made."
Democrats have their own contentious primary on Tuesday, but most analysts expect Rep. Jared Polis will emerge as his party's nominee to replace term-limited Democratic Gov. John Hickenlooper.
Republicans think Polis is too liberal even for an increasingly progressive state, and some think the Bush brand could end up helping Stapleton with moderate voters.
Steve House, the former chairman of the Colorado Republican Party, said he's winced at the personal tone of the attacks on a family that proudly served the country, but can see the political logic.
"The people beating him up about it are probably counting on a lower turnout, which would consist more of a grassroots conservative group," House said. "(But) most rational Republicans in Colorado just look at it and say, 'Am I responsible for everything my brothers and sisters do?' No, of course not."