Image: Paul
Ed Reinke  /  AP
Republican U.S. Senate candidate Rand Paul speaks during a campaign rally in Erlanger, Ky., Saturday, July 10.
updated 7/13/2010 9:09:46 AM ET 2010-07-13T13:09:46

Republican U.S. Senate candidate Rand Paul says the poor in America are "enormously better off than the rest of the world," citing an old Cold War film that showed even impoverished homes had color televisions.

Paul's recent remarks at his first forum with Democratic opponent Jack Conway stirred some anger in impoverished pockets of Kentucky, where as many as a third of residents live in poverty.

The libertarian-leaning Paul addressed the issue of poverty by alluding to a decades-old, anti-American propaganda film by the Soviet government designed to criticize the free-market system.

"They filmed a building in the poorer section of New York with some broken windows and they said, 'Oh, this is how the poor in America lives,'" Paul said at last week's forum. "But it backfired on them because the Soviet citizens looked at that video closely and they saw flickering color television sets in all those windows."

Paul went on to say that "the poor in our country are enormously better off than the rest of the world. It doesn't mean we can't do better. But we have to acknowledge and be proud of our system of capitalism."

Conway did not respond directly to Paul's comments about poverty, but told the audience he thinks Kentucky's best days are ahead. He said he supports small business tax credits and other measures to boost job creation.

Charles Hardin, a Democratic judge-executive from eastern Kentucky's Magoffin County, said Monday that Paul's comments rubbed him the wrong way and he criticized Paul for relying on "anecdotal tales."

"I think it reflects a dogmatic belief in free enterprise and limited government," said Hardin, who argued that government should reach out to assist those who can't help themselves.

Kentucky ranks among the poorest states in the country. The state tied for second poorest nationally with 17.3 percent of its residents living below the poverty level, according to the most recent U.S. Census Bureau figures.

Knott County Judge-Executive Randy Thompson, a Republican, said Monday he wasn't uncomfortable with Paul's comments about the poor, and that they reflected the truth.

"I know that as bad as we have it, there are people that have it worse in Third World countries," Thompson said.

  1. Other political news of note
    1. Animated Boehner: 'There's nothing complex about the Keystone Pipeline!'

      House Speaker John Boehner became animated Tuesday over the proposed Keystone Pipeline, castigating the Obama administration for not having approved the project yet.

    2. Budget deficits shrinking but set to grow after 2015
    3. Senate readies another volley on unemployment aid
    4. Obama faces Syria standstill
    5. Fluke files to run in California

Albey Brock, another Republican county judge-executive in the region, said he didn't think Paul meant to be hurtful or disparaging with the remarks.

"Oftentimes his unique way of communicating opens himself to criticism to be taken out of context," said Brock, who backed Paul's main opponent in the primary. "And in this instance, I'm not certain I know what context he meant it in."

Paul campaign manager Jesse Benton said Monday that the Republican has used the anecdote for years "to illustrate the strength of America, the power of our traditions and the superiority of freedom to socialism."

Paul, a Bowling Green eye doctor, drew sharp criticism in late May for saying the Obama administration's stance toward BP after the massive Gulf spill was un-American and anti-business. He drew more heat for expressing misgivings about requiring businesses to comply with the Civil Rights Act.

The Republican candidate also sparked a backlash from some county officials for suggesting at last week's forum that he would prefer to see programs for drug abuse paid for at the local level.

The issue came up in a question about a popular, federally funded task force that does drug investigations and pays for treatment for addicts and education programs in eastern and southern Kentucky.

Pike County Judge-Executive Wayne T. Rutherford, a Democrat, said Monday that the drug problem has become too big for local governments to handle all the costs.

"I think he made a drastic mistake," said Rutherford, predicting that the remarks would ultimately cost Paul votes in the region.

Thompson said he agreed that local communities should tackle their drug problems head on, but said, "We can't do it without the help of the federal government."

Paul said at the forum that he would strive to keep more money in Kentucky to deal with drug problems.

Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Paul criticizes newspapers

  1. Transcript of: Paul criticizes newspapers

    MATTHEWS: rallying cry now of Rand Paul , the Kentucky Senate candidate. He voiced it at an event this Saturday. Let`s watch.

    RAND PAUL (R), KENTUCKY SENATORIAL CANDIDATE: We have to get our policy out there. We`re not going to get a lot of help from the newspapers. We must present our message. We must articulate it. We must not let them describe who we are. We must describe who we are.

    PAUL: There has been a concerted effort since the Tea Party began to rise since my victory to paint us as something we are not. There is nothing about our movement that is really outside of any kind of mainstream.

    MATTHEWS: That`s right. Newspapers do nasty things, like write down and print up what you said last week. You, Dr. Paul , said you had problems with the `64 civil rights bill and how it got enacted. You, Dr. Paul , called White House criticism of BP un-American. How are people to judge you if not by your words? But if you want to speak finish yourself, you have a fresh start here, any time you want it, on HARDBALL . Speaking of Tea Partiers , Michele Bachmann continues to out-crazy even herself. The Minnesota congresswoman who once accused the Obama administration of running a gangster government has kicked up the rhetoric notch. Bachmann said at a conservative gathering in Colorado this past Friday that President Obama is turning the United States into -- quote -- "a nation of slaves." I guess once you get hooked on this stuff, you have to keep upping the dosage. Moving down to South Carolina , Democratic Senate candidate Alvin Greene tells " The New York Times " that the story of his unlikely primary victory has gotten interest from a New York publishing agent and a Hollywood screenwriter. Greene `s actor of choice to play him in a movie, Denzel Washington . Yes, I saw Denzel in "St._Elsewhere," in "Glory," as the great Steve Biko , the South African black consciousness leader. I saw him play Brutus in " Julius Caesar " in New York. I saw him as the lawyer in " Philadelphia ." Let`s see. He also played Malcolm x . So, I don`t blame you, Mr. Greene , for wanting him to play you. My question, Mr. Greene , is, who are


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments