IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Court rules Virginia House race is tied, winner to be picked 'by lot'

A Democrat's stunning one-vote victory over a Republican in the hotly contested race for the Virginia House of Delegates earlier this week became a tie on Wednesday after a three-judge panel ruled on a single ballot should have counted for the Republican, placing control of the House back in play.
Image: recount the ballots during the Newport News 94th district recount
Workers start to remove boxes from a storage room to recount the ballots during the Newport News 94th district recount on Dec. 19, 2017 at City Center in Newport News, Virginia. Officials will use a high-speed machine on to recount results from the 94th District House of Delegates race, which incumbent Republican Del. David Yancey won by 10 votes. Democratic challenger Shelly Simonds requested the recount.Joe Fudge / The Daily Press via AP

Grasping at straws is one way to win an election, at least in Virginia.

A Democrat's stunning one-vote victory in a hotly contested race for the Virginia House of Delegates this week suddenly became a tie on Wednesday after a three-judge panel ruled that an additional ballot should have been counted for the Republican.

Now, the winner will be determined "by lot," according to state law, and that could mean pulling a name out of a hat, a coin toss — or drawing straws.

The state Board of Elections said it hadn't decided on the next move.

"Once the court has issued a final order, we can better evaluate what next steps are necessary for the State Board of Elections or Department of Elections to take," said Department of Elections Commissioner Edgardo Cortes.

On Wednesday, Democrat Shelly Simonds was declared the apparent winner in the race for the 94th District, beating incumbent Republican David Yancey after a wild recount had Simonds ahead by one vote, flipped a red seat to blue, and created a 50-50 tie between the two parties in the Virginia House.

She won by 11,608 to 11,607, according to the nonpartisan Virginia Public Access Project. But the final tally now stands at 11,608 to 11,608.

Gary Anderson, the Newport News Circuit Court clerk, told NBC News that Yancey's camp brought a statement to the judicial hearing on Wednesday from a county official stating that the official had made a mistake by not counting a ballot during the recount.

The ballot in question had a bubble filled in for Ed Gillespie, the Republican who lost the governor's race in November, Simonds and Yancey. However, the bubble for Gillespie had an X mark and the bubble for Simonds had a slash-like mark. Anderson said the judges took the filled in bubble for Yancey, which was not crossed out, as intent to vote for him.

James Alcorn, chairman of the state Board of Elections, told The Richmond-Times Dispatch that ties are "rare," but they have been seen in local elections.

"In those situations, the electoral board typically draws names out of a hat. I believe one locality uses an old-fashioned tricorner hat for these occasions," Alcorn told the paper. "The State Board typically draws names out of a glass bowl when we're picking the order of candidates for the ballot."

Anderson said he does not know for sure if it's a landmark case, but added that he has never seen anything like it.

"Personally, I know of nothing in history like this," he said. "Several people I've chatted with think this is precedent-setting."