But we are seeing signs of shifting attitudes. When the Cubs traded for Chapman in July 2016, the backlash was relatively muted. Just two years later, the Astros' acquisition of Roberto Osuna has landed Astros general manager Jeff Luhnow in much more hot water. (Osuna was charged with domestic violence earlier this year and is currently suspended by MLB; his trial is ongoing.) Some Houston fans have gone so far to say they will no longer cheer for the team. The Astros were hammered in particular for claiming to have a “zero tolerance” policy on domestic violence when they obviously do not have such a policy. It has been a disaster and Osuna’s suspension isn’t even over yet.
The broader #MeToo movement and social media generally has changed the way the sports world discuss these issues. But what is perhaps more telling is how institutions and leagues have recently attempted to adjust their policies. Had the Braves tried to fire Bobby Cox two decades ago, they would likely have been severely criticized. But today, Meyer went from one of the most powerful figures in collegiate athletics to a toxic figure in the span of an afternoon. His life’s work, his status as one of the most revered, celebrated figures in college athletics is in jeopardy.
If Ohio State eventually fires him — and it is beginning to feel a bit more like when than if — he may never get a high-profile job in the sport again. (Alternatively, he could rehabilitate his career and stage a comeback, as we have seen with coaches like current Penn State coach James Franklin.) Whatever happens, however, Meyer’s punishment does not erase the many men who went unpunished before him.
In a deeply moving essay in “Baseball Prospectus” about the Osuna trade, writer Rachel MacDaniel noted that young pitcher’s suspension essentially benefitted the Astros, the team that traded for him, because it resulted in a sort of domestic violence discount. The same “grotesque” calculus was applied when the Cubs traded for Aroldis Chapman, MacDaniel argued. (It is particularly odd that players who test positive for performance enhancing drugs aren’t allowed to participate in the postseason, but Osuna will be able to play for Houston.) But as MacDaniel also notes, “We have to talk about this. We have to keep talking about it until something changes. Baseball, through its callous, greed-driven mismanagement of the situation, has given us the opportunity to talk about this.”
We are talking about it now, although assuredly not enough. This is small progress. It is insufficient progress. But it is still progress. Atlanta built Bobby Cox a statue. Will there be statues built for Urban Meyer?
Will Leitch is a national correspondent for MLB, contributing editor at New York Magazine, host of “The Will Leitch Show” on Sports Illustrated and the founder of Deadspin.