IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Why Calling 911 On Your Cell is Not Always a Good Idea

When the good guys on TV want to find someone,they instantly locate that person via their cellphone signal. In real life, it's not quite so easy.
We apologize, this video has expired.
Get more newsLiveonNBC News Now
/ Source:

You feel safe having that cellphone with you. If there's ever an emergency — no matter where you are — you can call 911 for help.

Unfortunately, that sense of security is partly an illusion.

Your wireless device has a big limitation: It doesn't give the 911 operator your exact location. So if you can't talk — which is often the case in a medical emergency or a crime in progress — it may be difficult or impossible for emergency responders to find you in time.

"It's a public safety hazard that is largely unrecognized," said Jamie Barnett, director of the Find Me 911 Coalition. "People's lives are at risk right now because they cannot count on 911 being able to find them when they call from a cell phone."

On TV crime dramas, when the good guys want to find someone, they simply go to their computers and instantly locate that person via their cellphone signal. In real life, it's not quite so easy.

If you're outdoors, and your phone's GPS chip can connect with satellites above or the phone hits a series of cell towers on the ground, the 911 operator will know your latitude and longitude—within 50 meters or so—most of the time.

Read More: Data at risk as Americans don't protect smartphones

But make that emergency call from inside a building — where it's hard for your phone to "see" the satellites and cell signals tend to bounce around a lot — and your location information could be off by 100 meters or more.

"We have to do better," said Todd Piett, chief product officer with Rave Mobile Safety. "In most cities, just a few meters can mean the difference between several buildings and that can be the difference between life and death."

And then there are those unfortunate situations where the location information turns out to be way off.

We apologize, this video has expired.

"We can find out the when, the why and the how once we get there. But we need to know where there is," Souder said.

On June 16, 2013, Mary Thomas was in an apartment on the upper east side of Manhattan when she had a stroke. She was able to call 911, but her speech was slurred and she couldn't tell the dispatcher where she was. Because she was inside a high rise, the location information provided by the cell tower was way off.

It took nearly eight hours to find her. Remarkably, Thomas was still alive when medics arrived and she was rushed to the hospital.

Read More: Cell phone thefts soar as advocates hail 'kill switch'

This is an extreme example, but far from an isolated case. The Find Me 911 Coalition recently surveyed emergency dispatchers in all 50 states and found that most (82 percent) do not have a great deal of confidence in the location data automatically displayed for wireless calls. More than half (54 percent) said that information is regularly inaccurate.

The problem is only going to get worse

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) estimates that more than 70 percent of all calls to 911 centers now come from wireless phones — that's more than 400,000 calls a day. The majority of these calls (64 percent) are made indoors. And these numbers are sure to go up as even more people pull the plug on their land-line phone service at home.

The FCC has heard the complaints—and the horror stories—and has acknowledged the potential threat to public safety. In a speech last year, FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel said that "if you call 911 from a wireless phone indoors, cross your fingers, because FCC location standards for emergency calls do not apply indoors."

"In most cities, just a few meters can mean the difference between several buildings and that can be the difference between life and death."

The FCC has proposed rules to require more accurate location information for emergency wireless calls made indoors: accurate within 50 meters of the phone 67 percent of the time within two years, and 80 percent of the time in five years. The rules would also require vertical location information—for those in multiple-story building — within three years.

In its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, he commission stated that the improvements it's considering could save approximately 10,000 lives each year.

CTIA — The Wireless Association says it supports the idea of better location technology, but disagrees with the FCC's proposed rules.

Brian Josef, CTIA's assistant vice president for regulatory affairs, said indoor locations pose some real challenges and the proposed rules lay out an unrealistically short timeline to solve them.

Read more: How the 'one ring scam' can cost you money

"The FCC needs to evaluate before they regulate," Josef said. "We are improving the technology and we want to continue working on that. But before you set rules that can't be met, let's first identify verified technologies that can improve indoor location and let's go forward from there."

The FCC is accepting public comments on its proposed rules until May 12.

— Herb Weisbaum, CNBC

Follow Herb Weisbaum on Facebook and Twitter @TheConsumerman or visit The ConsumerMan website.