Connecticut investigates HUD-funded landlord who rented infested homes to poor families
Connecticut's attorney general said his investigation was prompted by the federal government's failure to swiftly protect tenants.
In July 2017, Joshua Serrano, center, a tenant at the Clay Arsenal Renaissance Apartments, took part in a community meeting at Shiloh Baptist Church in Hartford to call attention to Emmanuel Ku, then the owner of the Clay Arsenal complex. Monica Jorge / Hartford Courant / Tribune News Service via Getty Images file
Breaking News Emails
Get breaking news alerts and special reports. The news and stories that matter, delivered weekday mornings.
Connecticut's attorney general is investigating a private landlord for sheltering poor families in federally subsidized housing infested with rats and covered in mold. The investigation, a rare move by a state's top prosecutor, was prompted in part by the federal government's failure to act swiftly and forcefully to protect tenants, his office said.
"State AGs are stepping in where the federal government has not acted or is unable to act, whether it's litigation on gun violence, on the environment, on climate, on health care," Attorney General William Tong, a Democrat, told NBC News. "This is another area in which we are stepping up and taking responsibility."
Connecticut's investigation focuses on Emmanuel Ku's failure to repair and maintain a 150-unit housing complex in Hartford known as the Clay Arsenal Renaissance Apartments, where families lived amid rodent infestations, mold, broken windows and inoperable smoke detectors, among other threats to their health and safety, according to federal records.
The attorney general's office estimates that Ku, who has a New York-based property management company, received at least $1 million a year in federal subsidies for the Hartford property from 2011 to 2018, when the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, or HUD, ended the contract. He sold the complex in late 2018 for $8.5 million, more than three times what he paid originally following a 2009 foreclosure auction for the property.
The attorney general's office is seeking Ku's tax returns and financial records, maintenance and repair records, and other documents to determine whether he violated the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices Act, which prohibits unfair and deceptive business practices.
State attorneys general rarely focus on cases of substandard housing conditions, which are typically relegated to local governments or to HUD, for those involving federally subsidized properties, according to tenant legal advocates. Connecticut says it's the first time that its attorney general has pursued such an investigation of a landlord.
Tong said he would consider suing Ku if he does not cooperate with the investigation.
Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.
Ku did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
"Emmanuel Ku bought Clay Arsenal at a rock bottom price, and extracted millions in federal and local subsidies based on unfulfilled promises to provide safe, affordable housing for vulnerable Hartford residents," Tong said in a statement announcing the investigation, set to be released Wednesday. "He let those properties rot, and subjected his tenants — who had little to no ability to leave — to dangerous, uninhabitable conditions."
HUD requires all federally subsidized housing to be "decent, safe and sanitary." The agency regularly inspects properties and can take swift enforcement action when landlords fail to fix problems.
But despite such federal protections, HUD did not act against Ku until tenants mounted a yearlong public campaign in 2017, the attorney general's office said.
Rhonda Siciliano, a spokesperson for HUD, said: "HUD desires for all of its affiliated properties to be maintained in decent, safe and sanitary condition and welcomes the efforts of state and local governments to assist in that goal."
But HUD still approved Ku's federal contract for Clay Arsenal in 2011, only to find rampant health and safety violations at the property years later. Even after Ku failed to fix serious deficiencies in the complex in 2017, HUD continued to give him monthslong extensions to make repairs, the Hartford Courant reported. Similar problems plagued a HUD complex in Hartford owned by another private landlord that NBC News investigated in 2018.
Tenants at Clay Arsenal began mobilizing in 2017, organizing public rallies and demanding meetings with HUD and local officials.
"It was the worst living conditions that I had ever experienced — mold, mildew, roach and rat infestations, rotten floorboards," said Joshua Serrano, a former tenant. "When HUD got confronted with resident leaders like myself, they didn't know what to do."
In May 2018, after nearly a year of public pressure, HUD announced that it was canceling its contract with Ku given the property's "major threats to health and safety" and said it would give tenants vouchers to relocate.
HUD had to abide by the terms of its contract with Ku or face potential litigation, and it granted him "reasonable extensions" to fix deficiencies, Siciliano said. "When it became apparent that progress was not satisfactory, the contract was abated and the residents relocated."
Ku is still doing business with HUD: He owns a federally subsidized apartment complex in Steubenville, Ohio, that has a federal contract running through May, according to federal data. The property received a high score of 97 out of 100 during its last HUD inspection in 2015, according to federal records.
In another recent case, Josh Hawley, a Republican U.S. senator who was Missouri's attorney general at the time, sued a St. Louis housing authority for failing to fix serious health and safety violations in a HUD housing complex. The lawsuit was settled last year after the management spent more than $300,000 cleaning up mold, mice and insect infestations.
Despite a growing number of properties that are failing inspection, HUD has been subject to staff cuts for years, and agency officials have admitted that they don't have the resources to closely monitor the subsidized properties where more than 4.6 million low-income families live, the 2018 NBC News investigation found.
"It shouldn't require resident mobilizing, legal service assistance and an AG investigation to ensure a modicum of decent living standards in HUD properties," said Diane Yentel, president and chief executive of the National Low Income Housing Coalition, an advocacy group based in Washington. "It reflects the poor job that HUD has done in enforcing housing standards for its properties."
Suzy Khimm is a national reporter for NBC News, focused on investigating federal agencies.
Laura Strickler is an investigative producer in the NBC News Investigative Unit based in Washington.